PTR averages ratings on different Mario series

U

User4042

Celestial Guide
For now, I am doing New Super Mario Bros. and the Mario 3D games (not counting Super Mario 3D Land)
IGN

3D: 9.725
NSMB: 9


Gamespot

3D: 9.225
NSMB: 8.25



PTR's comments

Hmmm, apparently the 3D games are better than the NSMB games for the reviewers.
 
Super Mario Galaxy 2 beats New Super Mario Bros. 2 by a mile
 
And Super Mario Galaxy 2 isn't even that good in the first place
 
New Year Baby Luigi said:
And Super Mario Galaxy 2 isn't even that good in the first place
Click to expand...

apparently it's worse than galaxy so thats sad.
 
Yeah, it's just Super Mario Galaxy but with different levels. I don't know how that qualifies as great when the engine and mechanics are exactly the same
 
New Year Baby Luigi said:
Yeah, it's just Super Mario Galaxy but with different levels. I don't know how that qualifies as great when the engine and mechanics are exactly the same
Click to expand...

wow thats bad.

and this is somehow rated more than sms and sm64ds? sheessh.
 
Joltik said:
New Year Baby Luigi said:
Yeah, it's just Super Mario Galaxy but with different levels. I don't know how that qualifies as great when the engine and mechanics are exactly the same
Click to expand...

wow thats bad.

and this is somehow rated more than sms and sm64ds? sheessh.
Click to expand...
I used the ratings from the original.
 
Squirtle said:
Joltik said:
New Year Baby Luigi said:
Yeah, it's just Super Mario Galaxy but with different levels. I don't know how that qualifies as great when the engine and mechanics are exactly the same
Click to expand...

wow thats bad.

and this is somehow rated more than sms and sm64ds? sheessh.
Click to expand...
I used the ratings from the original.
Click to expand...

but didn't most people enjoy sm64ds more?

I'd be surprised if they didn't.