If you had the choice to make the next Mario game, what would it be?

[Moon Captain Mario]

For me, a Paper Mario Remake would be nice. All except Sticker Star and Color Splash. Specifically Super Paper Mario.

 

[Xiahou Ba]

A Mystery Dungeon game starring the baby characters.

 

[Mcmadness]

A Mystery Dungeon game starring the baby characters.

Still caught up on my idea huh?

 

[Marceline]

I'd have a real hard time choosing one but I'd absolutely love any of the following:

• Galaxy 3
• Odyssey 2
• 3D World 2
• Mario Maker 3 (with how recent SMM2 is I doubt this will be soon but yeah)
• Mario Maker with actual 3D levels, especially an SPM or Galaxy theme
• A new M&L game with good story elements
• A return to form Paper Mario
• Remakes of:
  

  • SM64​
  • PM64​
  • TTYD​
  • SMRPG​
  • SPM​
  • PIT​
  • MP1​
  • MP3​
  • SMS​
  • SMG (honestly I'd rather wait for a console which can render these games REALLY well like in 4K with cool shaders etc., the potential for beautification this game has is unreal)​
• RPG / 3D platform hybrid​
• Donkey Kong RPG​
• More 3D Donkey Kong games​
• Mario Kart with better rosters​
• Mario RPG Party​

 

[Xiahou Ba]

Still caught up on my idea huh?

I'd take anything that would star the baby characters in a genre Mario hasn't done yet.

 

[BBQ Turtle]

A proper new Mario Kart (i.e. not a simplified micro-transaction filled mobile game or port). Something that combines some of the best parts of each of the other games and sorts out some of the issues, and has a decent roster with minimal clones.

 

[YoshiFlutterJump]

A Mario/Kirby full-scale platforming crossover, with lots of references to the histories of both series.

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Mario & Luigi: Double Dimensions, it would basically take the concept of Paper Jam but actually use characters specific to Mario & Luigi and Paper Mario.

Basically, if Paper Jam had come during the GCN/Wii/DS era, before a certain 2012 game came along and set a standard of Mario RPGs being nauseatingly sterile.

 

[Mcmadness]

I still doubt it would have turned out the way you'd wanted it to.

 

[Fawfulthegreat64]

Maybe not, but I also doubt it would be as sterile as it is now.

 

[winstein]

A Super Mario platformer with the Mario side of the Mario Party characters (based on how Super Mario Party categorise them) being playable. The more playable characters, the merrier.

Although perhaps a more unpopular idea, I would love to see another Mario character have a game starring game, provided that they haven't had a game starring them yet, so for example, Daisy and Waluigi.

Thank you for reading.