The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!! (Division 4, Round 4)

F

forum user 3254

Power Star
All right, time to see which Mario game is best!

Just give an answer to the poll above! You can explain your vote in a reply, if you want. The poll is replaced every week, although I may be late in replacing it sometimes.

The current poll is for the best Mario Tennis game! The console and handheld versions of the games are counted together in this poll.

Winners
Best 2D Platformer (Division 1) = New Super Mario Bros. Wii
Best 3D Platformer (Division 1) = Super Mario Odyssey
Best Mainstream Mario Kart Game (Division 2) = Mario Kart 8 (Deluxe)
Best Arcade Mario Kart Game (Division 2) = Mario Kart Arcade GP DX
Best Mainstream Mario Party Game (Division 3) = Mario Party 8
Best Handheld Mario Party Game (Division 3) = Mario Party DS
Best Mario Golf Game (Division 4) = Mario Golf: Toadstool Tour
Best Mario Baseball Game (Division 4) = Mario Super Sluggers
Best Mario & Sonic Game (Division 4) = M&S at the London 2012 Olympics
Best Paper Mario Game (Division 5) = Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door
Best Mario & Luigi Game (Division 5) = Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
Best Mario Tennis game (Division 4) = Mario Power Tennis
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

On the condition that New Super Mario Bros. U includes the Luigi U expansion (which is the game I got instead of both separately), I would vote for that because it offers a lot of Mario platforming goodness in several flavours that include the tradition gameplay (Mario U), short levels (Luigi U) and the challenges (found in Mario U).

Thank you for reading.
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

winstein said:
On the condition that New Super Mario Bros. U includes the Luigi U expansion (which is the game I got instead of both separately), I would vote for that because it offers a lot of Mario platforming goodness in several flavours that include the tradition gameplay (Mario U), short levels (Luigi U) and the challenges (found in Mario U).

Thank you for reading.
Click to expand...
NSLU is DLC for NSMBU, so yes, it counts.
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

LeftyGreenMario's burned calories and now I'm here and prepared for the face-off!!!

Oh...

*leaves disappointed*

I went for New Super Mario Bros. Wii because it's the first among the 4-person Mario platformers. I guess it's unfair, but it also has modding support including the amazing Newer Super Mario Bros. which really extends its shelf life.
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

I feel unqualified to vote in this since I haven't beat all of these games...
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

Plague Knight said:
I feel unqualified to vote in this since I haven't beat all of these games...
Click to expand...
Just vote among all you’ve played. I haven’t played too many of these, really. Don’t forget that playing an amiibo Tap or Smash demo counts as playing it.
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

Super Mario World is simply timeless. :mario: :yoshi:
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

Super Mario World was more than great. Such creative, challenging, unique levels deserve to be the best in the series despite their simplicity. Also the power-ups and :yoshi:

But the boss fights were too easy.
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

There are 3 Main Games I would vote for:

Super Mario World (+Great Level Design and Physics)
New Super Bros. (+Some of the best Level Design in the series -Super Mario Bros. Physics)
Super Mario Maker (+The ability to create levels -Super Mario Bros. Physics and a ton of inaccuracies of in each Game Mode)

Overall I'd have to say Super Mario World is the Best out of the three, due to stated negatives (there's probably some for SMW, but I can't think of any).
 
Re: The Ultimate Mario Face-Off!!!

Sorry I’m a bit late, but...

The winner of Round 1 is...New Super Mario Bros. Wii, with 5 votes! NSMBU and SMM were close, with 4 votes each.

The new poll is for the best 3D Mario platformer! Voting ends Saturday!