Rank the Mario Platformers (please separate 2D and 3D platformers!)

Pwwnd123 said:
What's wrong with SMG2?

It's the shameless same piece of crap I've already played in Super Mario Galaxy.

Pwwnd123 said:
It is a mind blowing masterpiece.

My head explodes because of the game's sheer unoriginality

Pwwnd123 said:
It has some more action in it and Yoshi makes it awesome.

Mario isn't a game series based on action. Super Mario Galaxy 2 is part of it. It's platformer-oriented. Go play Rayman 3 or any of the main Kirby games if you like action in your platformers, because they have far more action than this turd.

You know my opinion of Yoshi: he's terrible and he appears in only one percent of the game.

Pwwnd123 said:
It adds more to the fun factor and there were a lot of beautiful things in it like the ending and all that stuff.

The ending isn't beautiful, it's home to the absolute worst final boss fight in Mario existence.

Pwwnd123 said:
Why be so biased with a No#1 kick ass mind blowing masterpiece?

I feel like yelling at you for calling it a "number one masterpiece" when there are clearly far superior games out there far out of the Mario spectrum that are much more enjoyable than a 60 dollar barf fest.

Pwwnd123 said:
I mean c'mon if you wanted some more action you got it.

No, it's the same game. You still spin, and you still receive power-ups like any other Mario game. Wake me up when Mario is something like Rayman 3 or Devil May Cry or something like that when the game is CENTERED around action.

Pwwnd123 said:
I mean c'mon if Sunshine received a sequel called Sunshine 2 and it had more content and everyone else found it to be a no#1 badass sequel to Sunshine and you just had so much bias towards it. How would you feel if some people hated Sunshine 2 which you may have loved?

This is a red herring statement I will not bother answering

Pwwnd123 said:
How dare you insult gaming's beautiful platforming masterpiece known to existance in mankind?

Because it's not gaming's beautiful master piece. I can name 10 more games in the top of my head that I've enjoyed more than Super Mario Galaxy 2. Rayman Origins, Rayman Legends, Tales of Symphonia, Super Mario Galaxy, Super Mario 64 DS, Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask, Mario Party 6, Mario Kart 8, Kirby's Return to Dreamland, New Super Mario Bros. Wii, Donkey Kong 64...the list goes on and on. And to call it "the perfect game" is quite a show of your ignorance since 1. you're totally comparing different genres of games, which is STUPID and 2. Super Mario Galaxy 2 HAS flaws that you seem to ignore.

Pwwnd123 said:
It was the excellence of Nintendo's engineering of how good a game could be and the visuals were so spectacular than the first Galaxy. What more could you ask for?

Last time I checked, the visuals are exactly alike to the first game. You have very low-poly models of Toads, Mario is lower poly than he is in say, Mario Party 9 and Mario & Sonic games, and you have poorly anti-aliased 2D graphics, just as the first game. The rim-lighting is there to mask up the low-poly of the models to make it not only run at 60 fps, but also render all the levels. You also have bad draw distance for that as well. It's NOT good as you think it is. You know why I know that? 3D modeling experience.

Pwwnd123 said:
I'd bet heaven would offer a game so good to match SMG2's cleverness.

They already did. A tons. Just open your damn eyes outside of Nintendo's spectrum.
 
So Baby Luigi, what you are saying is that you think SMG2 is a mediocre game like Mario Sunshine even though a lot of other people think Sunshine and Galaxy 2 are the best ones ever? I mean Sunshine was remotely bad when compared to other Mario games. Sure it was criticized and do you think Sunshine is a 40$ barf fest just like how you called Galaxy 2 a 60$ barf fest. I mean if the AVGN (James Rolfe) were to play it, I'm pretty sure his reaction would be that it was so good. Sure I bet Metroid Other M and Mega Man X7 deserve the title of being barf fests. I mean Mega Man X4 as a lot of Mega Man fans say is the last real good Mega Man X game.

Galaxy 2 isn't that bad of a game like let's say Big Rigs:Over The Road Racing or all those piles of dog turds that the AVGN reviewed. If you think it is all that bad then suggest the idea to the AVGN to review it even though he will be moving from classic games. I think Galaxy 2 is like that one X4 of a Mario game. I mean it isn't repetitive and unoriginal like the Mega Man games on the NES. It is not that bad like how Mega Man 8 was on the PlayStation and Sega Saturn which you may call a barf fest because Mega Man 8 is considered by a lot of Mega Man fans to be the worst Mega Man game right next to X7.
 
Pwwnd123 said:
So Baby Luigi, what you are saying is that you think SMG2 is a mediocre game like Mario Sunshine even though a lot of other people think Sunshine and Galaxy 2 are the best ones ever? I mean Sunshine was remotely bad when compared to other Mario games. Sure it was criticized and do you think Sunshine is a 40$ barf fest just like how you called Galaxy 2 a 60$ barf fest. I mean if the AVGN (James Rolfe) were to play it, I'm pretty sure his reaction would be that it was so good. Sure I bet Metroid Other M and Mega Man X7 deserve the title of being barf fests. I mean Mega Man X4 as a lot of Mega Man fans say is the last real good Mega Man X game.

Yes I am saying that Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a mediocre game. It's not even a hard thing for me to say.

When did I ever say that Super Mario Sunshine was a mediocre game? I haven't even ranked it because I've never played it myself. I can only deduce conclusions based on what my sister played and the most serious flaw I see about Super Mario Sunshine was the Blooper surfing and the blue coins.

I don't give a dang about what reviewers say about Galaxy 2. Who's to say their opinion is better than my own personal opinion of the game that I've personally experienced and played for myself? Can't I have my own opinion, which is as valid as the most coveted review on the internet? Usually, reviewers' opinions have a degree of truth in them but ultimately, every single review is about 90% subjectively based as most criticisms are based off a player's expectations (the game is too long, it's too tedious, some game mechanics suck) and experience. The only objective things you can say about a game is its frame-rate and if its riddled with unplayable bugs. That's it.

For example, I personally find Pokemon to be probably one of the most boring and repetitive games I've ever played. No reviewer can ever sway my own opinion on this, and Pokemon is supposed to be a good series, right? It's simply not for me. I crave something a bit more....action-oriented and less tedious than what it feels like an overly complex game of rock-paper-scissors. Do I understand why other people enjoy Pokemon? Absolutely. Another example is Mario Party, which happens to be one of my favorite game series, yet receives middling scores. As well as Spore, which got like 70 metacritic when I feel like it's a brilliant game, especially its expansion pack. See why blindingly trusting reviewers is a bad thing?

Galaxy 2 isn't that bad of a game like let's say Big Rigs:Over The Road Racing or all those piles of dog turds that the AVGN reviewed. If you think it is all that bad then suggest the idea to the AVGN to review it even though he will be moving from classic games. I think Galaxy 2 is like that one X4 of a Mario game. I mean it isn't repetitive and unoriginal like the Mega Man games on the NES. It is not that bad like how Mega Man 8 was on the PlayStation and Sega Saturn which you may call a barf fest because Mega Man 8 is considered by a lot of Mega Man fans to be the worst Mega Man game right next to X7.

I never said it was. When did I ever said Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a bad game? I just said that I hate that game and I rather be playing the first Super Mario Galaxy any day of the week. I know crappy games too. You act like I never heard of crappy unplayable messes like Ride to Hell: Retribution, Big Rigs, Sonic Free Riders, etc. But just because a game is bug-free or polished doesn't mean I personally have to like it! It's like some vegetables being good for you, but you hate their taste, therefore, you refuse to eat it.

Stop comparing this game to other games. Super Mario Galaxy and Mega Man ARE. TWO. COMPLETELY. DIFFERENT. GAMES.
 
SMG2 > SM3DL > SMG1 >>>>>>>>>>>>> SM64DS > SM64

SMB3 > SMW > NSMBW > NSMB > SMB2 > SMB:TLL > SMB
 
I never said it was. When did I ever said Super Mario Galaxy 2 is a bad game? I just said that I hate that game and I rather be playing the first Super Mario Galaxy any day of the week. I know crappy games too. You act like I never heard of crappy unplayable messes like Ride to Hell: Retribution, Big Rigs, Sonic Free Riders, etc. But just because a game is bug-free or polished doesn't mean I personally have to like it! It's like some vegetables being good for you, but you hate their taste, therefore, you refuse to eat it.

Stop comparing this game to other games. Super Mario Galaxy and Mega Man ARE. TWO. COMPLETELY. DIFFERENT. GAMES.

I know that. But I don't think it's something very awful like the third Ninja Turtles movie which a lot of TMNT fans hate including the AVGN who destroyed his VHS cassette after reviewing it.
 
Lol I like how this guy keeps making completely irrelevant comparisons

What the hell do Ninja Turtles have to do with Mario Galaxy?
 
Nysic said:
Lol I like how this guy keeps making completely irrelevant comparisons

What the hell do Ninja Turtles have to do with Mario Galaxy?

I was just slightly exaggerating/comparing and being sarcastic.
 
Pwwnd123 said:
Nysic said:
Lol I like how this guy keeps making completely irrelevant comparisons

What the hell do Ninja Turtles have to do with Mario Galaxy?

I was just slightly exaggerating/comparing and being sarcastic.

There's turtles in both series?

But I hate the fact he compares a game to the "mediocre" game Super Mario Sunshine. May I remind some that Sunshine was one of the top selling GameCube games. Could we compare him to another person on the forums.. Maybe.

But for 3D platformers,
1. Super Mario 3D World (Only played through W1, 2, 3, 7, 8, 9, 10 ,11 and it was amazing, way better than the others even though it is a Flagpole kind of game)
2. Super Mario Galaxy (It's great, if only i can get a new disc or get mine fixed)
3. Super Mario Sunshine (Oh that Watermelon Mission!)
4. Super Mario 64 DS (Still could use work but I love it)
5. Super Mario Galaxy 2 (dang Green Stars, I hate short levels, feels kind of like an add-on to the first)
6. Super Mario 64 (Feels somewhat empty but very good)
7. Super Mario 3D Land (from what I played, the levels all feel the same)
 
Pwwnd123 said:
Nysic said:
Lol I like how this guy keeps making completely irrelevant comparisons

What the hell do Ninja Turtles have to do with Mario Galaxy?

I was just slightly exaggerating/comparing and being sarcastic.

That doesn't answer MKGuy's question of the relevancy of your statement
 
<