What’s the DARKEST moment in the Mario franchise?

Andy 28!

Male and Mario fan, JESUS IS THE KING!
How many will expect the Mario series isn't known for being dark but it has some moments very dark, and I think it's a moment of Partners in Time or Brothership (spoilers of the game), that trees that drains the live of the Toads shocked me,
IMG_3110.jpeg
IMG_3109.jpeg
but I think it's even darker this:
IMG_3111.webp
IMG_3112.webp
the dream flowers are flowers that trapp you into a fake reality where your dreams come true (like this example of Arc finding his dad on the fake reality) and they even trapped Mario and Luigi, they are in the mushroom kingdom and everything is in peace, but the dark thing on this is that Reclusa made this because in the reality you're going to die of hunger and you never want to escape because is your dreams coming true, the people has to give credit to Brothership of giving us the darkest moment in the franchise. So what you think?
 
in Mario's Time Machine when Bowser steals the completed rabies vaccine from Louis Pasteur and Pierre Roux before it could be industrialized. If Mario had failed to retrieve the vaccine, that would have had some dire ramifications. Objectively both the worst thing that Bowser did and the darkest thing that could have happened in a Mario game because, ignoring the goofiness of a giant dragon turtle wreaking havoc by traveling through time, it entails a realistic scenario of millions of lives lost due to a preventable disease.

in Bananza, K. Rool resorts to terrorism.
 
when did that happen?
In Super Paper Mario Dimentio killed Mario, Luigi, Peach and Bowser and sent them to the underwhere, but I'm agree with Sparks Partners in Time is without question the darkest Mario game, aliens that are dying and they are traveling in time to save his species, maybe this was a trauma for Mario and Luigi seeing that they want to kill them and they have to be saved by his adult versions, but also the chapter 4 of TTYD is dark.
 
In Super Paper Mario Dimentio killed Mario, Luigi, Peach and Bowser and sent them to the underwhere, but I'm agree with Sparks Partners in Time is without question the darkest Mario game, aliens that are dying and they are traveling in time to save his species, maybe this was a trauma for Mario and Luigi seeing that they want to kill them and they have to be saved by his adult versions, but also the chapter 4 of TTYD is dark.
I've heard people say that Mario dies and gets sent to hell in Super Paper Mario a few times, and although that idea is funny as a meme and not entirely inaccurate I'd like to correct the record a bit. First of all, the Underwhere is more of a cross between a parody of the Greek Underworld and the idea of Purgatory, it's not actually the equivalent of hell. Second of all Dimentio doesn't actually kill Mario and co, he just teleports them to the afterlife dimension. If I recall correctly multiple characters in the chapter notice that it's strange that Mario is there when he's not actually dead.
 
I've heard people say that Mario dies and gets sent to hell in Super Paper Mario a few times, and although that idea is funny as a meme and not entirely inaccurate I'd like to correct the record a bit. First of all, the Underwhere is more of a cross between a parody of the Greek Underworld and the idea of Purgatory, it's not actually the equivalent of hell. Second of all Dimentio doesn't actually kill Mario and co, he just teleports them to the afterlife dimension. If I recall correctly multiple characters in the chapter notice that it's strange that Mario is there when he's not actually dead.
Valid point, You got me right there.
 
The Beslan school massacre was a terrorist attack that lasted three days and took 1,100 people hostage (777 children) and resulted in the gruesome deaths of 334 people, 186 of them children. All in all, it is the deadliest school shooting in history.

So, naturally, Nintendo and Bandai Namco used a photograph taken during the crisis as a placeholder image for a Mario Kart game for the arcade.
 
The RPGs are no stranger to darker themes, and you're not wrong...but let's not forget the ending of Galaxy where the universe was reset after the final battle.
 
The Beslan school massacre was a terrorist attack that lasted three days and took 1,100 people hostage (777 children) and resulted in the gruesome deaths of 334 people, 186 of them children. All in all, it is the deadliest school shooting in history.

So, naturally, Nintendo and Bandai Namco used a photograph taken during the crisis as a placeholder image for a Mario Kart game for the arcade.
Which Mario Kart game? Arcade GP or Arcade GP 2 or Arcade GP DX?
 
The RPGs are no stranger to darker themes, and you're not wrong...but let's not forget the ending of Galaxy where the universe was reset after the final battle.
When I played it for first time I knew about the Lumas sacrifice but I didn't know about the universe's reset and when I saw it I was in shock because that happened in a MAINLINE GAME and I thought for a moment that Mario lost his memory but that didn't happen so I'm glad.
 
even without actually featuring mario dying for reals, super paper mario's a massive contender. not just the dark themes but how they present them. you watch the sammer kingdom get destroyed and then are immediately sent back there to see what's left: just an endless white void with the occasional ruin of a structure stripped down to just its abstract lines. and the game doesn't hold back the weight of it for the sake of gameplay either: you have to run for like 2 minutes before finding the pure heart. all the while the music has time to really set the scene. it's one of the most fucked sounding osts in a mario game and one of the sounds it samples is literally a failing heart monitor.

some people might see this as trying too hard but nah i love this kind of shit.
 
While not part of the official Mario franchise, Mario and the Music Box is a fan-made horror game featuring puzzle solving, exploration, and some visual novel elements, created by Team Ari. It has achieved somewhat of a following. The game features imagery like Mario facing gruesome deaths based on some choices the player made as well as setting off dangerous traps. A lot of fire was involved in the story as well, as arson is a frequent component of this game.

In December 18th 2025, at 1:45 AM, less than a year ago, during some dispute, the leading developer CorpseSyndrome allegedly doused a man with alcohol, set him on fire, which killed him, hospitalized another man, forced a woman and an 11 year old to flee the scene, and burnt a house down. This has made local news.

It must be both very unsettling and hilariously dark that one of the creators of an over-the-top edgy Super Mario horror game is serving prison time for arson and murder.
 
even without actually featuring mario dying for reals, super paper mario's a massive contender. not just the dark themes but how they present them. you watch the sammer kingdom get destroyed and then are immediately sent back there to see what's left: just an endless white void with the occasional ruin of a structure stripped down to just its abstract lines. and the game doesn't hold back the weight of it for the sake of gameplay either: you have to run for like 2 minutes before finding the pure heart. all the while the music has time to really set the scene. it's one of the most fucked sounding osts in a mario game and one of the sounds it samples is literally a failing heart monitor.

some people might see this as trying too hard but nah i love this kind of shit.
I have to be honest, this for a moment looked like a endless level literally, and then you fight against Brobot L-type and the player sees how Dimentio explodes Mr. L.
 
While not part of the official Mario franchise, Mario and the Music Box is a fan-made horror game featuring puzzle solving, exploration, and some visual novel elements, created by Team Ari. It has achieved somewhat of a following. The game features imagery like Mario facing gruesome deaths based on some choices the player made as well as setting off dangerous traps. A lot of fire was involved in the story as well, as arson is a frequent component of this game.

In December 18th 2025, at 1:45 AM, less than a year ago, during some dispute, the leading developer CorpseSyndrome allegedly doused a man with alcohol, set him on fire, which killed him, hospitalized another man, forced a woman and an 11 year old to flee the scene, and burnt a house down. This has made local news.

It must be both very unsettling and hilariously dark that one of the creators of an over-the-top edgy Super Mario horror game is serving prison time for arson and murder.
1793497110541.png

people laugh at how weird daisy fans are but mario fans have an arsonist in their ranks

also got a kick out of reading this:


i think mario and the music box pretty much is the most horrifying mario game just because of what the creator actually did.
 
Last edited:
Back