What is the best experience you have had in a mafia game

[NSY]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

 

[EctoBiologist]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

I think that is tied with MLP:FiM mafia again due the pandora's box thing.

 

[Baby Mario Bloops]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

I think that is tied with MLP:FiM mafia again due the pandora's box thing.

I think the MCD's MLP mafia had a day where 4 people die.

...of course, Mafia, The ended with all four mafia dying at once, but let's not speak of that until I redo it...

 

[Time Turner]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

I think that is tied with MLP:FiM mafia again due the pandora's box thing.

I think the MCD's MLP mafia had a day where 4 people die.

...of course, Mafia, The ended with all four mafia dying at once, but let's not speak of that until I redo it...

Was I the only one that voted?

 

[Baby Mario Bloops]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

I think that is tied with MLP:FiM mafia again due the pandora's box thing.

I think the MCD's MLP mafia had a day where 4 people die.

...of course, Mafia, The ended with all four mafia dying at once, but let's not speak of that until I redo it...

Was I the only one that voted?

There's no doubt you got MVP.

 

[Time Turner]

Is that the record for how many players died at once.

I think that is tied with MLP:FiM mafia again due the pandora's box thing.

I think the MCD's MLP mafia had a day where 4 people die.

...of course, Mafia, The ended with all four mafia dying at once, but let's not speak of that until I redo it...

Was I the only one that voted?

There's no doubt you got MVP.

>first to die
>still gets mvp

woot

 

[Crackin355]

I love the feeling of protecting someone who would've been killed using your own judgement (not a group decision).

It was Mario Party 9 Mafia, Magikrazy seemed like he was a target so I jailed him and no kill happened that night. They probably didn't think it could be blocked because the Doctor had died.

 

[Baby Mario Bloops]

Gonna bump this one too since the other one is up as well.

Nabber and Reverse probably still disagree with me, but...Magnificent Mafia 2.0 has one of my best experiences.

Mostly just because we were doing awesome, and rolefishing a bit, and then I got Yakuza'd, and somehow I managed to get 12 Innocents killed in a row while no Mafia member died and turned the game around. I love it because it showed that the mafia can still win even if rolefishing is happening.

Had I not forgotten that Timmy was the Inspired that got cop powers and killed him the first night, I probably would have ended that game a little sooner. It also helped that I knew all the good locations and two players dying from poisoning.

 

[Revin]

my current favorite games are digimafia 02 and jungle mafia, both for completely different reasons

digimafia 02 i loved because i just really managed to get into it. i figured out what all the characters in the game would be on day 2, and then after i told the reviver (neptune) to revive the cop (rocker), i basically just gave as much info to rocker as i had, and helped him get in contact with the tracker/watcher and the doctor, so i basically felt like i was as confirmed innocent as i could be without being killed and revived. in the end i got overall MVP (only time i've had that), so i really had fun with that one

jungle mafia was amazing for me, but mostly because i spent the whole time roleplaying as luke atmey and making fun of everyone while not being productive at all

 

[Dr. Javelin]

in my first mafia game someone (i think it might have been BMB?) was acting scummy so i vigkilled them

and they were the godfather. : )

There was also some mafia (I forget which) where I managed to convince the cop (MG1 iirc) that I was innocent, and he literally copchecked every single other player before determining that I must be mafia. Even if I did get ousted in the end, it was worth it.

 

[Revin]

oh, that was awesome mafia, wasn't it?
and then iirc you were the yakuza and converted mg1, and he won the game
i managed to work out he was converted, but by that time i was already dead haha