Roll and Maria Renard said:
How come Maria Renard isn't getting any votes even though she has appeared in about as many games as both Simon and Richter? I mean she was playable in a lot of Castlevania games as well. She's had way more games than any other female Castlevania character. People did talk good about her in Rondo of Blood and Symphony of the Night. She's best remembered as the easy mode of Rondo of Blood for people who played that game.
Speaking as an utter casual who never played a single Castlevania game, no, I don't know who Maria Renard is. Hell, your name on the forum was the first time I ever saw her name. I knew who Simon Belmont was prior to registering here.
You seem to misunderstand what "iconic" means. Iconic doesn't simply mean they appear in many games. Iconic also means they're recognized by people who haven't played a Castlevania game, as well as being able to name the character. I've known Simon Belmont and what he does and what is signature weapon is without playing one of the games or even prior to the Smash direct. He's had a cartoon appearance as a main character alongside Mega Man and Pit (thought I wouldn't argue that Pit is "iconic"). On the other hand I don't even know Maria Renard and what she does and what games she appears in. All I remember from a Castlevania game is some dude with a whip killing a bunch of fantasy creatures in a 2d sidescroller map game. That's it.