Mario games that are the best and the worst

Mamoru endou

Mamoru endou

My name is Mamoru Endo but you call me Mark Evans
Pronouns
Him, her,
Ever since I joined this forum, I wanted to ask you which games in the Mario series is good and which ones are bad, list them below
 
Good: Mario's Early Years CD Rom collection.
Bad: Everything else
The worst: Super Paper Mario Splash: The Sticker King Door.
 
Here's mine
Good: donkey Kong, donkey Kong Jr, Mario Bros, all three of the Super Mario Bros games for the NES, all of the Super Mario Land games (including the Wario Land games), Super Mario world, Super Mario all-stars, Super Mario kart, Super Mario 64, Mario party, and all of GBA remakes.
Bad: Super Mario world 2 Yoshi's island, Mario teaches typing, hotel Mario, Super Mario Bros(gbc), Super Mario Sunshine.
Worst: any port of either donkey Kong or Mario Bros for the Atari 2600
 
Mamoru endou said:
Bad: Super Mario world 2 Yoshi's island
Click to expand...
Genuinely curious as to why you consider a game that's often considered a masterpiece and one of the greatest games ever made to be bad.

Like I'm not asking 'WTf how can yu not like Yoshi island it BEST GAME EVER??????' but genuinely do wanna know, always interesting to see when someone dislikes a generally widely liked game (or likes a generally widely disliked game).
 
Princess Viola said:
Genuinely curious as to why you consider a game that's often considered a masterpiece and one of the greatest games ever made to be bad.

Like I'm not asking 'WTf how can yu not like Yoshi island it BEST GAME EVER??????' but genuinely do wanna know, always interesting to see when someone dislikes a generally widely liked game (or likes a generally widely disliked game).
Click to expand...
It tried to do something different with the franchise with baby Mario riding on Yoshi, don't get me wrong, I love the cute green dinosaur when he made his debut in Super Mario world, then for the next game they decided to make him the main character, baby sitting Mario who is a baby, thankfully when they made Super Mario 64, Mario is back to being a main character
 
Super Mario World 2 Yoshis Island is a mid platformer.
 
Princess Viola said:
Genuinely curious as to why you consider a game that's often considered a masterpiece and one of the greatest games ever made to be bad.
Click to expand...
the game doesn't particularly impress me and while i played yoshi's island ds before this one, which others might condemn me for this "mistake", this one doesn't seem that much better than yoshi's island ds (except the soundtrack maybe) to the point i'm interested in playing it at all. it's a "been there done that" thing and it seems like all the parts of yoshi's island ds i didn't like, such as transformations, skiing,, the collection (especially the collection, egh) are retained in this game. heck yids's boss fight is the strongest (and underrated) part of the game (nothing quite matches the intensity of the noise gilbert the gooey makes when defeated) and this one's boss fights have some stinkers from what i've seen.
 
Best: TTYD / SPM. Honourable mentions to PM64 and the first 4 M&L games.

Worst: I still probably have to say Sticker Star / Colour Splash. They aren't really terrible games in a vacuum, but I detest the complete 180 on a series that was going amazingly beforehand. Paper Jam would be an honourable mention too because it crosses over PM and M&L only to have a game that has 1 original character (Starlow) from both series combined, but that is barely above SS / CS due to its gameplay (Toad missions suck though).
 
Yoshi's Island is literally what people who hate collectathons think those type of games are like. A bunch of random items and numbers to get all of before the end of level. It just feels really arbitrary and meaningless, things to collect for the sake of having things to collect.

best game is Mario Kart Wii every time baybee let's fucking goooooo