Most Overrated Nintendo characters and games

I know there are similar threads like this but i wanted to hear your opinions about characters and games that you feel that is getting way too much praise from Nintendo in general.

Characters:Midna,Rosalina and Ike (from Fire emblem)

Games:Ocarina of time hands down!
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
I know there are similar threads like this but i wanted to hear your opinions about characters and games that you feel that is getting way too much praise from Nintendo in general.

Characters:Midna,Rosalina and Ike (from Fire emblem)

Games:Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
 

yoshidude99

Yoshidude is here
NSY said:
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
I know there are similar threads like this but i wanted to hear your opinions about characters and games that you feel that is getting way too much praise from Nintendo in general.

Characters:Midna,Rosalina and Ike (from Fire emblem)

Games:Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
Actually it is kind of. Though I've never played it(but want it) it's mainly because of nostaglia which I understand.
 

Ernest Fine

Dreamboat
Chat Operator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Retired Forum Mod
Retired Wiki Staff
NSY said:
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
I've played it and, honestly, it feels kinda boring. I find Zelda fine when you're watching somebody else play (and hopefully doing it right), but I find it pretty tedious to play. And I've played quite a few games in the series.

Oh, and Majora's Mask was way better than Ocarina of Time.
 

Bop1996

Power Star
Retired Wiki Staff
NSY said:
Games:Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
[/quote]
it's kinda hard for me to take you seriously when you say the same about every other 3d zelda game
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
Father Dougal McGuire said:
NSY said:
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
I've played it and, honestly, it feels kinda boring. I find Zelda fine when you're watching somebody else play (and hopefully doing it right), but I find it pretty tedious to play. And I've played quite a few games in the series.

Oh, and Majora's Mask was way better than Ocarina of Time.
Really? It's tedious when your stuck, but I had a blast when I got into to it.

I am a bit disappointed by the lack of Zelda fans here but I do understand that everyone has different tastes.
 

Ray Trace

You Can Tick Off Birds If You Follow My Advice
How about just Mario platformers in general? Especially the New Super Mario Bros. series.
 
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
I know there are similar threads like this but i wanted to hear your opinions about characters and games that you feel that is getting way too much praise from Nintendo in general.

Characters:Midna,Rosalina and Ike (from Fire emblem)

Games:Ocarina of time hands down!
Considering Fire Emblem doesn't have a huge fan base, I wouldn't consider him overrated.

And as far as I've heard a lot of people hate Midna.


And Ocarina of Time is a great game.


Geno is overrated, even though I like him.

For games:

Super Mario Galaxy

-Not a great game. Still good but it's not as perfect as people think

I can think of more later.

NSY said:
Father Dougal McGuire said:
NSY said:
ThisDudeIsaGamer said:
Ocarina of time hands down!
That will never be overrated. How can you not like it.
I've played it and, honestly, it feels kinda boring. I find Zelda fine when you're watching somebody else play (and hopefully doing it right), but I find it pretty tedious to play. And I've played quite a few games in the series.

Oh, and Majora's Mask was way better than Ocarina of Time.
Really? It's tedious when your stuck, but I had a blast when I got into to it.

I am a bit disappointed by the lack of Zelda fans here but I do understand that everyone has different tastes.
What? Majora's Mask time based thing is a good strategy thing, but it's just not as good. It felt a little rushed and It's to challenging for me. Ocarina of Time or Skyward Sword games are the best types of Zelda games.
 

Gumball Machine

Celestial Guide
Solar Blaze said:
Am I the only one here who sees Geno get far more hate than praise?
Today, yes. But when Super Mario RPG first came out, Geno was incredibly popular and so many people wanted him to return in another Mario game and even hoped he'd be playable in Brawl.
 

Ray Trace

You Can Tick Off Birds If You Follow My Advice
Yoshidude99 said:
Super Mario Galaxy 2 though good is the most overrated game of all time.
I wouldn't use superlatives like that, but I still agree with you that Super Mario Galaxy 2 is overrated. I don't think it deserves that much praise from the critics.
 

EctoBiologist

Best cat themed touhou. I love touhou and DR.
Banned User
Overrated...

Yoshi, Yoshi, Yoshi, Yoshi, Half-life, Portal, Homestuck Game(will probably be, please don't kill me), Ocarina of Time, Twilight Princess, Super Mario World, Super Mario 64, Pokemon 1st and 2nd gens.
 

Rocker64

~Massive Fangirl
Geno/Mallow

and the Galaxy series.

Also, Pokemon Black and White. I mean it isn't a bad game but it isn't a good as gold/silver/soulsilver/heartgold and i see too much praise for it.
 

RandomGuy

Earth Adept
Baby Luigi said:
Yoshidude99 said:
Super Mario Galaxy 2 though good is the most overrated game of all time.
I wouldn't use superlatives like that, but I still agree with you that Super Mario Galaxy 2 is overrated. I don't think it deserves that much praise from the critics.
I don't even know why all the gaming critics think it's great
 
Top