Crappy Games Discussion and Poll

[Magikrazy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

How would she know how she would feel if she bought the game if she never played it

 

[Stargazing]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

How would she know how she would feel if she bought the game if she never played it

Yeah this.

If you have no prior experience to a game, the only thing you would feel is you would feel like buying it.

 

[GalacticPetey]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

I can literally not remember a single song from the game because the music was so bland.

Though to be fair, this is just an older song reworked in Other M.

 

[Magikrazy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

why is this still in the marioverse board

 

[Dr. Peach]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

I added Action 52 and Cheetahman II.

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Baby Luigi, do you think Sticker Star deserves to be compared to Action 52 on NES and the Sega Genesis and even *bleep*ing Cheetahman II on the NES.

Of course not. Are you ----ting me?

 

[Magikrazy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Why would anyone compare Sticker Star to any of these games?

Do you honestly think it's that bad a game?

And also,

why is this still in the marioverse board

 

[Dr. Peach]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Baby Luigi, do you think Sticker Star deserves to be compared to Action 52 on NES and the Sega Genesis and even *bleep*ing Cheetahman II on the NES.

Of course not. Are you ----ting me?

So Baby Luigi, what's your big reaction to Action 52 on NES when compared to Big Rigs, Sticker Star, Sonic 06 and Superman 64? Is it a barf fest for it's $199 price point that is far above any NES game (which ain't cheap and is a total rip off)?

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Action 52 is its own brand of crap that it doesn't deserve to be compared to the other games

 

[Dr. Peach]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Action 52 is its own brand of crap that it doesn't deserve to be compared to the other games

and what about Superman 64 on the N64? Is it more of a barf fest?

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Action 52 is its own brand of crap that it doesn't deserve to be compared to the other games

and what about Superman 64 on the N64? Is it more of a barf fest?

...

non-sequitur much?

I mean what the ---- does Superman 64 have to do with Action 52 other than they're infamously bad games?

 

[Dr. Peach]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Action 52 is its own brand of crap that it doesn't deserve to be compared to the other games

and what about Superman 64 on the N64? Is it more of a barf fest?

...

non-sequitur much?

I mean what the ---- does Superman 64 have to do with Action 52 other than they're infamously bad games?

I was asking did you found it even more worse than Action 52 and god forbid Big Rigs.

 

[Magikrazy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Who cares?

They're all bad in their own special way.

 

[TheFarmboy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Why would anyone compare Sticker Star to any of these games?

Do you honestly think it's that bad a game?

And also,

why is this still in the marioverse board

I honestly hate the mentality that because of that one thing in a game that someone doesn't like, means they feel the rest of the game is awful.

Maybe we need to relocate it. Also to restart the poll since more options was added, as well as nix Sunshine.

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

I honestly hate the mentality that because of that one thing in a game that someone doesn't like, means they feel the rest of the game is awful.

Actually people hate it because it's not what they were expecting

It's a legit criticism but that doesn't mean that it's "DA WORST GAME EVAH!!!!"

 

[Paper Mario]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Actually that's only part of the reason. Things can be unexpected and good. For example, prior to me playing SPM, TTYD was the only Paper Mario game I had played. Naturally I expected SPM to be like it. It wasn't, but it still ended up being my favorite in the series. It had enough in common and changed things up at the same time.

Sticker Star took everything but the art style and tossed it in the garbage, and the resulting game was mediocre at best. I still enjoyed it, but not nearly as much as the first three.

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Actually that's only part of the reason. Things can be unexpected and good. For example, prior to me playing SPM, TTYD was the only Paper Mario game I had played. Naturally I expected SPM to be like it. It wasn't, but it still ended up being my favorite in the series. It had enough in common and changed things up at the same time.

Sticker Star took everything but the art style and tossed it in the garbage, and the resulting game was mediocre at best. I still enjoyed it, but not nearly as much as the first three.

You're disregarding the fact that if you take Sticker Star only for what it is, it's actually not a terrible game

 

[Paper Mario]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

It's not terrible, it's just mediocre. If it didn't have Mario in the title I doubt the sales would be even a quarter as much.

 

[banjonator1]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

sticker star was such a beautiful game, design wise, and it's really a shame how easy it could have been saved

i mean damn

that music

add some boss variety, even just a couple of partners, and have the action not completely rely on items, and pow

you've got a better paper mario game

 

[Magikrazy]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

I agree

I loved the design (except how a few of the enemies changed their designs).

And also,

why is this still in the marioverse board

 

[freakworld]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

sticker star was such a beautiful game, design wise, and it's really a shame how easy it could have been saved

i mean damn

that music

add some boss variety, even just a couple of partners, and have the action not completely rely on items, and pow

you've got a better paper mario game

also add a story

then we can talk

 

[Lee Chaolan]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Having no story really isn't much of an argument considering the amount of hate towards SPM's storyline, and Sticker Star's story didn't drown out the gameplay, which was pretty good, but Sticker Stars battle gameplay sucked, letting the whole game down.

Seriously, why would you enjoy wasting good stickers only to get ones that are worse? Because of this, the game was nowhere near as engaging as a Paper Mario game should be.

 

[Crackin355]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Having no story really isn't much of an argument considering the amount of hate towards SPM's storyline, and Sticker Star's story didn't drown out the gameplay, which was pretty good, but Sticker Stars battle gameplay sucked, letting the whole game down.

Seriously, why would you enjoy wasting good stickers only to get ones that are worse? Because of this, the game was nowhere near as engaging as a Paper Mario game should be.

Do people not fight to try and finish the battle in one turn? I can't stand wasting time using regular stickers if I have better ones that can finish things faster.

 

[Dr. Peach]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Out of Mega Man X7's soundtrack, my favourite one is the Highway Intro Stage theme and that's one of the only great tracks from that game.

Spoiler

Anyways Mega Man X7 is a purely badly designed game when compared to Sticker Star.

 

[Lee Chaolan]

Re: Paper Mario Sticker Star vs Mega Man 8 and X7 vs Metroid Other M vs Sonic 06

Having no story really isn't much of an argument considering the amount of hate towards SPM's storyline, and Sticker Star's story didn't drown out the gameplay, which was pretty good, but Sticker Stars battle gameplay sucked, letting the whole game down.

Seriously, why would you enjoy wasting good stickers only to get ones that are worse? Because of this, the game was nowhere near as engaging as a Paper Mario game should be.

Do people not fight to try and finish the battle in one turn? I can't stand wasting time using regular stickers if I have better ones that can finish things faster.

Then you have no good stickers for the other battles, and all coins get you can only be used to get standard ones that do little damage. Or you could just farm for Thing stickers and become horribly overpowered and not put any strategy into battles at all.