Waluigi vs Daisy: Who Should Be In Smash Switch???

Who Should Be The Next Super Mario Rep In Smash?


  • Total voters
    49
memoryman3 said:
Are you seriously comparing Daisy to a life threatening diesease Swiftie???!

Well for me it would go Daisy > Waluigi > Captain Toad >>>>>>>>>>>>>> trash >>>>> Paper Mario
Wow what did paper mario do to you
 
For me it’s Waluigi > Cappy > Pauline > Toad (preferably assist character though) >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Daisy.

I liked Smash 4’s inclusion of Daisy because it made it plain obvious who she truly is: Peach with an orange dress and brown hair. Until Daisy proves herself as an independent character from Peach (and stops showing hatred toward Waluigi), she will stay near the bottom of my favorite characters list—down there with Jojora and Starlow.
 
memoryman3 said:
Pauline can’t even make it to Mario Tennis...what chance does she have for Smash?
Guess who wasn't in Mario Tennis Open but ended up in Smash.
 
Guess who wasn't in Super Sluggers and also was in Smash.
 
Princess Mario said:
Guess who wasn't in Super Sluggers and also was in Smash.

Rosalina was only picked because of Sakurai liking the idea of a puppet fighter.
 
I think Pauline has almost no chance of being playable in Smash. She doesn't have much moveset potential as far as I can tell, and she still isn't even that major of a character in Odyssey compared to Rosalina's role in Galaxy. Furthermore, Rosalina was at least in some spin-offs before being in Smash, like MKW. Also Rosalina didn't get into Smash until 7 years after her debut. Barring the fact that Pauline already existed as a minor character in the arcade Donkey Kong and Mvs.DK, Pauline getting into this Smash game would be more equivalent to Rosalina getting into Brawl, which certainly would not have been a possibility even if Galaxy had been out for long enough when they were developing Brawl. Spin-offs aren't necessarily a big factor in it, but I still don't think Pauline has a chance.
 
Technically neither of them, as I don't think the game would benefit fromhaving them as playable, they simply wouldn't be particularly good characters to have as fighters.
But if I have to pick I'd say Waluigi for various reasons:
1) Daisy would feel like a "spiced up Peach" whereas Waluigi would feel quite different from Wario (as he might be his opposite: fast on the ground but slow in the air)
2) He could attack using sport equipment like tennis rackets, golf clubs etc.(which ha already been suggested for Daisy); also according to Dancing Stage: Mario Mix, he's a great dancer so he might use dance moves for his light attacks, kinda like the Wii Fit trainer but dance-themed

Personally neither of the characters would be good smash newcomers, but if we were forced to pick one between the two then it's a no-brainer that Waluigi would be the better option.