Save a character: Mario Power-Ups

In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Double Cherry
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
Lucky Bell
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Spring Mushroom
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Weird Mushroom
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom

Out:
 
In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Double Cherry
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Spring Mushroom
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Weird Mushroom
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell

Out:
 
Trivia: There was a Mario Power Up Save a Character that was abandoned about 5 years ago (since I was the last poster). Here's the thread:

In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Double Cherry
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Spring Mushroom
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom

Out:
 
In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Spring Mushroom
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry

Out:
 
In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry
Spring Mushroom

Out:
 
In danger:
1-Up Mushroom
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Double Cherry
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Leaf
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
Lucky Bell
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Spring Mushroom
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Mushroom
Super Pickax
Weird Mushroom
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Invincibility Leaf
 
In danger:
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Hammer Suit
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry
Spring Mushroom
Invincibility Leaf
1-Up Mushroom

Out:
 
In danger:
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Acorn
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry
Spring Mushroom
Invincibility Leaf
1-Up Mushroom
Hammer Suit

Out:
 
In danger:
+ Clock
Bee Mushroom
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry
Spring Mushroom
Invincibility Leaf
1-Up Mushroom
Hammer Suit
P-Acorn

Out:
 
In danger:
+ Clock
Big Mushroom
Boo Mushroom
Hammer (Donkey Kong)
Invincibility Mushroom
Life Mushroom
P-Wing
Power Balloon
Red Star
Rock Mushroom
Spin Drill
Super Crown
Super Hammer
Super Pickax
Wing

Saved:
Blue Shell
Fire Flower
Boomerang Flower
Super Bell
Gold Flower
Cape Feather
Tanooki Suit
Goomba's Shoe
3-Up Moon
Super Leaf
Mega Mushroom
Superball Flower
Super Acorn
Ice Flower
Penguin Suit
Statue Leaf
Cloud Flower
Mystery Mushroom
Master Sword
Propeller Mushroom
Super Star
Carrot
Frog Suit
Mini Mushroom
Super Mushroom
Lucky Bell
Weird Mushroom
Double Cherry
Spring Mushroom
Invincibility Leaf
1-Up Mushroom
Hammer Suit
P-Acorn
Bee Mushroom

Out: