...I just explained how Paper Mario can be a different character. He's only similar to Mario in appearance, very different from Mario than Toon/Young Link from Link, Falco/Wolf from Fox, Ganondorf from Captain Falcon, Lucas from Ness, and even Luigi from Mario moveset wise.
My Improved Roster!
- Thread starter New Super Mario
- Start date
Anser
King Bowser
I still don't get what's wrong with having the same character two times in the same game as long as they're completely different in both appearance and moveset. It's not like we're trying to make Paper Mario like Young/Toon Link, you know. Who cares if Paper Mario is Mario too? It's a different version. He looks different and would surely have a unique moveset.
I wouldn't complain about having Bowser Jr. or Waluigi. Bowser Jr. has earned his right to make his appearance and is now an important character in the series and Waluigi, while he hasn't appeared in main games, has appeared in almost every single spin-off which makes him a Nintendo star already. Even though Rosalina is my favorite character, I think she's still very unpopular to appear. Maybe as an Assist Trophy.
I wouldn't complain about having Bowser Jr. or Waluigi. Bowser Jr. has earned his right to make his appearance and is now an important character in the series and Waluigi, while he hasn't appeared in main games, has appeared in almost every single spin-off which makes him a Nintendo star already. Even though Rosalina is my favorite character, I think she's still very unpopular to appear. Maybe as an Assist Trophy.
- Pronouns
- She/her
- MarioWiki
- Ray Trace
The problem is that I would want some roster variety. The addition of Toon Link, Young Link (even though I like him), and other versions of existing characters make the characters look redundant, whether they have differing movesets or not. I don't think Paper Mario represents the Mario series well. If anything, and hypothetically speaking, if Paper Mario does get in, he should represent his own series.
Dorayaki
King Bowser
I quite like Paper Mario, but the concern of other Mario characters is also the problem, so I'm neutral with it if PM really becomes playable.
It seems not doing with Waluigi or BowserJr. if Toad, Birdo or KingK.Rool are prior to them. For Waluigi, he can't represent Mario series, and he can represent Wario games but he didn't have enough appearances in them.
It seems not doing with Waluigi or BowserJr. if Toad, Birdo or KingK.Rool are prior to them. For Waluigi, he can't represent Mario series, and he can represent Wario games but he didn't have enough appearances in them.
Anser
King Bowser
Dorayaki said:
Now that you say it, no. It really doesn't. But personally, I'd like that Mario, Zelda and Pokémon, as they are Nintendo's biggest franchises, have 5 representants. I would put Mario, Luigi, Peach, Bowser, Bowser Jr./Paper Mario for the Mario series, Link, Zelda/Sheik, Ganondorf, Toon Link and Toon Zelda/Tetra (given she was partially programmed in Brawl) for the Zelda series and Pikachu, Jigglypuff, Lucario, Pokémon Trainer (with Charizard, Ivysaur and Squirtle) and Mewtwo for Pokémon.
supermariofan
Dry Bowser
How do you make a roster?
New Super Mario
Ghirahim
- Thread starter
- #65
Digimon? Seriously that has no chance. Street Fighter is laughable at. I mean, it's its own fighting game already. Clay Fighter I don't even know what that is. Dante? Bomberman, maybe, but I don't think his chances are too likely. I think Rayman would be cool, but seems unlikely as well. Banjo, eh..... Probably not gonna happen. And I don't know who Bub and Bob are.Ghostony said:Banjo, Rayman, Bub/Bob, Bomberman, a digimon, a Street Fighter, a Clay Fighter, and the real Dante since playstation messed up.
How's that for something new?
inb4mad@3rdparties
supermariofan
Dry Bowser
Taito is owned by Square Enix now, and if we're getting a Square Enix rep it's gonna be either:Proto Man said:
Sora
Geno
Black Mage
Slime
New Super Mario
Ghirahim
- Thread starter
- #68
Updated it:
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
supermariofan
Dry Bowser
Crash and Spyro are both Activision pick only one, Toad is technically a generic character in the Mario series I don't think he could have a good moveset, the Baby Bros would share the same problems Pichu had, I don't think another Link is necessary even if they are from different timelines, and an Animal Crossing character is unnecessaryGhirahim said:Updated it:
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
New Super Mario
Ghirahim
- Thread starter
- #70
NO! In this roster, that are Insomniac Games and Naughty Dog. Activision sucks. If I did pick one though, I'd have to boot Crash.supermariofan said:Crash and Spyro are both Activision pick only oneGhirahim said:Updated it:
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
supermariofan
Dry Bowser
Insomniac Games is not a big company, why did you bring up Naughty Dog? First they don't own Crash anymore, and two Naughty Dog is owned by SonyGhirahim said:NO! In this roster, that are Insomniac Games and Naughty Dog. Activision sucks. If I did pick one though, I'd have to boot Crash.supermariofan said:Crash and Spyro are both Activision pick only oneGhirahim said:Updated it:
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
New Super Mario
Ghirahim
- Thread starter
- #72
Original Crash was made by Naughty Dog. Original Spyro was made by Insomniac Games. They were actually good than. I'm not going to let Activision's versions in there...... And besides, they have no chance anyway....... But, it's a dream of mine.supermariofan said:Insomniac Games is not a big company, why did you bring up Naughty Dog? First they don't own Crash anymore, and two Naughty Dog is owned by SonyGhirahim said:NO! In this roster, that are Insomniac Games and Naughty Dog. Activision sucks. If I did pick one though, I'd have to boot Crash.supermariofan said:Crash and Spyro are both Activision pick only oneGhirahim said:Updated it:
Just switched some things out. Was going to make a big fancy one in gimp, but sadly I made a huge mistake and didn't feel like starting the whole thing over.
PrincessOfPeaches
Oh, did I win?
A pretty good roster I must say, but a little bit too many third-party members for my taste.
... And if Young Link still is a Link clone, then I would rather have Skull Kid or something.
... And if Young Link still is a Link clone, then I would rather have Skull Kid or something.
New Super Mario
Ghirahim
- Thread starter
- #74
Well, really the only third parties I expect were the other three, and Spyro and Crash are most of a wish list kinda thing.PrincessOfPeaches said:
And no, if you cared to read, I said Young Link would have a Mask-based moveset.