Overrated Mario Characters

[User4042]

List characters in the Mario universe who you think are overrated.

Geno
Luigi
Peach
Birdo
Wart
Tatanga

 

[Ernest Fine]

Rosalina
Bowser Jr.
Diddy Kong
Toad

 

[Boidoh]

Rosalina and Bowser Jr.


Overated NPC's in Spinoffs (Nintendo): Piantas :D

 

[User4042]

Poochy

 

[GalacticPetey]

Geno
Rosalina (Kinda like her though)
Poochy
Donkey Kong

 

[Awesome Koopa]

Rosalina
Geno
Ludwig

 

[Smasher]

Birdo

don't most people hate Birdo

Luigi
Rosalina
Poochy
Geno
the Koopalings

 

[Soundless Voice]

Ludwig

Ludwig Von Koopa?

the Koopalings

Not to me... Maybe to you!

 

[Awesome Koopa]

Yeah that Ludwig. I just think he gets far more attention then the other Koopalings. And I just don't like him much.

 

[Dorayaki]

Overrated by whom? Fans or the staff?

And strictly speaking how the staff overrate characters?
If by giving too many spinoff apperances, I'm sure Birdo, Rosalina and even Geno are not overrated.

 

[Awesome Koopa]

Probably by fans. If we were talking staff, Geno would be underrated!

 

[User4042]

Overrated by whom? Fans or the staff?

And strict speaking how the staff overrate characters?
If by giving too many spinoff apperances, I'm sure Birdo, Rosalina and even Geno are not overrated.

Overrated by whom? Fans or the staff?

And strict speaking how the staff overrate characters?
If by giving too many spinoff apperances, I'm sure Birdo, Rosalina and even Geno are not overrated.

Everyone says stuff like "Geno come back" or "Geno is so awesome he needs to appear in SSB4" or "GENO IS SO AWESOME YEAAAAAAAAAH!". Dont get me started on the other two

 

[Dorayaki]

Everyone says stuff like "Geno come back" or "Geno is so awesome he needs to appear in SSB4" or "GENO IS SO AWESOME YEAAAAAAAAAH!". Dont get me started on the other two

I haven't played Seven Stars yet. Geno might be just like most Paper characters who had been only appeared in one game and just correspond to that story (especially Tippi's example). Nobody is sure if the staff are willing to make them return.

If there are something doing with SE, Geno might already return in Hoops 3-3 or Fortune Street games.

 

[Gumball Machine]

The Koopalings
Toad
Yoshi
Luigi
Waluigi
Geno

Excluding Waluigi and half the koopalings, I still like these characters though.

 

[Magikrazy]

Everyone says stuff like "Geno come back" or "Geno is so awesome he needs to appear in SSB4" or "GENO IS SO AWESOME YEAAAAAAAAAH!". Dont get me started on the other two

I haven't played Seven Stars yet. Geno might be just like most Paper characters who had been only appeared in one game and just correspond to that story (especially Tippi's example). Nobody is sure if the staff are willing to make them return.

If there are something doing with SE, Geno might already return in Hoops 3-3 or Fortune Street games.

I'm sure Square Enix, Nintendo wants to use genotyping if they would give their right funny.

But as they are not interested in any other character anymore either, they are clearly not interested anymore in genotyping.

 

[MnSG]

Geno and Fawful are pretty much very overrated.

 

[Anser]

I sense fire coming...

Geno, definitely. I can't understand why people love him so much, to the point of wanting him for Brawl (and even for Smash 4). It's an extremely irrelevant character who appeared in just one game, and only as a sidekick, not even as the main character.

 

[Magikrazy]

I sense fire coming...

Geno, definitely. I can't understand why people love him so much, to the point of wanting him for Brawl (and even for Smash 4). It's an extremely irrelevant character who appeared in just one game, and only as a sidekick, not even as the main character.

I agree. The real hero is Mallow in my opinion.

 

[Smasher]

oh yes, Baby Mario and Baby Luigi are overrated too.

 

[Redshift]

Overrated by fans
Yoshi
Geno
Rosalina (even though I do like her)
The Koopalings
Fawful (even though I like him)
Luigi
Poochy

Characters given too much attention by Nintendo (thus overrated by staff)
Mario
Peach
Bowser
Yoshi
Luigi

oh yes, Baby Mario and Baby Luigi are overrated too.

Maybe in this forum, but everywhere else, baby characters are generally hated

 

[Dorayaki]

Geno, definitely. I can't understand why people love him so much, to the point of wanting him for Brawl (and even for Smash 4). It's an extremely irrelevant character who appeared in just one game, and only as a sidekick, not even as the main character.

I don't hate him, but in a fair view of all RPG characters, it wouldn't be a nice thing to favor him only.

Characters given too much attention by Nintendo (thus overrated by staff)
Mario
Peach
Bowser
Yoshi
Luigi

Protagonists are not really overrated in general conditions. (Yoshi is strictly not.)
For Mario, I might think the staff make Mario too "heroic" for Mushroom residents in main games.

 

[Boidoh]

Who is GENO!?!

 

[Redshift]

Characters given too much attention by Nintendo (thus overrated by staff)
Mario
Peach
Bowser
Yoshi
Luigi

Protagonists are not really overrated in general conditions. (Yoshi is strictly not.)
For Mario, I might think the staff make Mario too "heroic" for Mushroom residents in main games.

They're still used in every damn game they appeared in. I'm getting sick of Mario as the main protagonist. Nearly every recent game that came out with Mario as the main protagonist is the SAME, DAMN game to the last one.

 

[Magikrazy]

Who is GENO!?!

Long story, but here I go.

In the game Super Mario RPG, Mario and his partner Mallow visit a town called Rose Town. A little kid named Gaz shows Mario his doll collection consisting of Mario, Bowser, and one doll named Geno (he looks like this:

). Overnight, a star being with an unpronouncable name takes over the doll's body, making him fully sentinet. He later joins Mario's party and tells him to collect the Star Pieces to fix a Star Road so wishes can be granted once more.

And that is Geno.

 

[Mini Star]

Wario
Waluigi
Piantas
Nokis
Baby Luigi.