It's impossible to accurately predict which piece of violent media is going to inspire a madman to go on a murderous rampage, because the actions of psychotics are completely unpredictable; Charles Manson was inspired by a Beatles song, for instance. That's where the "oh games cause violence, we should ban them!" argument just falls apart.
Rather than blaming entertainment and artistic mediums, I think people should instead be focusing on better mental health care and gun control (I know this is a controversial subject for Americans, but the last mass shooting we've ever had in Australia came before we tightened gun control, which at least says it's worked wonders for us). Those really should be top priorities at this point.