Do you believe the leak?

[GalacticPetey]

I personally no not believe it. There's simply too much evidence against it.

...


What evidence exactly?

Although I've read in another forum that the Duck Hunt Dog render was found in the internet, making the leak more dubious.

Someone actually made a render trying to disprove the leak. Yes. People were that desperate.

 

[Xiahou Dun]

I personally no not believe it. There's simply too much evidence against it.

...


What evidence exactly?

Although I've read in another forum that the Duck Hunt Dog render was found in the internet, making the leak more dubious.

Someone actually made a render trying to disprove the leak. Yes. People were that desperate.

Wait, what makes you think it's that?

 

[GalacticPetey]

I personally no not believe it. There's simply too much evidence against it.

...


What evidence exactly?

Although I've read in another forum that the Duck Hunt Dog render was found in the internet, making the leak more dubious.

Someone actually made a render trying to disprove the leak. Yes. People were that desperate.

Wait, what makes you think it's that?

It was posted on SmashBoards by a user with next to no posts. Reverse google searching it lead to nothing at all and it looked really poor quality.

 

[GBA]

just found it lol

Spoiler

yep that's it leak completely disproved go home everyone

speaking of which, I found a nice list of arguments and counterarguments for the leak's inconsistencies on the same site, it's very detailed and I reckon it's worth a read

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Nope, that leak is fake as all hell.

As someone who loves the Mario cast in Smash, even I find it odd that Mario has SEVEN reps. IMO the only likely Mario character left is Paper Mario and he wouldn't rep the Mario series, rather his own subseries. IF Mario got one more mainline rep Bowser Jr. is likely, but not Jr. AND Dr. Mario. Plus why would they pick Doc of all Melee cuts rather than Mewtwo, a far more unique character? It makes so little sense.

 

[Xiahou Dun]

speaking of which, I found a nice list of arguments and counterarguments for the leak's inconsistencies on the same site, it's very detailed and I reckon it's worth a read

Interesting read. It doesn't prove or disprove the leak, and it brought up great points.

Nope, that leak is fake as all hell.

As someone who loves the Mario cast in Smash, even I find it odd that Mario has SEVEN reps. IMO the only likely Mario character left is Paper Mario and he wouldn't rep the Mario series, rather his own subseries. IF Mario got one more mainline rep Bowser Jr. is likely, but not Jr. AND Dr. Mario. Plus why would they pick Doc of all Melee cuts rather than Mewtwo, a far more unique character? It makes so little sense.

Don't let your personal opinion color your view on the legitimacy of the leak.

 

[Xiahou Dun]

Double post
THIS image has been circulating to "prove" that Dr. Mario is fake.

Spoiler

Hoo, boy, this is where being a Mario fanatic sure helps.

But I have several red flags to show that the Mario render is fake. I don't know why people think THIS is clear cut evidence.

Check out the cruddy MS paint job on his right ear and sideburn. You can't miss it, you don't even need to know you're a Mario freak to notice this crap.

Also, the way Mario's hat is designed, his forehead should run straight along the edge, but the Mario image has a bump.

His right eye shape looks slightly ruffled when it should be circular.

The way Mario's hat is structured, there should not be a huge bump on the back of his hat; that's overdone.

The shading on the left corner of his mouth is smudged out compared to the rest of his mouth.

I'll point out the flaws in my image.

No wonder this Mario looks off.

 

[Magikrazy]

So in other words, it could go either way.

I hope they reveal another character soon so we can know for sure.

 

[yoshiking14x]

I guess I don't need to hire my cousin Sherlock Yoshi to solve this.

 

[Magikrazy]

Wow. Your cousin is the famous Sherlock Yoshi?

I own all his comics.