Piantas and their stupidity (with inclusion of Noki humor of course)

[Boidoh]

Lets talk about how stupid (but awesome) piantas are

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Their trials are the most rigged ever.

But...their trial made Super Mario Sunshine a game most of us can enjoy

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

They were a nice touch in SMG2.

 

[Dr. Javelin]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

About the fruit:

How do you know that the piantas aren't a good peace-loving society where everyone contributes their part and gives away free fruits? You don't steal them, they're free because Isle Delfino is like a messed up communist socialist state or something.

It even comes with secret police who arrest foreigners and turn them into slaves for the state!

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

I don't think they're actually selling fruit. When you take the fruit away, the fruit immediately grows back.

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

About the fruit:

How do you know that the piantas aren't a good peace-loving society where everyone contributes their part and gives away free fruits? You don't steal them, they're free because Isle Delfino is like a messed up communist socialist state or something.

It even comes with secret police who arrest foreigners and turn them into slaves for the state!

Wait, what?

 

[Dr. Javelin]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

It all depends on your perspective whether it's messed up or good.

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

It all depends on your perspective whether it's messed up or good.

I'm confused because communism and socialism are two contradictory economic systems.

 

[Dr. Javelin]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Isn't Communism a more extreme version of socialism? Or am I wrong?

 

[Lario]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Spoiler

I'M A CHUCKSTER!

 

[Post-Damage Invincibility]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

My vote is mistaking me for Shadow Mario because it's the only dumb thing they done that negatively affected me.

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

TC should add the rigged trial to the poll. There are just so many things WRONG about it

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Isn't Communism a more extreme version of socialism? Or am I wrong?

No. In a nutshell, communism is an economic system in which resources and power are shared equally among members of a population (you may have heard the phrase "from each according to ability, to each according to need"). Socialism as implemented in government (communism has not been implemented in government to date) involves a central authority controlling resources/holding power and meting it out to the other members of society (or in the case of Stalin, withholding almost everything) to create a semblance of social ownership (since everyone gets or is supposed to get the same amount).

My vote is mistaking me for Shadow Mario because it's the only dumb thing they done that negatively affected me.

I still don't understand how that happened.

 

[Post-Damage Invincibility]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Isn't Communism a more extreme version of socialism? Or am I wrong?

No. In a nutshell, communism is an economic system in which resources and power are shared equally among members of a population (you may have heard the phrase "from each according to ability, to each according to need"). Socialism as implemented in government (communism has not been implemented in government to date) involves a central authority controlling resources/holding power and meting it out to the other members of society (or in the case of Stalin, withholding almost everything) to create a semblance of social ownership (since everyone gets or is supposed to get the same amount).

My vote is mistaking me for Shadow Mario because it's the only dumb thing they done that negatively affected me.

I still don't understand how that happened.

Since Communism has never truly been implemented in government, which country, in your opinion, has come the closest to true Communism?

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

None, as the countries claiming to implement it have done so under a central authority, therefore violating what is essentially communism's basic principle, and I don't see it ever being implemented as a form of government. To stay on-topic, that trial was a joke. He doesn't even get a chance to defend himself.

 

[Post-Damage Invincibility]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

None, as the countries claiming to implement it have done so under a central authority, therefore violating what is essentially communism's basic principle, and I don't see it ever being implemented as a form of government. To stay on-topic, that trial was a joke. He doesn't even get a chance to defend himself.

I know he didn't do anything. It was so stupid. Why didn't he have the right to an attorney?

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

He wasn't even told he had the right to remain silent (how ironic that would have been), and that anything he said could be used against him in a court of law. Sure, it's not the U.S., but Isle Delfino doesn't look the sort of place in which people just get randomly "tried" and imprisoned.

 

[Raven Effect]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

 

[Mario4Ever]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

He could have used those six words effectively. If Phoenix Wright were there, this wouldn't be an issue.

 

[Post-Damage Invincibility]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

But since the law says you cannot be convicted if there is a reasonable doubt (although I think it should be beyond a shadow of a doubt). Since there was a reasonable doubt, he should not have been convicted. Was his guilty verdict ever overturned even at the very end of the game? That was never made clear!

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

Uh, he did

 

[Raven Effect]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

He could have used those six words effectively. If Phoenix Wright were there, this wouldn't be an issue.

This isn't DC you can't just interact with the other universes Mario is on Universe 1 Phoenix Wright is on Universe 5.43

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

But since the law says you cannot be convicted if there is a reasonable doubt (although I think it should be beyond a shadow of a doubt). Since there was a reasonable doubt, he should not have been convicted. Was his guilty verdict ever overturned even at the very end of the game? That was never made clear!

>Implying that a series of islands have the same legal system as the United States

Look that trial was very fair using Isle Delfino legal standards and Mario couldn't testify any way since he never says anything longer then 6 words making him unreliable. Peach isn't reliable as a witness because she has a clear bias (plus she was acting as his attorney) Toadsworth wasn't even there nor were the other toads so the trial was fair and the conviction was fair.

Uh, he did

Yeah and what did that testify inlclude

 

[Ray Trace]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

I didn't mean about the testifying part. I meant about speaking longer than 6 words

 

[Raven Effect]

Re: Piantas and their stupidity

I didn't mean about the testifying part. I meant about speaking longer than 6 words

Point remains the fact is that Mario isn't good with words