Super Mario 64 DS
So far, this game really is as good as they say, and I've enjoyed it quite a bit. It was a bit strange, starting out with Yoshi and having to unlock Mario, but Yoshi plays pretty well and it feels like the closest we'll ever get to a 3D Yoshi game. I know that the controls were a common complaint for the DS version, but they merely felt, at worst, less fluent than other 3D Mario games. And besides, it's not like the N64 controls have a better reputation. I have 20 Stars so far, including all seven stars in both Bob-omb Battlefield and Whomp's Fortress. I also have ten or so Rec Room keys. Some levels just felt a bit cheap (looking at you, Bowser in the Dark World), but overall, it's been pretty fun. Looking forward to playing more of this legendary classic.