Which Mario game has the most disappointing character roster?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Xiahou Ba

Xiahou Ba

いやいやいや
Awards Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
Poll Consultant
Pronouns
She/her He/him
I'd say Mario Sports Mix or Mario Tennis Open. Mario Tennis Open gets the edge for excluding someone, you know, but Sports Mix's character roster is also pret-ty bad since they made a ton of cuts, all who are Mario characters, while only including Toad and Slime.

Anyone wanna share their sour little thoughts? :P

Btw worst =/= disappointing. We all know that a 4 character roster made in the NES days are awful, today but you know, it was really reasonable and awesome at the time.
 
^Yes, but there's a few good characters like Lakitu and Toadette.

I really disliked Mario Party 9's roster, mainly because they cut Toadette and Hammer Bro., I am fine with Koopa and Shy Guy but it just seemed like a bad roster in my opinion.
 
New Super Mario Bros. U. Sorry but putting the same Toad colors as in New Super Mario Bros. Wii with no new character (and I don't want to call Mii a real character) is a big disappointment.
 
Pretty much all recent Mario rosters have been pretty bad for the most part. The best one is World Tour, though. Everything you need, nothing you don't.

except gold mario and maybe nabbit but w/e
 
YoshiGo99 said:
I really disliked Mario Party 9's roster, mainly because they cut Toadette and Hammer Bro., I am fine with Koopa and Shy Guy but it just seemed like a bad roster in my opinion.
Click to expand...

Yeah I hate Mario Party 9's roster. It felt like a gigantic step backwards.
 
The Mario golf games on the gbc and gba have soul crushingly disappointing rosters.
 
Mcmadness said:
The Mario golf games on the gbc and gba have soul crushingly disappointing rosters.
Click to expand...

But Bowser is technically playable in the GBA version
 
Thats not why they are disappointing. Though that didn't help.
 
Aren't those rosters have like only 4 Mario characters and the other billion are generic humans?
 
MK8. Gone are Birdo, Diddy, Junior, Dry Bones, and King Boo. Instead we have seven koopalings, another baby, and pink gold Peach.