Super Mario RPG 2?

g.narron

#1 Mario And Koopalings Fan!!!!!!
Does anyone hope that the new unannounced game is Super Mario RPG 2?
 
N

Nerdy Guy

Guest
I highly doubt it is, SMRPG is too old for there to be a sequal nowadays.
 

g.narron

#1 Mario And Koopalings Fan!!!!!!
I thought there was a chance since all the fans of the original are wanting a sequel so bad i thought it would be perfect for the ds
 

Uniju

Hazukashii serifu kinshi
Oh god I hope not. I hated that game.
Besides, Paper Mario was already a semi-unofficial sequel.
 

Smashgoom202

Dry Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
Super Happy Nerd Time said:
I highly doubt it is, SMRPG is too old for there to be a sequal nowadays.
You're the first person I've every come across on the Internet to say that.
 

g.narron

#1 Mario And Koopalings Fan!!!!!!
Smashgoom202 said:
Super Happy Nerd Time said:
I highly doubt it is, SMRPG is too old for there to be a sequal nowadays.
You're the first person I've every come across on the Internet to say that.
You've got that right, the game is definetly not to old and it deserves a sequel!
 

Smashgoom202

Dry Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
g.narron said:
Smashgoom202 said:
Super Happy Nerd Time said:
I highly doubt it is, SMRPG is too old for there to be a sequal nowadays.
You're the first person I've every come across on the Internet to say that.
You've got that right, the game is definetly not to old and it deserves a sequel!
Well, I meant that he's the only one to say something like that, not that he doesn't have a point. Still, I don't really think it's too old. In fact, I dont' think it's old enough to get a sequel! Remember all those old games that are making a comeback? Super Mario RPG has to gain some sort of massive cult following and being unanimously popular to get a sequel, and even that won't guarantee anything.

Don't get me wrong, I'd love to see a sequel, but you have to think about just what it will be about. Think about what you want before you actually say it.
 

g.narron

#1 Mario And Koopalings Fan!!!!!!
It could tell about Geno after he went back to star road.
 

Smashgoom202

Dry Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
g.narron said:
It could tell about Geno after he went back to star road.
How would that make an interesting game? And besides, he's not possessing the Geno doll anymore, so he would just be some sort of weird twinkle star.
 
N

Noahp89

Guest
Herr Shyguy said:
SMRPG was lame.
It was okay, but I much prefer newer RPGs such as the Paper Mario and Mario and Luigi series.
I never restarted my file when my VC version was corrupt.
 

ShyGuy27

The Cardinal is dead -- long live The Cardinal!
It's not a terrible game, but there are so many better RPGs out there.
 

Super Mario Bros.

Oh boy! Haha!
Core 'Shroom Staff
Retired Wiki Staff
Herr Shyguy said:
It's not a terrible game, but there are so many better RPGs out there.
Don't forget that this game was made in 1996, and that the game looks excellent for the time it was released.
 

Uniju

Hazukashii serifu kinshi
I've always hated people who say things are good because they were considered good when they were new.
 

Smashgoom202

Dry Bowser
Retired Wiki Staff
Well, as long as we're complaining about this game, I might as well say I didn't like it that much. I haven't finished it yet, and I want to wait until I beat Smithy before I give it my final judgement, but I didn't like it that much. The camera and the jumping sections where the parts I hated the most, it got really annoying and frustrating after a while.
 

Luigifreak

OH YEAH!!! WALUIGI TIME!!!!
I want a new mario RPG, not a new SMRPG. We already have Mario RPG's with similar and (In my opinion) better formulas. So, a sequal to SMRPG would have to have a similar story. What can you do? Stuff with Geno. But, is there anything that geno can do that any other character can't do? No! I don't get the fanboyism for Geno. The only reason to bring back SMRPG is for the characters, and I thought the characters were only average.
 

SolarBlaze

Guardian of the Sol Emeralds.
Retired Wiki Staff
Waluigi said:
But, is there anything that geno can do that any other character can't do? No!
That's funny, I don't recall any of the other characters being able to shoot bullets out of their fingers.
 
they were making one but was replaced with the Paper Mario series, and in my opinion, is WAY Better overall... Super Paper Mario was a let down for me but they'll go back to the normal Paper Mario formula
 

Aiko Heiwa

Power Star
Banned User
Crackin355 said:
they were making one but was replaced with the Paper Mario series, and in my opinion, is WAY Better overall... Super Paper Mario was a let down for me but they'll go back to the normal Paper Mario formula
They were never making a sequel to SMRPG.

Paper Mario was going to be called Super Mario RPG 2, but due to legal complications with Square (now Square-Enix) they couldn't name the game Super Mario RPG 2 as Square owned the rights to the name Super Mario RPG.
 
in that case.... Thank GOD that they didnt name it that, otherwise i wouldnt have even considered playing it.
 
N

Nerdy Guy

Guest
Togepi said:
Crackin355 said:
in that case.... Thank GOD that they didnt name it that, otherwise i wouldnt have even considered playing it.
You're welcome. ;)
I see what you did there.
Unijuism-wise, you're not a god, you're just Jesus #2.

On-topic:
I don't really see them making a SMRPG 2. The game is too old for new one, and not old enough for a comeback.
 

Seteth

I have something to ask of you...
Chat Administrator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
Crackin355 said:
they were making one but was replaced with the Paper Mario series, and in my opinion, is WAY Better overall... Super Paper Mario was a let down for me but they'll go back to the normal Paper Mario formula
I didn't know that they plan to make any sequels. It seems unlikely to me somehow...
As for me, the first part was solid, but a little boring sometimes. The second one was a little more daring, ditched the central Mushroom Kingdom and Bowser as the main antagonist, and it worked. The game was great. The third part however overdid it. It went completely away from any relation to the Mushroom Kingdom, and replaced it with an abstract style. The game felt kinda cold and reserved to me...

And to topic:
It seems like I am one of the few persons who actually liked that game :-\
 

SolarBlaze

Guardian of the Sol Emeralds.
Retired Wiki Staff
No, you're not. I like that game, too, and I don't understand all the hate for it in this topic.
 
Top