What game has the darkest theme?

What game has the darkest theme?

  • Paper Mario: The Thousand-Year Door

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Super Paper Mario

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
  • Poll closed .

Xzelion

Join us in the shadows where we stand vigilant...
Retired Wiki Staff
Which one of these games have the darkest theme?
 

Xzelion

Join us in the shadows where we stand vigilant...
Retired Wiki Staff
Not to double post but I'll go with PiT.
 

maledict

Hammer Bro.
I vote for the thousand years door, the places were very calm and lonely, ghost toad and the way of killing you, the pit of 100 trials, the shadow palace and the introduction of the shadow queeny
 

yoshster

Whomp
I've only played superstar saga and SMRPG but I've reed a walktrough of PMTTYD, it's theme was pretty dark
 

YellowYoshi398

King Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
Yeah, my vote goes for TTYD. I haven't played much of SPM, but so far Mario hasn't fought any demons or interacted with street gangs.
 

Sir Grodus

King Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
:bobomb: SPOILER ALERT :bobomb:

Super Paper Mario, I mean, c'mon, Luigi is brainwashed into being a bad guy, the tragic love story of Lord Blumier/Count Bleck and Lady Timpani/Tippi, the whole Mario equivalent of Hell, etc. Not to mention the whole Count Bleck was going to commit mass, mass, mass genocide and destroy everything.

:bobomb: END SPOILERS :bobomb:
 

YellowYoshi398

King Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
I didn't read whatever that spoiler was, but I'm assuming it totally PWNED me and my comment about SPM lacking demons and street gangs.
 

3Dejong

THIS PERSONAL TEXT IS SILLY!
I saw the entire story and all bosses on SPM on Youtube (MAJOR SPOILERS! RUN!) and yeah, SPM is DARK. But TTYD is darker. DEMONS, DUDES. Bleck is nothing with Shadow Queen. She's pure evil. DUDE.
 

Plumber

Tenacious Trio
Retired Wiki Staff
Well, the destruction of multiple universes and dimensions is pretty big too.....Plus he has his cane
 
Plumber said:
Well, the destruction of multiple universes and dimensions is pretty big too.....Plus he has his cane
A CANE!! :shock: :shock: :lol:
and luigi goes bad (Mr. L) sammer guys die....
 

maledict

Hammer Bro.
3dejong said:
I saw the entire story and all bosses on SPM on Youtube (MAJOR SPOILERS! RUN!) and yeah, SPM is DARK. But TTYD is darker. DEMONS, DUDES. Bleck is nothing with Shadow Queen. She's pure evil. DUDE.
spoiler alert!!!!!!!!!!




and don't forget that almos every place were very lonely, like reverside station and posley satum, the music of the pit, ghost toad and the music of shadow peach was astonishing
 

kappa16

Monty Mole
Sir Grodus said:
:bobomb: SPOILER ALERT :bobomb:

Super Paper Mario, I mean, c'mon, Luigi is brainwashed into being a bad guy, the tragic love story of Lord Blumier/Count Bleck and Lady Timpani/Tippi, the whole Mario equivalent of Hell, etc. Not to mention the whole Count Bleck was going to commit mass, mass, mass genocide and destroy everything.

:bobomb: END SPOILERS :bobomb:
I agree with Sir Grodus... I watched people playing the game on YouTube (Becasuse I can't afford to buy the Wii and play it myself :P ) and the storyline does seem very dark... Darker than I'd expect from a Super Mario game...
 

Sir Grodus

King Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
It's funny, but Cyrus from Pokémon Diamond and Pokémon Pearl had pretty much the same plan as Count Bleck; destroy the universe and make a newer, better one. Of course, Cyrus was a misanthropic sociopath and Count Bleck was simply demented with grief. Still, Count Bleck's plan of destroying everything and killing an infinite number of people seems to make Super Paper Mario one of the darkest of the Mario games.
 

Dreyfus2006

Koopa Troopa
Super Paper Mario has such a dark theme... I love it; especially...

SPOILERSPOILERSPOILER!!!!!

How Bleck and Tippi were in love, how Bleck and Tippi were seperated, cruel and sinister Dimentio, the destruction of Sammer's Kingdom (come ON people, that is MASS MURDER!), the World of Nothing (SUUUPER spooky at night), and even the amazing, deep surprise ending of Chapter 7.

ENDSPOILERENDSPOILERENDSPOILER!!!!!

Though I must say, Partners in Time had the darkest theme. Reminded me of horror films... Especially the stuff about sucking the life out of Toads... Creepy...

The Thousand-Year Door never struck me as a dark game, but now that I think of it it is A dark game, but not very dark; there are some dark themes, yes, but the great humor and wackiness sort of nulls the darkness. Doopliss was dark and spooky, for example...until he's actually met, then he's never dark nor spooky again. Grubba was one dark dude, though.

So anyway, my vote goes to Partners in Time.
 

Max2

King Bowser
I picked PiT. I mean, look at the poor toads in Toadwood forest!

In SPM, so what, the world was ending.

In PiT it was to, but much more painfully.
 

Sir Grodus

King Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
Max2 said:
In SPM, so what, the world was ending.
In Super Paper Mario, all the worlds were ending; as in, all of existance would be wiped out and nothing will be left; several... some really, really, really huge number of people would die.
 
Top