Osu! I am Hariyama Deluxe, here to root out the source of the evil with my powerful arm thrusts! My stats are double those of a regular Hariyama, including 288 HP and 240 Attack. Now let us begin the voting!
Xiahou Ba: As funny as it is to roll the dice and have the first person be executed at pure random and turns out that he was mafia, a massive boon for us all if we are lucky, the chances of that are not in our favor. It's around a quarter chance, which is roughly the same odds as landing an OHKO move like Horn Drill or Guillotine. We risk executing someone with a pivotal role to the game on the flipside, whether it's a doctor, or a cop, or maybe a suicide bomber or a bulletproof, or any other role, and we just cannot risk taking that gamble without any information.
It's best we wait until helpful roles are done in the night, action is taken, information is gleaned, and see who gets murdered on the night phase before we make a decision. Scouting is the least risky play we can do.
Some of you may die but it's a sacrifice we are willing to make.
"It appears I find myself amidst a party of like-minded investigators, as the majority of them are in agreement that playing it safe during the first day of the investigation is the way to go when we have very little in the way of information to go off of. The moment the dark sacred night sets in, we must make use of our wit and skill, and the resourcefulness of our Pokémon and their powers to gather what information we can to bring back once the night yields to the breaking dawn. I do find myself in agreement Xiahou Ba that some of the investigators might have their lifeblood shed by the thieves that dwell within our presence, but that is a chance we must be willing to take. For if we do triumph over the outlaws in the end, the martyr's blood of the fallen investigators shall water the meadows of Johto, as a symbol that those who perished in their line of duty shall always be remembered for their bravery and courage."