Unpopular opinions about the Mario series

And even by excuse plot standards it's dumb.

WRONG PARENTS, HERE WE GO AGAIN
 
Baby Luigi said:
My unpopular opinion is that we also seek and destroy every copy of Yoshi's New Island so society would get a huge benefit from burning them.

(if that "story" is correct, that means that Baby Luigi literally gets kidnapped as soon as he gets rescued...honestly I think they just tied in those two plots in the most incohesive manner because they lack talent and wanted to ---- over anyone who has beaten the original Yoshi's Island and Baby Luigi fans aka me)
Click to expand...
but wouldnt burning yni copies harm society because of the amounts of co2 let out
 
Not as much as Warping through space and time would.
 
Mcmadness said:
And even by excuse plot standards it's dumb.

WRONG PARENTS, HERE WE GO AGAIN
Click to expand...

[complaining about mario continuity]Not only that, it completely renders one of my favorite games of all time entirely pointless. I remember beating the original Yoshi's Island way back when and felt completely satisfied seeing the ending. Beating the kickass final boss and the whole "Heroes are born!" at the end just made me feel good and left a lasting impression on me for many years.

then new island comes along and is all "lol nope our silly stork dropped the babies off at the wrong house ha ha oops"

It's like it just shat all over my warm and fuzzy childhood memories. If the game actually new, interesting, and not a bland rehash it wouldn't have bothered me nearly as bad.[/complaining about mario continuity]
 
As I said, this plot twist exists is because the writers are as incompetent as hell and don't know how to make an interesting plot twist without shatting all over people's childhoods

and also shatting over baby luigi fans aka me but I digress
 
you know, yoshi story and woolly world had the right idea, just don't have the babies around to be kidnapped.

YNI already had a perfectly acceptable scenario with that egg island being taken over by Baby Bowser, they really didn't need to retcon the end of YI like that.

In fact as far as I'm concerned thats all that happened in that game, no wrong delivery, no warping through space and time king bowser, just a simple island invasion.
 
Mcmadness said:
you know, yoshi story and woolly world had the right idea, just don't have the babies around to be kidnapped.
Click to expand...

or better yet, make them playable characters that platform alongside yoshi
 
Like in YIDS!

Except for a certain somebody.
 
sitting on yoshi's back isn't exactly being "playable"

I mean like player 2 or something
 
wouldn't really work though considering yoshi plays much differently.
 
they could get creative and find ways around it

i mean, they got freaking gooey playable in a kirby game