SMG vs. SMS

Which game is better? Super Mario Galaxy or Super Mario Sunshine?

  • Super Mario Galaxy

    Votes: 15 60.0%
  • Super Mario Sunshine

    Votes: 4 16.0%
  • Both were horrible

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Both were equally amazing

    Votes: 6 24.0%

  • Total voters
    25

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
Personally, I like SMS better because of the format. I liked traveling to each world by warp pipe or graffiti. I also like Isle Delfino better than the Comet Observatory. Also, I do not like the extra comets like the purple coin comet and the daredevil comet. I wish it was just regular galaxies with just 3 stages in each galaxy. I like the idea of stars and power stars, but I also like the idea of Shine Sprites. The SMG final boss fight was WAAAYYYY more challenging than the sad "hot tub in Corona Mountain where you use a rocket to pound a spot on the ground while Bowser Jr. shoots stuff at you"
 
N

Nerdy Guy

Guest
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
Why?
Galaxy had a better camera, more areas, an extra “play as Luigi” mode that is harder than the mario mode, etc.
 

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
Why?
Galaxy had a better camera, more areas, an extra “play as Luigi” mode that is harder than the mario mode, etc.
I still like SMS better.
I see.
What does that supposed to mean? Not trying to be rude, just wondering.
 

Xluidi

beep bep boop
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
Why?
Galaxy had a better camera, more areas, an extra “play as Luigi” mode that is harder than the mario mode, etc.
I still like SMS better.
I see.
What does that supposed to mean? Not trying to be rude, just wondering.
I think he means you're being a fanboy.
 
N

Nerdy Guy

Guest
Xpike said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
Why?
Galaxy had a better camera, more areas, an extra “play as Luigi” mode that is harder than the mario mode, etc.
I still like SMS better.
I see.
What does that supposed to mean? Not trying to be rude, just wondering.
I think he means you're being a fanboy.
No,no,no
I use a different context, I'm just saying I see what he's saying.
 

SolarBlaze

Guardian of the Sol Emeralds.
Retired Wiki Staff
Pronouns
He/him
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
This. I like Super Mario Sunshine, but there's just no denying the fact that Super Mario Galaxy was better than it in almost every possible way.
 

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Xpike said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
≥£®∂¥ ₲Ú¥ said:
Luigi+Daisyfan11 said:
Flailing Dark Boo said:
Super Mario Galaxy. No contest.
Why?
Galaxy had a better camera, more areas, an extra “play as Luigi” mode that is harder than the mario mode, etc.
I still like SMS better.
I see.
What does that supposed to mean? Not trying to be rude, just wondering.
I think he means you're being a fanboy.
No,no,no
I use a different context, I'm just saying I see what he's saying.
Oh, thank you.
 

Weasel

Donkey Kong
Retired Forum Mod
Pronouns
He/him
Both were great. I do have 1 small gripe with Sunshine, though:



The hell happened to Boo? :-\
 

Easmo

Bob-omb
As much as I like both, Galaxy is better in every possible way, although Sunshine´s more "adventure" style (opossed to Galaxy´s more familiar "point A to point B" style) should also be taken on count. Both games are awesome.

I mean, the fact that one game is better than the other doesn´t mean the other is bad, just "less good" but still good. It´s like when you compare Metroid Hunters to the other Metroid games, or Minish Cap to the other Zelda games... they are the least good in a series of freaking awesome games, which still makes them very good games.
 

Smiddle

Power Star
Pronouns
He/him
Brie Loader said:
Metal Man said:
Both were great. I do have 1 small gripe with Sunshine, though:



The hell happened to Boo? :-\
That was a freaking awesome redesign
I thought Nintendo intended not to have any references to alcohol in their games, but w/e.

Anyway, SMG is our easy winner for me. Mainly because I didn't quite like FLUDD, but there are other reasons.
 

IzadoreSoap

Izador Soap:Dreamer
I liked them both about the same, Galaxy looked and felt cooler tho :mario:
 

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
Lario said:
SMS.

Why? It feels more free...
I know. Isle Delfino had so much more to explore as the Comet Observatory was boring. I really like SMS, but I'm not saying that SMG was bad and everyone else likes SMG better.........
 

ChaosNinji

Shine Sprite
Pronouns
He/him
SMG looked beautiful, was beautifully orchestrated, had inventive level designs, and didn't have to add something like FLUDD just to seem a little interesting.
 

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
Black Mage said:
SMG looked beautiful, was beautifully orchestrated, had inventive level designs, and didn't have to add something like FLUDD just to seem a little interesting.
I thought SMS was interesting without FLUDD. Idk if it's just me but Lava Monsters seems more interesting than a bunch of Lumas. That's just me though...
 

Luigi+Daisyfan11

Violet Lumas ARE REAL!!!^
Black Mage said:
...

how can you even compare lava monsters to lumas

Lumas aren't enemies. :mellow:
Ok, the storyline is more interesting in SMS, F.L.U.D.D. was cooler than his spin attacks in SMG and the bosses and enemies were better in SMS.
 
Top