What's the most overrated/underrated Mario game out there?

Lemmy Koopa Fan

Koopa Troopa
So what do you think? I think the most overrated is Super Mario Galaxy or New Super Mario Bros. Wii. And I think the most underrated game is... Hotel Mario. Don't get me wrong, it does suck. But I think it deserves more 3.5 than 1.1...
 

Pokemon DP

God I'm good at being an owl
Retired Wiki Staff
Kaptain K. Rool said:
I agree. It was fun, but certainly wasn't the great game everyone was making it out to be.
 

Uniju

Hazukashii serifu kinshi
Kaptain K. Rool said:
Over'd: a tie between SMRPG and SMW
Under'd: Partners in Time
Those must be typos...
 

Snowstalker

Snowstalker
Overrated: SMB (started it all, but sue me; now it doesn't seem as hot)
Underrated: SMW (Great game or greatest game?)
 

Easmo

Bob-omb
Kaptain K. Rool said:
Over'd: a tie between SMRPG and SMW
Under'd: Partners in Time
Per.

Also:

Over´d: The N64 Mario Parties (really good but not that superior over the cube ones)
Under´d: The Cube Mario Parties (nowhere near as bad as people say).
 

Rosalina Spalko

I'm just confused as you are.
The Wii Mario Party makes all Parties beforehand look like works of art.

-also-

Overrated - SMRPG (It's a great game, but I'd sooner play.....)

Underrated - SM3 (because it keeps getting bumped between world for it's awesomeness and 2 for it's underrated-ness)
 

Garlic Man

Name-change free since 2018
I thought SM3 was considered one of the greatest of all time



Overrated - SSBB. It's great and all but the online play sorta sucks. (Otherwise, it's awesome)

Underrated - Super Mario Sunshine. People always seem to compare it to Super Mario 64 and Galaxy so it tends to become overshadowed, but I still enjoyed playing that game a lot.
 

Garlic Man

Name-change free since 2018
Weird. I once saw an advert about SMG that said "Everything from Super Mario 64 you loved, without everything from Super Mario Sunshine you hated!"



I think Super Paper Mario is also underrated...
 

Uniju

Hazukashii serifu kinshi
Kinniku Man said:
"Everything from Super Mario 64 you loved, without everything from Super Mario Sunshine you hated!"
That's weird, since Galaxy plays a lot like Super Mario Sunshine with a new gimmick. I'm not hating on Galaxy, it's great, but it just feels a lot more like Sunshine than it does like 64.
Kinniku Man said:
I think Super Paper Mario is also underrated...
That's like saying Luigi is underrated: It's the opposite of true, but for some reason a lot of people do it.
 

Garlic Man

Name-change free since 2018
Well when I say that Super Paper Mario was better than PM2, people try to shoot me.
 

Uniju

Hazukashii serifu kinshi
That's because you deserve it!
 

Garlic Man

Name-change free since 2018
With nerf guns!


on-topic: I would say Super Mario 64 DS is overrated.
 
Top