Striker Mario said:
Dr. Alphys said:
Mcmadness said:
I am pleased by the amount of SPM hate.
Don't get too pleased with yourself. I dislike SPM for having a badly-written story, not for the fact that it tried to tell a story.
From what I've seen, it seemed like the poor writing actually intervened with your enjoyment of the game. You've pointed out that it negatively affected your motivation to save the world and the attachment to characters. Not to mention, you had to slog through cruddy padded gameplay because of plot and negative writing. Those two are factors in enjoying a game.
I wouldn't even give it credit for actually trying to tell a story either. The story, as you said, so riddled with tired cliches and you quipped that it is something from
Final Fantasy 1, and I think you added it as "they're not even trying anymore".
It's kind of a complicated nuance with this game. It's a very particular combination of trying too hard while also not being willing to commit to the attempt. Like, think someone who makes big claims of their work being deep and meaningful, but is unwilling to put in any actual effort to realize that depth.
From playing SPM, it is very apparent that the game's story takes itself very seriously. Very,
very seriously. You have all these elements, like a long-standing clan of sage-like characters, prophecies of the apocalypse, a tragic love story, ancient conspiracies. The game is constantly beating you over the head with how oh-so-high the stakes are and how epic and grand this plot is.
The problem is that, in trying to make it this "spectacular" and "amazing" thing, they just looked at other acclaimed fictional works and lifted elements from those. They made those things great, so logically they'd make SPM great, ignoring that you can't just copy-paste story bits together like that. And just like that, in the process of gathering acclaimed story fragments, they neglected to put their own spin on them.
So instead of getting a game that plays with these narrative tropes in an interesting way, you get a bunch of uninspired retreads. Count Bleck's backstory that gets so much praise? It's Romeo and Juliet, sans any unexpected subversions that would make it able to stand on its own. The prophecy of the Light Prognosticus? It's a carbon copy of the plot of Final Fantasy 1, which itself has already been repeated by other works so many times it can be considered a joke at this point.
And then there's Mario himself. Mario has zero agency in this game. From the moment you arrive in Flipside, the game puts you into a chokehold by means of "the prophecy". Mario must save the worlds because of "the prophecy". Everything that happens in the game happens because it was written in "the prophecy". Mario isn't even really involved, he's like a piece moving across a game board because "the prophecy" demands it. It makes him this weird expendable bystander entity; like anyone could have done what he does in this game if THEY were in the prophecy instead of him.
This approach is so wrong for a Mario game, it hurts. Mario may not have much personality to his name, but there are SOME definite traits we know him to have: He is brave, he is heroic, and he saves people if they cry out for help. You don't need a prophecy to get him to do his thing. Just give him something to save. Make the characters more sympathetic and show the negative effects Bleck's bullshit is having on them. Make the player feel good about helping them. Have Merlon or whatever ASK Mario for help instead of demanding it because a prophecy says so. That's all the motivation Mario needs to kick ass.