I hate people who underestimate artistic substances and styles in a video game.
I am not arguing that gameplay doesn't matter. I'm arguing that graphics, sounds, and music also greatly aid in an enjoyable experience and immersion. The best games out there not only have superb gameplay but also breath-taking graphics and artistic designs and satisfactory sound design. Not all games need a story, but many need graphics and sound in order to be presentable. Many games sell because of their presentation which basically helps advertise a game.
Sure many indie games out there have old graphics but as gameplay can be timeless same with graphics. Besides indie games have an excuse not to emphasis on graphics too much but even playing in a retro 8 bit style can be nostalgic. Really there's a difference in being retro and being just plain outdated in which something like Super Mario. Bros falls into the former.