Which smash game is the best?

[Blue]

Warning: Please keep the violence down. Please be calm and reasonable.
Which is the best?

 

[Lin Beifong]

I mean, I'll always have a soft spot for Melee, but it's probably Ultimate for the sheer amount of variety, isn't it?

 

[Blue]

I'm kinda on the same boat but instead with brawl. I first picked up smash when brawl came out and played it for more than I'm willing to admit. I built stages with it and just had so much fun. But I will admit Ultimate is better.

 

[Xiahou Ba]

With the way the modding scene is progressing, Ultimate would eventually top Smash 4 for me.

The filesize limit for most Ultimate files recently got lifted iirc, so you could have characters that go over the poly limit. You can already put music bigger than the original ones you're replacing, and that's a major plus for me.

All Ultimate really needs now is one-slot voice mods and that'll be it. Well, if I have a Switch that is.

 

[fantanoice]

Melee continues to be such a joy

 

[Xiahou Ba]

I feel like every time a new Smash game gets released, I play Melee less and less and I realize how much of a jankfest that game really is. Also, Melee Ness is horrible and he feels super bad to play as so there's that.

 

[Xiahou Dun]

I like them all for their own qualities, barring vBrawl lmao. But Ultimate right now (and modded) is excellent and I've sunk too many hours playing the stupidest crap with the dumbest settings.

 

[forum user 3254]

Ultimate, no contest. It has everything great about previous Smash games and so much more.

 

[Teedgee]

...do i even need to say anything?

 

[Chair]

my response is kinda obvious