Have a good replacing characters from my MK8 roster?

Windy

Lakitu
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario
Baby Luigi*
Baby Peach
Baby Daisy*
Toad
Toadette*
Koopa Troopa
Koopa Paratroopa*
Dry Bones*
Shy Guy*
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu)
E. Gadd*

Middleweight
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Daisy*
Yoshi
Birdo*
Diddy Kong*
Dixie Kong*
Tiny Kong*
Bowser Jr.*
Kamek*
Hammer Bro.*

Heavyweight
Wario
Waluigi
Donkey Kong
Bowser
King Boo*
Petey Piranha*
Rosalina*
Funky Kong*
Candy Kong*
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline)
Kritter*
King K. Rool*

Some of accounts from Youtube said "Too many DK characters".
My replacing characters instead of weird characters:
Candy Kong -> Pianta
Toadsworth and E. Gadd -> Noki and ???
Tiny Kong -> ???

EDIT: Dry Bones added in Lightweight. My mistake of missed for him.
 

Cirdec

Celestial Guide
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario Ok
Baby Luigi* Ok
Baby Peach Ok
Baby Daisy* Yes
Toad Must
Toadette* Yes
Koopa Troopa Ok
Koopa Paratroopa* Meh
Dry Bones* Meh
Shy Guy* Fine
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) Ok
E. Gadd* Yes, but I would class him as a Middleweight

Middleweight
Mario It's called Mario Kart for a reason
Luigi Must
Peach Must
Daisy* Must
Yoshi Must
Birdo* Fine
Diddy Kong* Ok
Dixie Kong* No
Tiny Kong* No
Bowser Jr.* Fine
Kamek* Fine
Hammer Bro.* Fine

Heavyweight
Wario Must
Waluigi Ok
Donkey Kong Must
Bowser Must
King Boo* Fine
Petey Piranha* Ok
Rosalina* Ok
Funky Kong* Ok
Candy Kong* No, replace her with Lubba
Dry Bowser* Fine(In previous, Pauline)
Kritter* No
King K. Rool* No, replace him with Metal Mario

Some of accounts from Youtube said "Too many DK characters".
My good replacing characters are
Candy Kong -> Pianta
Toadsworth and E. Gadd -> Noki and ???
Tiny Kong -> ???
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario yes
Baby Luigi* yes
Baby Peach eh
Baby Daisy* well I personally don't like her, but I can't think of anyone good to replace her with now, so eh
Toad definitely
Toadette* sure
Koopa Troopa yes
Koopa Paratroopa* eh
Dry Bones* yes
Shy Guy* yes
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) eh
E. Gadd* sure, but I'd move him to middleweight and give his lightweight spot back to Lakitu

EDIT: oh lol didn't notice a spot was missing. i changed this part

Middleweight
Mario ofcnot
Luigi definitely
Peach definitely
Daisy* yes
Yoshi definitely
Birdo* yes
Diddy Kong* yes
Dixie Kong* sure
Tiny Kong* no, take her out and move E. Gadd to middleweight
Bowser Jr.* yes
Kamek* eh
Hammer Bro.* sure

Heavyweight
Wario definitely
Waluigi definitely
Donkey Kong definitely
Bowser definitely
King Boo* eh
Petey Piranha* sure
Rosalina* eh
Funky Kong* eh
Candy Kong* no, but not sure who to replace with
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline) eh
Kritter* no, but not sure who to replace with
King K. Rool* sure

My replacing characters instead of weird characters:
Pianta
Noki
I don't like either of these
 

Windy

Lakitu
I think DK characters have only 4(Kong) and 2(Kremling) in Mario Kart. Only Mario Baseball or DK series have almost.
My weird obsession with Candy Kong has deleted by some of Anime and Tales series. (My weird things happen in Mario Tennis Open)

Only allowed list from Mario Kart
Donkey Kong
Diddy Kong
Dixie Kong
Funky Kong
King K. Rool
Kritter
 

Dark Light

Cherries and Berries
You have Baby Luigi in the roster?

I approve.
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario Ok choice
Baby Luigi* Ok choice
Baby Peach eh only if the roster is huge
Baby Daisy* No
Toad must
Toadette* Ok choice
Koopa Troopa Yes
Koopa Paratroopa* HELL NO
Dry Bones* eh
Shy Guy* yes
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) Lakitu was better
E. Gadd* YES

Middleweight
Mario eh what are the chances
Luigi must
Peach must
Daisy* yes
Yoshi MUST
Birdo* yes
Diddy Kong* yes
Dixie Kong* better than funky
Tiny Kong* no
Bowser Jr.* yes
Kamek* yes
Hammer Bro.* maybe but better choices are out there

Heavyweight
Wario must
Waluigi DON'T MAKE HIM ABSENT AGAIN
Donkey Kong must
Bowser must
King Boo* maybe
Petey Piranha* no
Rosalina* yes
Funky Kong* Dixie > Funky
Candy Kong* HELL No
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline) Pauline would be a hell no and Dry Bowser is shifted to the no side anyway
Kritter* HELL NO
King K. Rool* no

Some of accounts from Youtube said "Too many DK characters".
My replacing characters instead of weird characters:
Candy Kong -> Pianta Pianta -> Cnady Kong
Toadsworth and E. Gadd -> Noki and ???
Tiny Kong -> ???

EDIT: Dry Bones added in Lightweight. My mistake of missed for him.
 

The Mandalorian

Mushroom Attendant
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario sure
Baby Luigi* sure
Baby Peach sure
Baby Daisy* sure
Toad sure
Toadette* sure
Koopa Troopa sure
Koopa Paratroopa* sure
Dry Bones* sure
Shy Guy* sure
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) No
E. Gadd* No

Middleweight
Mario Of course
Luigi Sure
Peach sure
Daisy* sure
Yoshi sure
Birdo* sure
Diddy Kong* sure
Dixie Kong* no
Tiny Kong* no
Bowser Jr.* sure
Kamek* no, but possibly a Magikoopa
Hammer Bro.* sure

Heavyweight
Wario sure
Waluigi sure
Donkey Kong sure
Bowser sure
King Boo* sure
Petey Piranha* sure
Rosalina* sure
Funky Kong* maybe
Candy Kong* no
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline) sure
Kritter* maybe
King K. Rool* no

Some of accounts from Youtube said "Too many DK characters".
My replacing characters instead of weird characters:
Candy Kong -> Pianta
Toadsworth and E. Gadd -> Noki and ???
Tiny Kong -> ???

EDIT: Dry Bones added in Lightweight. My mistake of missed for him.
 

Toad85

MarioKartRPG
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario Mmkay.
Baby Luigi* I'd make him unlocked from the start, but whatever floats your boat.
Baby Peach I'd make her locked at the start, but whatever floats your boat.
Baby Daisy* NOPE.
Toad YES.
Toadette* YES.
Koopa Troopa Mmkay.
Koopa Paratroopa* Not sure about this choice. There're probably a few other, more deserving choices, but Paratroopa isn't necessarily a bad character.
Dry Bones*
Shy Guy* YES.
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) I love the idea of Toadsworth racing, but Lakitu deserves to be in it as well, IMO. Probably could replace Paratroopa or Gadd
E. Gadd* Don't really like the idea of this choice. Don't get me wrong, I'd love him in this game, but I'd rather have him as an NPC.

Middleweight
Mario Pretty much mandatory, if you're planning on calling it Mario Kart 8.
Luigi Again, he's been in pretty much every spinoff game ever. I don't see him leaving any time soon.
Peach Mmkay.
Daisy* Mmkay.
Yoshi Mmkay.
Birdo* Alright, I guess I can go with her.
Diddy Kong* Mmkay.
Dixie Kong* YES.
Tiny Kong* NO.
Bowser Jr.* Sure.
Kamek* YES. Though I'd probably make him a lightweight if I were making the list.
Hammer Bro.* There are many more deserving characters just waiting outside. Why go for another nameless enemy?

Heavyweight
Wario As long as he's not locked again
Waluigi YES.
Donkey Kong Sure.
Bowser Mmkay.
King Boo* Good choice.
Petey Piranha* Haven't seen him since Double Dash!! I for one would like to see his return to the series.
Rosalina* Sure.
Funky Kong* Umm... ok?
Candy Kong* whyyyyy
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline) I'd prefer Pauline or some other heavyweight, IMO. But whatever floats your boat.
Kritter* YES. Though I'd move him down to midweight.
King K. Rool* YES.
 

Pyro

Power Star
stamp of approval
not now
fuck no

Lumin Blade said:
Lightweight
Baby Mario
Baby Luigi*
Baby Peach

Baby Daisy*
Toad
Toadette*
Koopa Troopa

Koopa Paratroopa*
Dry Bones*
Shy Guy*

Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu)
E. Gadd*


Middleweight
Mario
Luigi
Peach
Daisy*
Yoshi
Birdo*
Diddy Kong*
Dixie Kong*

Tiny Kong*
Bowser Jr.*
Kamek*
Hammer Bro.*


Heavyweight
Wario
Waluigi
Donkey Kong
Bowser
King Boo*
Petey Piranha*

Rosalina*
Funky Kong*
Candy Kong*

Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline)
Kritter*
King K. Rool*
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Toad85 said:
Baby Luigi* I'd make him unlocked from the start, but whatever floats your boat.
Baby Peach I'd make her locked at the start, but whatever floats your boat.
actually yeah I agree with this.
 

Yoshi K

Come with me if you want cookies
Lumin Blade said:
My current roster

Lightweight
Baby Mario YES
Baby Luigi* YES
Baby Peach YES
Baby Daisy* NO, replace with Metal Mario (heavyweight)
Toad YES
Toadette YES
Koopa Troopa YES
Koopa Paratroopa* YES
Dry Bones* YES
Shy Guy* YES
Toadsworth* (In previous, Lakitu) NO, go back to Lakitu
E. Gadd* YES, place as middleweight

Middleweight
Mario YES
Luigi YES
Peach YES
Daisy* YES
Yoshi YES
Birdo* NO, replace with Shadow Mario
Diddy Kong* YES
Dixie Kong* YES
Tiny Kong* NO, replace with Noki
Bowser Jr.* YES
Kamek* YES
Hammer Bro.* YES

Heavyweight
Wario YES
Waluigi YES
Donkey Kong YES
Bowser YES
King Boo* YES
Petey Piranha* YES
Rosalina* YES
Funky Kong* YES
Candy Kong* NO, replace with Pianta
Dry Bowser* (In previous, Pauline) YES
Kritter* NO, replace with Whomp (probably won't happen but would be epic)
King K. Rool* YES
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
I don't think Pianta or Noki are good choices, personally.
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
Donkey, Diddy and Dixie are enough for the DK series.

I don't get why you all want Koopa Paratroopa.
 

The Mandalorian

Mushroom Attendant
NSY said:
Donkey, Diddy and Dixie are enough for the DK series.

I don't get why you all want Koopa Paratroopa.
Because you touch yourself at night

I'm sorry, that was mean.

In all seriousness, why do you guys want E.Gadd? Granted he was cool, but he's too minor.
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Cirdec said:
Me too, even Queen Bee is better than them.
Nah I wouldn't go that far. Queen Bee was a pretty terrible choice.
 

The Mandalorian

Mushroom Attendant
Toad85 said:
Bane said:
If you keep on saying "whatever floats your boat", I'm going to have to kill you.
i only said it three times. :\
Dude I was only joking. :\

Toad85 said:
Bane said:
Cirdec said:
Bane said:
In all seriousness, why do you guys want E.Gadd? Granted he was cool, but he's too minor.
Queen Bee was minor as well.
That was their biggest mistake. Queen Bee sucked like hell.
Metal Mario was worse.
No. Metal Mario was cool. Cooler than the other side of the pillow.
 

Dorayaki

King Bowser
So I remember that there was a similar thread, why don't you just post there?
http://www.marioboards.com/index.php?topic=14996.0

And generally I don't think there would be 12 characters available in each weight. If you're not making prediction, we can imagine that there are 40 characters in each weight and don't have to talk about replacement.

Cirdec said:
Candy Kong* No, replace her with Lubba
King K. Rool* No, replace him with Metal Mario
Some of accounts from Youtube said "Too many DK characters".
My good replacing characters are
Candy Kong -> Pianta
Toadsworth and E. Gadd -> Noki and ???
Tiny Kong -> ???
In your example, I don't think you follow the rule that recurring characters should be prior to species or minor characters.
And if you think DK series have too much representives, you can vote for other subseries like Warioware and Paper, Tennis characters.
 
Top