What's the most overrated/underrated Mario game out there?

[Lemmy Koopa Fan]

So what do you think? I think the most overrated is Super Mario Galaxy or New Super Mario Bros. Wii. And I think the most underrated game is... Hotel Mario. Don't get me wrong, it does suck. But I think it deserves more 3.5 than 1.1...

 

[Lario]

You're right on both of those.

 

[Aiko Heiwa]

Overrated - Super Mario RPG</thread>

 

[ShyGuy27]

Overrated - Super Mario RPG</thread>

That, and SMB2 is underrated.

 

[Aiko Heiwa]

Overrated - Super Mario RPG</thread>

That, and SMB2 is underrated.

Yes.

 

[Time Turner]

SMG is overrated, SMS is underrated. Sue me, I prefer F.L.U.D.D. over Luma.

 

[Weasel]

Over'd: a tie between SMRPG and SMW
Under'd: Partners in Time

 

[Pokemon DP]

SMRPG

I agree. It was fun, but certainly wasn't the great game everyone was making it out to be.

 

[ShyGuy27]

Over'd: SMW

No wai.

 

[Uniju]

Over'd: a tie between SMRPG and SMW
Under'd: Partners in Time

Those must be typos...

 

[Snowstalker]

Overrated: SMB (started it all, but sue me; now it doesn't seem as hot)
Underrated: SMW (Great game or greatest game?)

 

[Lario]

SMW vs. DKC2

Well, they're both the best in their own series.

 

[Noahp89]

SMRPG

I agree. It was fun, but certainly wasn't the great game everyone was making it out to be.

I third that.
Oh yeah, and SMB2 is under-rated as Shyguy said.

 

[Aiko Heiwa]

SMRPG

I agree. It was fun, but certainly wasn't the great game everyone was making it out to be.

I third that.
Oh yeah, and SMB2 is under-rated as Shyguy said.

Seriously, that's one of my favorite Mario games.

 

[Nerdy Guy]

SMB2 is under-rated as Shyguy said.

Seriously, that's one of my favorite Mario games.

It's one of my favorites too.

 

[Aiko Heiwa]

SMB2 is under-rated as Shyguy said.

Seriously, that's one of my favorite Mario games.

It's one of my favorites too.

And I rarely play Mario games now.

 

[Easmo]

Over'd: a tie between SMRPG and SMW
Under'd: Partners in Time

Per.

Also:

Over´d: The N64 Mario Parties (really good but not that superior over the cube ones)
Under´d: The Cube Mario Parties (nowhere near as bad as people say).

 

[Rosalina Spalko]

The Wii Mario Party makes all Parties beforehand look like works of art.

-also-

Overrated - SMRPG (It's a great game, but I'd sooner play.....)

Underrated - SM3 (because it keeps getting bumped between world for it's awesomeness and 2 for it's underrated-ness)

 

[Garlic Man]

I thought SM3 was considered one of the greatest of all time



Overrated - SSBB. It's great and all but the online play sorta sucks. (Otherwise, it's awesome)

Underrated - Super Mario Sunshine. People always seem to compare it to Super Mario 64 and Galaxy so it tends to become overshadowed, but I still enjoyed playing that game a lot.

 

[Lario]

Funny how some find SMS overrated...

 

[Garlic Man]

Weird. I once saw an advert about SMG that said "Everything from Super Mario 64 you loved, without everything from Super Mario Sunshine you hated!"



I think Super Paper Mario is also underrated...

 

[Uniju]

"Everything from Super Mario 64 you loved, without everything from Super Mario Sunshine you hated!"

That's weird, since Galaxy plays a lot like Super Mario Sunshine with a new gimmick. I'm not hating on Galaxy, it's great, but it just feels a lot more like Sunshine than it does like 64.

I think Super Paper Mario is also underrated...

That's like saying Luigi is underrated: It's the opposite of true, but for some reason a lot of people do it.

 

[Garlic Man]

Well when I say that Super Paper Mario was better than PM2, people try to shoot me.

 

[Uniju]

That's because you deserve it!

 

[Garlic Man]

With nerf guns!


on-topic: I would say Super Mario 64 DS is overrated.