Your headcanons

If it’s true that a comet shower occurs every 100 years, that is. But maybe there were two showers in one century, you know, by chance.
 
Easter Yoshi said:
Plague Knight said:
Easter Yoshi said:
Yeah, that means SMG2 is either an alternate canon or takes place in a parallel universe...
Click to expand...
Not if the rearrangement was only physical. It just means that the universe got physically changed without affecting time. When a Luma becomes a planet, it isn't a parallel universe, so I don't see how the entire universe going through this change is any different. It also can't be parallel because the old layout of the universe simply doesn't exist anymore.
Click to expand...
Basically, you’re assuming that Mario is 126 years old.
Click to expand...

No, you missed this part:
Plague Knight said:
the rearranging of the universe allows the Star Festival to happen again in a shorter time
Click to expand...
If the universe is rearranged, then it is entirely in the realm of possibility for whatever factors make the comet come to be changed during the rearrangement so that the comet comes much sooner, like in only one year for example.
 
ugh this is why i never think deeply about tying plot holes in galaxy 1/2, i'm getting a headache right now just from reading this.
 
goombas that have been squished are teleported back to bowser's castle

inflated back to normal

and sent back out

so you are actually stomping on the same few goombas
 
Sgt Nate V said:
goombas that have been squished are teleported back to bowser's castle

inflated back to normal

and sent back out

so you are actually stomping on the same few goombas
Click to expand...
Yeah, that’s what I thought. Yoshi’s New Island shows that Goombas don’t actually die when you stomp on them anyways.
 
My Super Paper Mario headcanon is that Blumiere was sincere about trying to build a better universe after the destruction of the old one (at least early on). The only sources we have for him just killing everybody are Dimentio (who has an interest in making himself look much better to Mario and Co. than Bleck) and Bleck, when he'd be trying to get Mario and Tippy to kill him after realizing that not only was Timpani alive but all he did (destroyed his family, rampaged across the universe) was in vain.
 
some of my headcanons are:

the aforementioned broodal origin
a good chunk of lemmy's land (i.e., morton sr)
characters from the NCS (i.e., king toadstool, wooster)

mario and luigi were born on plit
soon after yoshi's new island they were taken to earth
and they lived there until they discovered the mushroom kingdom
 
bowser built bob-ombs after he saw them in a dream

there is also a way of transportation between subcon and reality

so that's why you see mario 2 characters outside of subcon
 
bonneters reproduce by having 2 parents gather up and do some elaborate magic on a hat and a babby will form eventually
i keep on coming bac k with headcanons