My Mario Kart 8 Roster (Updated!)

[Windy]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Where's Toadette?
She has not appear in any games since 2008!!

 

[Dorayaki]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

I think Toadsworth is a better choice than Toadette, as she is only a female counterpart to Toad, while Toadsworth is his own character of the Toad species.

We can also say that Toad is a species generic representive lack of personality, and Luigi has more personality than his brother. I don't think certain complaints against main characters work.

Where's Toadette?
She has not appear in any games since 2008!!

I don't say Toadette should be playable this time, but at least she should have been a referee in previous mainstream games.

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Where's Toadette?
She has not appear in any games since 2008!!

I'm actually neutral on Toadette. The only one I don't think should be here is Honey Queen. Maybe that's just because I got the feeling she replaced Waluigi, and I liked Waluigi.
I actually like the Metal Mario idea. (And I'm sure all of 2 people agree with me on that) Maybe Shadow Mario would have been a bit more interesting, though.

 

[Xiahou Ba]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Where's Toadette?
She has not appear in any games since 2008!!

I'm actually neutral on Toadette. The only one I don't think should be here is Honey Queen. Maybe that's just because I got the feeling she replaced Waluigi, and I liked Waluigi.
I actually like the Metal Mario idea. (And I'm sure all of 2 people agree with me on that) Maybe Shadow Mario would have been a bit more interesting, though.

My twin loves Metal Mario, but you know what? She will love any Mario form

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

She will love any Mario form

Even this?

Spoiler

 

[LuckySeven]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

So what do you guys think?

Looking back, I probably should have used Dark Bowser instead of O'Chunks, but whatever. Found 3D pics of whoever I could (which leaves Fawful, can't find one of him)

Replace Toadsworth with Toadette, O'chunks with Dixie, Mr. L with Birdo, Peasly with Tiny, E. Gadd with Koopa, Fawful with Dry Bones and Dimentio with Paratroopa and I'll be here for it.

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

So what do you guys think?

Looking back, I probably should have used Dark Bowser instead of O'Chunks, but whatever. Found 3D pics of whoever I could (which leaves Fawful, can't find one of him)

Replace Toadsworth with Toadette,
What's wrong with Toadsworth? Toadette could be added though.
O'chunks with Dixie,
That could work.
Mr. L with Birdo,
Not a big fan of Birdo.
Peasley with Tiny,
Maybe that could work.
E. Gadd with Koopa,
Koopa is fine, but what's wrong with E. Gadd?
Fawful with Dry Bones
Same as above with Dry Bones (He's fine) but what's wrong with Fawful?
and Dimentio with Paratroopa
Paratroopa's OK, Dimentio is unlikely but I still want him.
and I'll be here for it.

Fine with the suggested characters, but what do you have against the ones you want replaced?

 

[Shyghoul]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Screw the RPG characters and replace them with more mainstream ones and this would be a really good roster imo.

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Screw the RPG characters and replace them with more mainstream ones and this would be a really good roster imo.

What do you have against the RPG characters?

 

[Shyghoul]

Re: My Mario Kart Wii U Roster

Screw the RPG characters and replace them with more mainstream ones and this would be a really good roster imo.

What do you have against the RPG characters?

Most of them have made only one appearence in a game and really don't deserve to appear imo,except for Fawful.