Stage Legality Discussion Thread

Lumastar

Stay off this text, jerks! He has personal issues.
What stages will be starters or counterpicks aside from the big two? I have a list, and most of the stages seem to be high contenders for the banhammer.

Battlefield- Starter due to simple design.
Final Destination- Starter due to simple design.
3D Land- Banned for scrolling and extreme hazards.
Golden Plains- Banned for scrolling, walk-offs, and having a distracting element.
Paper Mario- Banned for having extreme hazards.
Rainbow Road- Banned for unpredictable terrain changes and extreme hazards.
Mushroomy Kingdom- Banned for scrolling, walk-offs, and large amount of obstacles that can stop KOs and lead to camping.
Jungle Japes- Banned for water rapids and Klaptraps.
Gerudo Valley- Banned for extreme hazards and walk-offs.
Spirit Train- Banned for scrolling and extreme hazards.
Yoshi's Island- Counterpick due to Support Ghosts and Fly Guys that can stop projectiles.
Brinstar- Banned for acid and breakable parts of the stage.
Unova Pokémon League- Banned for extreme hazards and random platform appearances.
Prism Tower- Despite having changing terrain and walk-offs in the first phase, the stage itself follows a set pattern and has no major hazards. I would consider it a counterpick.
Corneria- Banned due to extreme hazards, promotes camping, and large size.
Mute City- Banned for track that damages upon contact and interchanging F-Zero machines.
Arena Ferox- Counterpick due to random platform changes and some forms promoting camping and blocking projectiles.
Tortimer Island- Banned due to random layout each time and the shark. It may end up becoming a counterpick due to its mostly simple nature, but chances are low.
Dream Land- Banned due to scrolling, random terrain changes, walk-offs, blind spots on the edges of the stage, and promotion of camping in some sections.
Reset Bomb Forest- Banned due to breakable parts, promotion of camping, and extreme hazards during the second half.
WarioWare Inc.- Banned due to extreme hazards and having a distracting element.
Distant Planet- Banned for extreme hazards and walk-off to the left of the stage.
Boxing Ring- Banned due to falling lights and walk-offs.
Magicant- Banned for Flying Men and random platform appearances.
Living Room- Banned due to falling blocks, random platform changes, and walk-offs.
Tomodachi Life- Banned due to blind spots and large amount of platforms.
Pictochat 2- Banned due to extreme hazards and random platform changes.
Find Mii- Banned due to the Dark Emperor and swinging cage.
Balloon Fight- Banned due to random layout each time, "walk-offs", and extreme hazards.
Flat Zone 2- Banned due to random terrain changes and extreme hazards.
Gaur Plains- Banned due to massive size and walk-offs.
Wily Castle- Banned for Yellow Devil and random platform appearances.
Green Hill Zone- Banned for checkpoints, collapsing ground, slope, and walk-offs.
Pac-Maze- Banned for Ghosts, solid platform in the middle of the stage, and having a distracting element.
Omega Forms- All are starters, but be aware that some may be slightly different.
 
Peri Peri said:
GalacticPetey said:
GalacticPetey said:
Counter-Pick: Tomodachi Life
I'm not so sure of a stage that has blind spots and really big blast zones.
All the stages in this game have larger than average blast zones. In addition, blind spots only appear if a character is not there so that won't be an issue. Items aren't on so nothing will be hidden in there.
 
Starter:
Battlefield
Final Destination
Omega Stages

Counterpick:
Yoshi's Island
Prism Tower
Arena Ferox
Tomadachi Life(?)

Banned:
Everything else

Those are my thoughts.
 
GalacticPetey said:
Peri Peri said:
GalacticPetey said:
GalacticPetey said:
Counter-Pick: Tomodachi Life
I'm not so sure of a stage that has blind spots and really big blast zones.
All the stages in this game have larger than average blast zones. In addition, blind spots only appear if a character is not there so that won't be an issue. Items aren't on so nothing will be hidden in there.
The blast lines are still big for a 3DS stage, and projectiles can travel unnoticed in the apartments.
 
Peri Peri said:
GalacticPetey said:
GalacticPetey said:
Counter-Pick: Tomodachi Life
I'm not so sure of a stage that has blind spots and really big blast zones.
Tortimer Island is the one with the REALLY far away blast lines.

Which is why I really dislike that stage.
 
Dr. Mario said:
Peri Peri said:
GalacticPetey said:
GalacticPetey said:
Counter-Pick: Tomodachi Life
I'm not so sure of a stage that has blind spots and really big blast zones.
Tortimer Island is the one with the REALLY far away blast lines.

Which is why I really dislike that stage.
I don't necessary dislike the stage, but it really makes it annoying to play on at times, especially in All-Star Mode.

EDIT: 7000 posts!
 
Lumastar said:
EDIT: 7000 posts!
hoopla

another user has more posts than me despite me being here longer
but it may be the other way around
i may of been here less time
 
Lumastar said:
Dr. Mario said:
Peri Peri said:
GalacticPetey said:
GalacticPetey said:
Counter-Pick: Tomodachi Life
I'm not so sure of a stage that has blind spots and really big blast zones.
Tortimer Island is the one with the REALLY far away blast lines.

Which is why I really dislike that stage.
I don't necessary dislike the stage, but it really makes it annoying to play on at times, especially in All-Star Mode.

EDIT: 7000 posts!

Ha, I still have 400 to go.
 
Stargazing said:
Lumastar said:
EDIT: 7000 posts!
hoopla

another user has more posts than me despite me being here longer
but it may be the other way around
i may of been here less time

He joined after me... and I don't even have 3000 posts...
 
Marth said:
Starter:
Battlefield
Final Destination (Includes Omega variants)
Yoshi's Island

Counterpick:
Prism Tower
Arena Ferox
Tomadachi Life(?)

Banned:
Everything else
changed to represent how I feel.

not that it really matters, one will be made eventually and I'm sure at least four of the stages there will be legal.
 
Claus said:
Ichabod Crane said:
They shouldn't ban any stages

I agree. That's like saying certain characters should be banned.
They will for tournaments though, that's the thing. It's because of luck based elements.
 
GalacticPetey said:
Claus said:
Ichabod Crane said:
They shouldn't ban any stages

I agree. That's like saying certain characters should be banned.
Grand finals of tournaments with thousands of dollars on the line shouldn't come down to random stage hazards.

Okay. Well, if they want it for tournaments, so be it. I do remember Sakurai, when talking about the balance of characters, wanted it to be unique, not a sport.
 
Which is really just a stereotype of the competitive community. It's not all about fox only, no items, final destination. The community wants platforms.

Battlefield is a much more neutral stage than FD. Maybe in the future he can make "alpha" versions of the stages.
 
Back