SMG vs. SMS

Which game is better? Super Mario Galaxy or Super Mario Sunshine?

  • Super Mario Galaxy

    Votes: 15 60.0%

  • Super Mario Sunshine

    Votes: 4 16.0%

  • Both were horrible

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Both were equally amazing

    Votes: 6 24.0%
  • Total voters
    25
Super Mario Galaxy by far, they had better and more interesting bosses, better level designs and more tasteful musc.
 
Gumby said:
Super Mario Galaxy by far, they had better and more interesting bosses, better level designs and more tasteful music.
Click to expand...
:)

I'm glad there's atleast one other person on SMG's side besides Ninji and me.
 
Oh come on Luigi+Daisy fan, it´s not like we should argue.

I´ll repeat myself: Galaxy is technically better but better game does nto mean the previous one is bad. For example, I like Mario Kart Double Dash better than MK Wii. Same goes for any person liking one game or another depending on their tastes or whatever they consider more important in a videogame.
 
Easmo said:
Oh come on Luigi+Daisy fan, it´s not like we should argue.

I´ll repeat myself: Galaxy is technically better but better game does nto mean the previous one is bad. For example, I like Mario Kart Double Dash better than MK Wii. Same goes for any person liking one game or another depending on their tastes or whatever they consider more important in a videogame.
Click to expand...
Per
 
Easmo said:
Oh come on Luigi+Daisy fan, it´s not like we should argue.

I´ll repeat myself: Galaxy is technically better but better game does nto mean the previous one is bad. For example, I like Mario Kart Double Dash better than MK Wii. Same goes for any person liking one game or another depending on their tastes or whatever they consider more important in a videogame.
Click to expand...
i'm doen arguing. Okay, you win! SMG is better ok.
 
I like how everything I say is apparently a lie, but if someone else says it, it's awesome.

Also, this is an opinion poll. If you weren't claiming your opinion as fact, I wouldn't argue.
 
One of the problems that SMS has legacy-wise is that it was a Mario 3D game. The quality expectation goes way up with a Mario 3D game, which is why SMG2 now is being bashed for being recycled (which we know Nintendo has done with sports games like Sluggers). But SMS was still the best platformer on the Gamecube, hands down. It was just that putting 20% of the Shines to blue coins, less variation of the worlds, a feeling of less exploration put it down.

That said, I did vote for SMG, which did limit exploration sometimes too. It would be nice to be able to get any (or most) of the stars of any world again.
 
Black Mage said:
I like how everything I say is apparently a lie, but if someone else says it, it's awesome.

Also, this is an opinion poll. If you weren't claiming your opinion as fact, I wouldn't argue.
Click to expand...
Now, you're arguing with me again. I already said SMG was better. What else do you want? Money? jk