Re: disney misrepresentation
Hypochondriac Mario said:
This movie, again, is based on a fairy tale. I don't know if they deliberately suppressed speaking roles of other races, but Disney shouldn't be forced to give speaking roles just to please some politically-correct viewers.
So what, fairy tales can only be about white people now?
The fact of the matter is,
there is still racism. And if companies just continue on their merry way without anyone pointing out their racism, then you won't see PoC's unless you're trying to perpetuate racism with your Token Sassy Black Person.
Olaf said:
I get racial diversity and stuff, but I don't think they should be including a person of a different race JUST TO INCLUDE A PERSON OF A DIFFERENCE RACE.
Really, I don't think it matters in this day in age.
The character's personality's are what matter. I don't care if they're all white, black, a mix, or whatever.
In this day and age? What's so different now? Have we finally achieved equality among all races? Because, quite frankly, that's not true, and you'd be blind to think so. It's hard to find people of color in movies that aren't being played for laughs. Sure, some movies are firmly rooted in their locations, but a lot don't have that excuse, and even those that do work around it.
You say Disney has to abide by historical accuracy? Look at The Princess and the Frog. Was New Orleans segregated in the 1920s? Hell no, but that didn't stop princess from having a black "princess" anyway. Does that make the movie awful now? Can you not watch it because the movie doesn't accurately reflect the time period?
And again - "It doesn't matter in this day and age"? What, now that blacks have equal opportunities as whites (fun fact: they don't), does that mean we can just stop representing them and go back to giving the whites all roles?
Princess Zae said:
Elsa said:
because people other than whites should be able to have a role in movies...?
and because, quite simply, it perpetuates racisim...?
its not even a big deal, i mean its not like there arent movies in the world that doesnt have other races
but they aren't common, and when they do have them, most are just played for laughs
Princess Zae said:
Elsa said:
because people other than whites should be able to have a role in movies...?
and because, quite simply, it perpetuates racisim...?
besides if it was implying racism, there would be like, ya know, actual racist comments.
no. it's simply racist in and of itself to not have anyone but white actors, because that's, you know, excluding?
Princess Zae said:
Elsa said:
because people other than whites should be able to have a role in movies...?
and because, quite simply, it perpetuates racisim...?
overall it just sounds like people are over reacting to something this small
it'd be small if it was just one movie, but it's perpetuated everywhere.
a quick search found me this post, which is better worded than mine. tbh, the only animated movies in the past 10 years that I can think of that contain PoC's that aren't played for laughs are maybe The Incredibles and The Princess and the Frog? i'm not really a movie-goer, so there's almost certainly more... probably. but it's still a problem