Re: Zelda (Wii U)
No-Face said:
i don't get why people didn't like skyward sword so much
i thought it was still enjoyable, for the most part
Probably the motion controls.
If there's some sort of control gimmick, I find that it usually works best when it's just there to enhance the gameplay without eclipsing classic button and stick controls. Super Mario Galaxy is a good example. The game makes some good use of Wiimote technology with the whole pointing at starbits thing, but you still play the actual game normally.
Button control takes advantage of the amazing ability of the human mind to view an abstract tool as an extension of the body. After a while you stop noticing that you're holding a gamepad or whatever, and you become completely immersed in the control scheme. Your brain thinks "Jump!", instead of "I need to press the A button to jump".
Technology has not yet advanced enough however to achieve the same effect with motion control swordplay. You don't get the same feedback from your wiimote that you get while holding a real sword. If you hit something with a sword, you will feel the recoil. The wiimote obviously cannot replicate that effect. Your mind picks up on the dissonance between what's happening on screen and what's happening in your hand, and that dissonance will make it feel fake.
I guess it is comparable to the uncanny valley effect, except here it's more of a fakeness valley. Button controls are abstract enough that we don't need to actively compare them to what's happening on screen. However, the closer we get to replicating the motion on screen with the movements we do ourselves, and the more "realistic" this becomes, the more we feel inclined to compare, and the more fake it starts to feel.
One day, when technology has advanced so far that holding and swinging a controller feels exactly like using a sword, these issues will disappear and there will be truly immersive motion controls.
But we aren't there yet, so motion controls still suck.