Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition - STATUS: POSTPONED UNTIL POKEMON IS FUN

Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

It was good, I enjoyed it. (I especially enjoyed your characterization- you nailed everyone else's too, surprisingly. Kudos.)

On the other hand, something just occured to me about the Pokemon universe.

If beating Gym leaders is so common, why are they gym leaders? Like, you'd think after they get smacked around by a few new kids somebody would think to get a better replacement for them.
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

Jack English said:
It was good, I enjoyed it. (I especially enjoyed your characterization- you nailed everyone else's too, surprisingly. Kudos.)
I thought about adding some character development via reveals but decided it was too early, it just wouldn't work yet.

Don't worry, we actually will get around to hearing Javelin's story! It's not quite as obvious as it seems.
Jack English said:
On the other hand, something just occured to me about the Pokemon universe.

If beating Gym leaders is so common, why are they gym leaders? Like, you'd think after they get smacked around by a few new kids somebody would think to get a better replacement for them.
I actually plan on expanding on a theory I heard about that. Someone somewhere in the vast world of internet had the idea that the Gym Leaders actually have a whole slew of Pokemon, and they pick ones that makes the battle fair to accurately test the challengers. Which explains why when you face the Gym Leaders a second time in Pokemon Emerald, they have tons of evolved Pokemon and stuff. It's not like that's all they have - it would be impossible for newbie trainers to win if that was the case. Rather, they use Pokemon that are kinda close to the challengers' in level.

So what I'm saying is that the Javelin vs Cilan (Javelin started with Water, remember) and Walkazo vs Cress (because of her Cyndaquil) battles aren't going to be complete wipeouts.
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

Nifty theory.

Also, just because the heroes and rivals always get their badges doesn't mean everyone does. In the anime and manga, plenty of random background characters lose to the Gym Leaders.


Anyway, I figured the story was dead, so even if it this chapter was short, it was a more-than-welcome surprise. One caveat: "your old pal the president" sounds very scripted and unnatural, just have them say "the president". I'm interested to find out what the real story behind Javelin is: like you implied, him being Red would be too obvious (and a wee bit Sueish).
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

Funny, I was just wondering about this story today.

Nice nod to the change in Gen V with the reusable TMs. I always wondered though, how exactly would they work in the anime/this story. How do you use them?
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

It's...

CHAPTER 4?!

This suddenly motivates me to somehow get rid of this superglue on my ass and do another episode of TPR.

Great chapter, btw.
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

Walkazo said:
Nifty theory.

Also, just because the heroes and rivals always get their badges doesn't mean everyone does. In the anime and manga, plenty of random background characters lose to the Gym Leaders.
Yeah, but they always face them again, don't they? It never impedes the progress of the story for long.

Although that is a good point, perhaps I should make it so someone loses and eventually has to come back and finish the challenges...
Walkazo said:
Anyway, I figured the story was dead, so even if it this chapter was short, it was a more-than-welcome surprise.
One word: school.
Walkazo said:
One caveat: "your old pal the president" sounds very scripted and unnatural, just have them say "the president".
I was kinda of going for the angle that the Silph Co. president is a bit of a old duffer, so having him use weird phrasing is part of his character.
Walkazo said:
I'm interested to find out what the real story behind Javelin is: like you implied, him being Red would be too obvious (and a wee bit Sueish).
I'm not planning on spoiling any of that. >_>
GalacticPetey said:
Funny, I was just wondering about this story today.

Nice nod to the change in Gen V with the reusable TMs. I always wondered though, how exactly would they work in the anime/this story. How do you use them?
In FireRed/LeafGreen, it looks like you place the TM on the Pokemon's head and then it spins and they absorb the knowledge or something. That's how I was planning on using it.

If I get a cooler/more practical idea though then I'll probably use that.
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 3 released!

Dr. Javelin said:
Walkazo said:
Anyway, I figured the story was dead, so even if it this chapter was short, it was a more-than-welcome surprise.
One word: school.
Say no more.

Dr. Javelin said:
Walkazo said:
I'm interested to find out what the real story behind Javelin is: like you implied, him being Red would be too obvious (and a wee bit Sueish).
I'm not planning on spoiling any of that. >_>
Wouldn't want you to! Just voicing my interest, is all.
 
Re: Pokémon Black and White: Wiki Edition: Chapter 4 :O

Alright, I've got the Javelin vs Cilan battle done. Would you guys rather see that as a standalone chapter or back to back with Walkazo's Gym challenge? It's longer than the last chapter but not too long.