Rosalina vs. Peach who would win a battle?

[LeftyGreenMario]

They're both ditzy party animals now.

 

[Mcmadness]

Why is this even a question? Rosalina is a powerful universe being. If you think about it, she's perhaps the most powerful Mario character.

Considering how Bowser was able to over power and steal her comet's power and she called to Mario for help, I don't think she's quite as all powerful as people think she is.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

It's clearly Mario that's the powerful one if some space goddess was humbled by his mere 100-times-defeated arch-nemesis and had to turn to him for assistance.

 

[Koops]

Battle won't even take place then. Mario nukes everyone before they're able to say anything.

With a bazooka.

 

[Mcmadness]

100-times-defeated arch-nemesis

We should really put together like, a science team to make a count of how many times Mario has defeated Bowser across the whole franchise.

 

[Ray Trace]

That's not to count the times Bowser was defeated by another character.

 

[Starlight24]

Why is this even a question? Rosalina is a powerful universe being. If you think about it, she's perhaps the most powerful Mario character.

Considering how Bowser was able to over power and steal her comet's power and she called to Mario for help, I don't think she's quite as all powerful as people think she is.

Um? Rosalina did not call for Mario for ''help''.

He landed in a planet and was brought to Rosalina by the Lumas to essencially do the dirty work and for the grand finale Rosalina saved everybody.

the end.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

Rosalina needed Mario's help and Mario needed Rosalina's help. But it's still funny to think that Rosalina couldn't defeat Bowser without Mario.

 

[Mcmadness]

Um? Rosalina did not call for Mario for ''help''.

He landed in a planet and was brought to Rosalina by the Lumas to essencially do the dirty work and for the grand finale Rosalina saved everybody.

the end.

No, the Lumas saved everyone. The most Rosalina did was move the observatory. Besides that she did sweet FA all game.

And that's not even getting into Galaxy 2 where the entire observatory with her on it was held captive by Bowser.

She's clearly more of an administrator than any kind of super powerful being.

 

[LeftyGreenMario]

At least Peach can bake a goddamn cake.

 

[Koops]

Ah yes.

Scientifically speaking everyone in the entire Marioverse is magnetized to came whenever it's brought up, making it the most OP weapon in the games.

Which is why that minigame from Super Mario Party has you throwing pies because otherwise it's an instant draw.

 

[Starlight24]

Um? Rosalina did not call for Mario for ''help''.

He landed in a planet and was brought to Rosalina by the Lumas to essencially do the dirty work and for the grand finale Rosalina saved everybody.

the end.

No, the Lumas saved everyone. The most Rosalina did was move the observatory. Besides that she did sweet FA all game.

And that's not even getting into Galaxy 2 where the entire observatory with her on it was held captive by Bowser.

She's clearly more of an administrator than any kind of super powerful being.

She commanded them to do what they did, they did not do anything at will. So yeah it was Rosalina who ultimately did it.

Besides Bowser doing or not doing stuff means nothing more than plot devices, and with that i mean that they conveniently make other characters seem ''passive'' for Mario to shine more and ultimately beat Bowser , kinda why we know Peach can sorta defend herself but still gets captured by Bowser every other game.

If Rosalina somehow does not use her full powers is either because the game favors Mario or because she doesnt want to but not because she isn't powerful, even more compared to Peach in this context.

Even in the worst scenario, Rosalina still kicked Bowser's ass in SM3DW so anyways.

 

[Mcmadness]

She is never seen commanding them. They just show up after the blackhole goes nuts and then they stop it. The most we see of her is explaining that whole crying baby star nonsense.

Though you are correct that this series will make anybody stronger or weaker for the sake of the scenario. That being said for the Galaxy games I see no reason to believe she is more powerful than how she was presented within the context of those specific games.

Also nobody kicked Bowser's ass in SM3DW. He was stupid enough (as usual) to stand on a pow block and you don't even unlock Rosalina till after the game is over so it's debatable if she even technically encountered him within the context of that game.