- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Hooded Pitohui
Rogues in Rogueport 2: The Uprising - Mafia Game - Game Thread - Night 6
- Thread starter Diamant
- Start date
Shmaluigi
Private Investigator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Poll Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
- Pronouns
- He/him
(Eh? Wait a minute, dis ain't right. Dis place... It's full of townies! And they're votin' for who gets to survive? Good thing I ain't introduced myself yet, they're never gonna see past my clever disguise.)
Pleased to make your acquaintances. You can call me Old Man Town, capische? I love bein' innocent and not mafia. And uh, whatever else it is dat townies like. Do townies like pudding?
Now den sonnies, as a real innocent townie I been keepin' an eye on what's been goin' on around here. Seems we got votes so far for... Dang, should'a brought my glasses. Glitz Yoshi, Sholmès, Agent F, Stingy, and Yang? What, dat's it? Too many of you boys are yappin' but ain't votin'! Dis kind of laziness wouldn't fly in my organization- I mean my town. Da town dat I'm a part of. As a townie. So dat leaves... Shmalu Sniffer, ClawgripFan, Tasse, Xzzwls, Mr. N, BigBoom, and your old pal Old Man Town without any votes. *AAACK PTH* Youse wouldn't leave a feeble old man to his own devices, would ya?
Looks like somebody used my vote before I got here, so I'm gonna have to tell da boys to bust their knees. Anyway, of dat crowd I think someone oughta vote for Mr. N, capische? He's been doin' good, givin' some valuable insights. Would be a shame to see him get wheeled outta here. Also youse should vote for me.
Shmalu Sniffer, I'd like to see more substance but it seems like he's alright. Looks like he claimed to be the doc but den said he ain't usin' his powers, so either he's a lousy doc or dat ain't it. Dis may be a bad thing to say but I think ClawgripFan's a townie too, mostly 'cause dat pardonin' power would be real nice if da mafia got their hands on it. So dat one's mostly "meta" as my great-grandson says. But youse should vote for me before you vote for either of them, capische?
Let's just say Tasse ain't givin' me the warm fuzzies, capische? But maybe I'm just bein' paranoid, I can't put my finger on anything dat seems off. Not a fan of Xzzwls though, especially with dat latest stunt of wastin' a vote on someone who's already been voted for. Seems there's better ways to save your neck than tryin' to drag more townies down with you, capische?
Dat BigBoom guy, there's only so many votes to go around so I think we can write 'em off as collateral unless he wants to actually add something.
Now I gotta take my pills. Where did I put those...
- Pronouns
- They
- MarioWiki
- Roserade
I think this claim smells bad, and I'm gonna tell you why.
Firstly, there's everything the masked guy said. You had no major reason for revealing your role this early, when you were hardly on the chopping block. We wanted input from you, not a role claim. Why give us one anyway?
Secondly, there's the fact that you know the identity of the cop. Now, this isn't impossible. I can't know what your entire directive is. But, I would also argue that I've rarely seen a role like this that knows the identity of the cop. Usually, backups aren't informed of who the cop is. Especially since they'll be getting alignment info every night for all the other suspects anyway!
Thirdly, there's the fact that this is an invisible role with absolutely no way to verify it. No proof exists that you've done anything this game. The only way anyone could prove this accurate is if the real alignment cop showed up right now and verified what you said. See where I'm going with this?
You made this claim earlier into the day, so Rock Paper Wizard wasn't yet fully primed for elimination. Imagine with me for a moment, though. If you had a sense your scum buddy role cop wasn't going to make it through the day, but you still needed to actually locate the alignment cop, what would you do? Maybe invent a role that requires the real cop declaring their identity, and hope that they take the trap so you could snag them last night? Simple setup, potentially huge reward.
As for the claim that the rat and I are innocent? Easy. Pick two people who would be most likely to get me off your back - by piggybacking off of my most recent sus list. I mean, you later piggybacked again with identifying the hand as someone suspicious.
Then there's the whole kerfuffle with the masked guy in the first place. He mentioned having a failed role interaction with you, but it can't be as simple as him being roleblocked, because I'd assume he would've gotten the notice that he was roleblocked. I suppose I could be mistaken in that, but I got clear indication that I was silenced yesterday morning, and I don't know why roleblocking would've been different. So if no outside party interfered with him, that would mean that your role itself counteracted his... but that wouldn't match with the claim you've made so far, would it?
I don't think we should send the blonde to the gallows today. Frankly, with the advantageous position we're in, I'd sooner let BigBoom fizzle out, assuming the suit wants to stop dooming himself. But when it comes time for us to start pointing fingers for real again, I'm going to be starting here, potential alibi of mine be damned.
In the meantime, if this is your role, then you surely got another result tonight, so I would love for you to share it. And alignment cop, wherever you are - don't roleclaim yet, lord knows we've had enough of that today - but keep a very careful eye on what she says.
ClawgripFan9001
Pirate Crustacean
- MarioWiki
- ClawgripFan9001
"Argh, so I finally managed to sharpen me wits enough ta the point I be capable o' properly producin' food fer thought on this fourth day o' the witch hunt fer Sir Yux's spies. Anyhoo, bear with me as I try ta share me thoughts at the current moment without regurgitatin' what's already been said."
"So first thing's first, there's the Ratooey (Waluigi Time). As already established, I accused 'im o' bein' a member o' the guilty party a few times b'fore o'er the course o' this investigation as per Agent F's theory on Town House dwellers potentially bein' scum. Granted, I latched onto that theory longer than was good fer. As things currently stand, the Ratooey could be undoubtedly Innocent, an' if 'e do turn out ta be scum later down the line, then I gotta commend 'im fer hidin' it behind that stern poker face o' his fer that long."
Second thing's second, there's the moth lady (Pitohui). While 'er incredibly verbose musings be kinda difficult ta decipher at times, she do be bringin' food fer thought ta the table when the situation demands it. I believe she cast a vote t'wards me on the second day due to me continuous switchin' 'tween votes came off as suspicious, which I couldn't fault 'er for. Kinda difficult ta get a read on 'er alignment due ta 'er aforementioned incredibly verbose musings, but I ain't gettin' any strong readings from 'er that 'int t'wards 'er bein' with the guilty party."
"Third thing's third, there be the case o' Mr. Xzzwls (Cloudwalker). A very curious case if I e'er saw one, in the sense that in spite o' bein' evenly matched with me in terms o' investigative experience, the man managed ta make it up ta the fourth day yet draw so much suspicion ta 'imself. The two o' us ended up beefin' back an' forth quite a lot on the previous day, an' at the end o' the day, both of us kept our votes cast on one another fer the same reason; The fear o' bein sent ta the gallows, an' if it weren't fer the Rock Paper Wizard (Hint Toad) drawin' so much attention ta 'imself an' ultimately bein' unmasked as a member o' the guilty party, it coulda very well been either him or me in the Rock Paper Wizard's place. While I would still be a long way from placin' Mr. Xzzwls at the top list o' people most unlikely ta be scum, the tetrahedronical one be tryin' ta prove 'is intentions be fer the greater good o' the expulsion o' the Dark Crystal Star an' the X-Naut Remnants."
"Fourth thing's fourth, there be Agent F (Roserade). I got no doubts 'bout me that she be with the innocents due ta 'er bein' a huge drivin' force in our hunt fer the guilty party. She be at the top o' me list o' folks most unlikely ta be scum fer the duration o' the game, an' if she do turn out ta be scum later down the line, I also gotta commend 'er fer keepin' the con up fer so long."
"Fifth thing's fifth, there's the case o' Mr. N (Ninelevendo). Another curious case, though in a different way compared ta Mr. Xzzwls. 'E be bringin' lots o' food fer thought ta the table when the topic o' who can be trusted an' who can't be brought up, so the lad be observant enough ta be payin' attention ta the game, ta say the least. While it be difficult ta get a read on the lad's alignment, I'm leanin' t'wards 'im bein' Innocent."
Sixth thing's sixth, we got Shmalu Sniffer (Boo1268). The lad be on the same level o' skill as Mr. Xzzwls an' meself where investigative experience be concerned, an' while 'e 'asn't been all that active in directly contributin' ta the witch hunt, he at least be showin' signs o' activity by regularly runnin' his nonexistent lip off, so he ain't dead weight nor ta be viewed as a threat."
Seventh thing's seventh, we got the Violet-Eyed Girl (Hot Cocoa), who ain't been very present fer most o' the game, though she recently been startin' ta show signs o' bein valuable due ta 'er revelation o' bein' in cahoots with the Cop. Even if the legitimacy o' 'er claims remain ta be seen fer the time bein', it also proves she ain't dead weight, but she could still very well be a threat if 'er claims prove ta be false."
"Eighth thing's eighth, we got Stingy (Power Flotzo). The lad ain't been all that present fer the majority o' the game, ta say the least, but 'im bein' targeted the other night managed ta loosen 'is tongue a wee bit. It be up in the air like a plumber launchin' outta a cannon if 'is claims o' bein' innocent 'old up, but it do place the lad lower on the list o' prime suspects still."
"Ninth thing's ninth, there's the case o' Mr. Sholmès (Revin). His alignment be up fer debate like many other folks who are still alive, what with 'is survival o' the fittest mentality an' all, but 'is intentions prove 'im ta be leanin' t'wards the side o' the innocents regardless. If 'e do prove ta be scum later on though, I once again give the man credit where it's due fer not breakin' character the whole time."
"Tenth thing's tenth, there be Glitz Yoshi (Yoshi the SSM). The lad could flip any which way as far as 'is alignment be concerned. He were a drivin' force in the execution o' the Rock Paper Wizard, though as previously mentioned by the others, that could very well still be a scum tactic o' sellin' out 'is comrades ta make 'imself look good. Not much else ta say 'bout 'im."
"Last thing's last, there be BigBoom1946. This lad undoubtedly be dead weight since he signed up fer the gig, then never showed any interest in bein' a part o' the gig the entire time. Whether it be due ta real-life commitments or mere laziness, it can be made clear that 'e ain't gonna be 'elpful fer the remainder o' the investigation."
"Argh, there ye 'ave me thoughts on everyone as things currently stand. I dunno if it'll 'elp me case or anyone else's fer that matter, but at least I tried ta do so on me own accord rather than followin' through on someone else's."
"So first thing's first, there's the Ratooey (Waluigi Time). As already established, I accused 'im o' bein' a member o' the guilty party a few times b'fore o'er the course o' this investigation as per Agent F's theory on Town House dwellers potentially bein' scum. Granted, I latched onto that theory longer than was good fer. As things currently stand, the Ratooey could be undoubtedly Innocent, an' if 'e do turn out ta be scum later down the line, then I gotta commend 'im fer hidin' it behind that stern poker face o' his fer that long."
Second thing's second, there's the moth lady (Pitohui). While 'er incredibly verbose musings be kinda difficult ta decipher at times, she do be bringin' food fer thought ta the table when the situation demands it. I believe she cast a vote t'wards me on the second day due to me continuous switchin' 'tween votes came off as suspicious, which I couldn't fault 'er for. Kinda difficult ta get a read on 'er alignment due ta 'er aforementioned incredibly verbose musings, but I ain't gettin' any strong readings from 'er that 'int t'wards 'er bein' with the guilty party."
"Third thing's third, there be the case o' Mr. Xzzwls (Cloudwalker). A very curious case if I e'er saw one, in the sense that in spite o' bein' evenly matched with me in terms o' investigative experience, the man managed ta make it up ta the fourth day yet draw so much suspicion ta 'imself. The two o' us ended up beefin' back an' forth quite a lot on the previous day, an' at the end o' the day, both of us kept our votes cast on one another fer the same reason; The fear o' bein sent ta the gallows, an' if it weren't fer the Rock Paper Wizard (Hint Toad) drawin' so much attention ta 'imself an' ultimately bein' unmasked as a member o' the guilty party, it coulda very well been either him or me in the Rock Paper Wizard's place. While I would still be a long way from placin' Mr. Xzzwls at the top list o' people most unlikely ta be scum, the tetrahedronical one be tryin' ta prove 'is intentions be fer the greater good o' the expulsion o' the Dark Crystal Star an' the X-Naut Remnants."
"Fourth thing's fourth, there be Agent F (Roserade). I got no doubts 'bout me that she be with the innocents due ta 'er bein' a huge drivin' force in our hunt fer the guilty party. She be at the top o' me list o' folks most unlikely ta be scum fer the duration o' the game, an' if she do turn out ta be scum later down the line, I also gotta commend 'er fer keepin' the con up fer so long."
"Fifth thing's fifth, there's the case o' Mr. N (Ninelevendo). Another curious case, though in a different way compared ta Mr. Xzzwls. 'E be bringin' lots o' food fer thought ta the table when the topic o' who can be trusted an' who can't be brought up, so the lad be observant enough ta be payin' attention ta the game, ta say the least. While it be difficult ta get a read on the lad's alignment, I'm leanin' t'wards 'im bein' Innocent."
Sixth thing's sixth, we got Shmalu Sniffer (Boo1268). The lad be on the same level o' skill as Mr. Xzzwls an' meself where investigative experience be concerned, an' while 'e 'asn't been all that active in directly contributin' ta the witch hunt, he at least be showin' signs o' activity by regularly runnin' his nonexistent lip off, so he ain't dead weight nor ta be viewed as a threat."
Seventh thing's seventh, we got the Violet-Eyed Girl (Hot Cocoa), who ain't been very present fer most o' the game, though she recently been startin' ta show signs o' bein valuable due ta 'er revelation o' bein' in cahoots with the Cop. Even if the legitimacy o' 'er claims remain ta be seen fer the time bein', it also proves she ain't dead weight, but she could still very well be a threat if 'er claims prove ta be false."
"Eighth thing's eighth, we got Stingy (Power Flotzo). The lad ain't been all that present fer the majority o' the game, ta say the least, but 'im bein' targeted the other night managed ta loosen 'is tongue a wee bit. It be up in the air like a plumber launchin' outta a cannon if 'is claims o' bein' innocent 'old up, but it do place the lad lower on the list o' prime suspects still."
"Ninth thing's ninth, there's the case o' Mr. Sholmès (Revin). His alignment be up fer debate like many other folks who are still alive, what with 'is survival o' the fittest mentality an' all, but 'is intentions prove 'im ta be leanin' t'wards the side o' the innocents regardless. If 'e do prove ta be scum later on though, I once again give the man credit where it's due fer not breakin' character the whole time."
"Tenth thing's tenth, there be Glitz Yoshi (Yoshi the SSM). The lad could flip any which way as far as 'is alignment be concerned. He were a drivin' force in the execution o' the Rock Paper Wizard, though as previously mentioned by the others, that could very well still be a scum tactic o' sellin' out 'is comrades ta make 'imself look good. Not much else ta say 'bout 'im."
"Last thing's last, there be BigBoom1946. This lad undoubtedly be dead weight since he signed up fer the gig, then never showed any interest in bein' a part o' the gig the entire time. Whether it be due ta real-life commitments or mere laziness, it can be made clear that 'e ain't gonna be 'elpful fer the remainder o' the investigation."
"Argh, there ye 'ave me thoughts on everyone as things currently stand. I dunno if it'll 'elp me case or anyone else's fer that matter, but at least I tried ta do so on me own accord rather than followin' through on someone else's."
- Pronouns
- He/Him |Boo1268
Shmalu Sniffer:
I suppose I best be giving my support see? Well to tell the truth I found this decision to be pretty hard, but not for the reasons you think see, I trust a few folks here and garner them with my full support and If I so wished I would support multiple people, but since I can only choose one im gonna Support ClawgripFan9001 see, the fellows been an integeral part of our investigation so far, providing facts rebuttals and overall support to many individuals in this quest of ours see, cant imagine a game without him see, infact the reason I havent talked as much as I should is because he alongside that Sholmès fellow do a much better job at chipping away at things than I could, however I will put in more effort to the team going forward when it comes to investigatein see.
- Pronouns
- She/her
…such as? I don't have any other action to take that could aid me in this time.
Lee Chaolan
Oh, excellent!
Just to clear something up, I double checked my results with the host and it appears that I didn't get roleblocked or else my role would have "failed", this didn't happen, so your observation must be correct, it was instead Cocoa's role that didn't allow me to interact with them.
I'm inclined to side with what Rose is saying here, the out of the blue role claim was already odd and I was leaning more on them making a misplay, but now it seems evident that they're just straight up lying about their role. Obviously we can't vote for elimination this phase, if I could this is where I'd be going, but I'm very curious as to what Cocoa's response is here.
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Ninja Squid
- Thread starter
- #283
Vote tally:
Roserade (2) - Waluigi Time, Cloudwalker
Yoshi the SSM (1) - Reverse Input
Reverse Input (1) - Ninelevendo
Power Flotzo (1) - Yoshi the SSM
Cosmic Cowboy (1) - Hooded Pitohui
Waluigi Time (1) - Roserade
ClawgripFan9001 (1) - Boo1268
Boo1268 (0)
Hooded Pitohui (0)
Cloudwalker (0)
Ninelevendo (0)
BigBoom1946 (0)
No vote (3) -ClawgripFan9001, Power Flotzo, Cosmic Cowboy, BigBoom1946
24 hours remain...
Day 4 ends .
Roserade (2) - Waluigi Time, Cloudwalker
Yoshi the SSM (1) - Reverse Input
Reverse Input (1) - Ninelevendo
Power Flotzo (1) - Yoshi the SSM
Cosmic Cowboy (1) - Hooded Pitohui
Waluigi Time (1) - Roserade
ClawgripFan9001 (1) - Boo1268
Boo1268 (0)
Hooded Pitohui (0)
Cloudwalker (0)
Ninelevendo (0)
BigBoom1946 (0)
No vote (3) -
24 hours remain...
Day 4 ends .
Power Flotzo
the gun member of the coconut crew
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Power Flotzo
Okay, since the vote count's been brought up, I suppose I'll cast my vote for the guy with the sword, since several people are hinting at him being innocent and he seems to be making plenty of good points.
I just wish those points were mine, y'know?
Support: Ninelevendo
I just wish those points were mine, y'know?
Support: Ninelevendo
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Hooded Pitohui
- Pronouns
- They
- MarioWiki
- Roserade
@Shmaluigi, swap your vote over to the nose.
If the suit is an Investigator like they've claimed this entire time, they'll keep their vote on me. If they insist on casting me into the lower lot, that'll be just as telling.
And for the sake of fairness, @BigBoom1946. If you make an appearance by the end of today, you need to vote for someone who has zero votes in the tally above you (besides Ninelevendo, who just got a vote after). I'd recommend you select Cloudwalker or Hooded Pitohui, but it is ultimately up to you.
Shmaluigi
Private Investigator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Poll Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
- Pronouns
- He/him
"Alright, that's enough fun for today! You can have your rodent back. Hehahaho!"
Uh... That was weird. Looks like I missed a lot.
Can't say I trust the suit farther than I can throw 'em - but I can't argue with this plan.
Support: Boo1268
Just know I won't be letting any last-minute betrayals off easy if things don't go smoothly here.
- Pronouns
- She/her
- Pronouns
- She/her
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Ninja Squid
- Thread starter
- #290
Yes, it's possible. For example, I once played a Mafia game where both the Inno and Mafia sides had a Roleblocker. (See Pokémon Masters Mafia)
Naturally, I say this without confirming anything about RiR2's setup (which I can't).
- Pronouns
- She/her
Understood. Well, I had something to say, but this seems to throw it out the window.
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Hooded Pitohui
- Pronouns
- She/her
Would it be possible for you to prove innocence of mine by "hiding behind me"? It would be quite nice to have me outside of suspicion.
And if you die, it'd be very clear I am a villain in this game. (This is a hypothetical. Do not take this as confirmation of traitorous intent.)
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Hooded Pitohui
- Pronouns
- She/her
Not to be rude, but could this not be a big mistake? As I am considered quite suspicious, would you not like to know if eliminating me is an error? You could easily confirm a villain if it goes awry, also.
If I am confirmed innocent, we could take a further look at those who claim me treacherous, as well.
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Hooded Pitohui
- Pronouns
- She/her
I may be spending my last moments attempting to figure out what you mean by that.
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Ninja Squid
- Thread starter
- #298
Day 4 is over. Voting is now locked.
An update will be provided shortly.
An update will be provided shortly.
- Pronouns
- He/him
- MarioWiki
- Ninja Squid
- Thread starter
- #299
Vote tally:
Roserade (1) - Cloudwalker
Yoshi the SSM (1) - Reverse Input
Reverse Input (1) - Ninelevendo
Power Flotzo (1) - Yoshi the SSM
Waluigi Time (1) - Roserade
ClawgripFan9001 (1) - Boo1268
Boo1268 (1) - Waluigi Time
Ninelevendo (1) - Power Flotzo
Cosmic Cowboy (1) - Hooded Pitohui
Hooded Pitohui (0)
Cloudwalker (0)
BigBoom1946 (0)
No vote (2) -ClawgripFan9001, Cosmic Cowboy, BigBoom1946
BigBoom1946 was eliminated. He was...
For full transparency, I have made the firm decision to remove BigBoom1946 from the game due to a severe lack of activity, even after having been warned for remaining inactive through a full Day/Night cycle. Despite this, they made practically no effort to remedy the situation.
Therefore, between eliminating a player between Cloudwalker and Pitohui who both have actively contributed throughout the game or removing someone who simply does not participate and could, in the long term, harm their side if they were to reach the endgame, I prefer to keep active players involved.
In hindsight, I should have removed them at the start of Day 4, when no one had been killed. At this point though, I believe I was lenient enough.
This was no easy decision, but I hope you understand. Thank you!
We are now on Night 4.
Please, submit privately your night actions.
The phase ends .
Roserade (1) - Cloudwalker
Yoshi the SSM (1) - Reverse Input
Reverse Input (1) - Ninelevendo
Power Flotzo (1) - Yoshi the SSM
Waluigi Time (1) - Roserade
ClawgripFan9001 (1) - Boo1268
Boo1268 (1) - Waluigi Time
Ninelevendo (1) - Power Flotzo
Cosmic Cowboy (1) - Hooded Pitohui
Hooded Pitohui (0)
Cloudwalker (0)
BigBoom1946 (0)
No vote (2) -
BigBoom1946 was eliminated. He was...
For full transparency, I have made the firm decision to remove BigBoom1946 from the game due to a severe lack of activity, even after having been warned for remaining inactive through a full Day/Night cycle. Despite this, they made practically no effort to remedy the situation.
Therefore, between eliminating a player between Cloudwalker and Pitohui who both have actively contributed throughout the game or removing someone who simply does not participate and could, in the long term, harm their side if they were to reach the endgame, I prefer to keep active players involved.
In hindsight, I should have removed them at the start of Day 4, when no one had been killed. At this point though, I believe I was lenient enough.
This was no easy decision, but I hope you understand. Thank you!
We are now on Night 4.
Please, submit privately your night actions.
The phase ends .
- Pronouns
- He/Him |Boo1268
Shmalu Sniffer:
Well that was...Disapointing see, the one guy who didnt do anything had the most useful ability see, how unfortunate.