Yeah, discussing it is always better than trying to come out of nowhere and steamroll over a page. However, doing anything to the "Super Mario" series page would have repercussions on almost every single History section across the wiki, so a Talk Page Proposal would not be a good move. It would be better to do it with a real Proposal, or continue the discussion here until some of the points of conflict can be resolved and then making a more focused Proposal later.
And now I shall make a long post about how I view the "Super Mario" organization and why. But first, I shall include a preemptive
tl:dnr (there's also a chart at the bottom showing how I do the History sections):
-
Don't split up the "Super Mario" sub-series. - It'll screw up History sections and Nintendo has officially acknowledged this grouping of games in its official "Super Mario History" booklet.
-
SM3DL is a unique entry in the "Super Mario" sub-series. - It's nothing like the old
SML games, and while it's 3D, it's structured more like the 2D
NSMB games than
SM64 et al.
-
The SML games aren't part of the "Super Mario" sub-series. - The first one is SMB-ish, but
SML2 is totally different and the series morphs into the
Wario Land series before long, plus. Nintendo left the games out of the "Super Mario History" booklet.
-
SMW2:YI is not part of the "Super Mario" sub-series. - It's totally different than the other "Super Mario" games, it has the Yoshi egg in its title like all other "Yoshi" games, including two released before
SMW2:YI, and it wasn't included in the "Super Mario History" booklet.
-
The G&W SMB is a remake and should not be listed as a "Main game" in the "Super Mario (series)" page, nor given separate sections in article Histories - It has new levels, but the plot is the same, and the same goes for the various other
SMB remakes.
Anyway, as I explained here (
Talk:Main_Page#New_Super_Mario_Bros._series), I really don't think splitting up the "Super Mario" series is a good idea. These games are the backbone of the overall
Mario series (i.e. all the games that aren't crossovers,
Yoshi,
Wario or
Donkey Kong games), and even Nintendo recognized them with the timeline included in the
SMASLE "Super Mario History" booklet
(which included SMB1-3 and LL; SMAS; SMA1, 2 & 4; SM64 and -DS; SMS; SMG1 & 2; SMB Deluxe; NSMB and -Wii; and "Classic NES Series: SMB"). Splitting the series up will just send the more recent groupings of games down to the bottom of History sections, far away from the classic
SMB games and buried below all the random games and sub-series. No, they should be kept together and left at the tops of the Histories.
What's more, it's not actually a clean break between the different breeds of "Super Mario" games. Calling things "classic" is speculative, but putting
SMW in an "SMB" grouping would look weird, and while it's not a "NSMB" title,
SM3DL has way more in common with them than the actual 3D sidescrollers, so lumping it in with either group would be wrong. (It would also be wrong to add it to the
Super Mario Land series, because it has nothing in common with those games: as was mentioned earlier, the name is a homage, nothing more.) But we don't want either of these titles as stand-alones, because they're not: they're "Super Mario" titles, and classifying them and all the "Super Mario X" titles is the most efficient and logical thing to do.
That being said, not everything with "Super Mario" in the name
should go in this central series. Random things like
Super Mario Bros. & Friends: When I Grow Up,
Super Mario Bros. Print World and
Super Mario Sweater (I Am a Teacher: Super Mario Sweater ) have nothing in common with the sidescrollers, nor do the [wiki=Super Mario Fushigi no Janjan Land]
Super Mario Fushigi games[/wiki],
Super Mario Strikers or
Super Mario Kart. So... What about
Super Mario Land? Nintendo doesn't count is as part of the
Super Mario series, seeing as it wasn't in the aforementioned
SMASLE booklet. As for whether
we should think outside the box and include it or not... Well, the original
SML was admittedly similar to the classic
SMB games of the era: it was effectively the Game Boy counterpart to the NES games. But it
did have different characters, enemies, setting and even a unique power up,
SML2 totally went of in its own unique direction, and by the time we got to
SML3, the sub-series had morphed into
Wario Land and was the start of a whole new series. With all this in mind, I generally view the
SML games as branching off from the core
Super Mario series, with that branch turning into the
Wario series (rather than that being a new branching point off the
SML sub-series, although for organization's sake, the
WL titles get their own grouping separate from their
SML ancestors).
As for the
SMW2:YI, as was mentioned earlier, the connection with
SMW wasn't there in the original Japanese (which also gave
SMW a "SMB4" subtitle), so that weakens the connection. And, like the
SML series, neither
SMW2:YI or
YI:SMA3 were included in the
SMASLE "Super Mario History" booklet. But what seals the deal for me is that every single "Yoshi" game has a Yoshi egg instead of the "O" in their titles, which links them all together (the exception being
Yoshi's Safari, which I don't consider a
Yoshi series game anyway, given its thoroughly unique premise and gameplay). Plus, the first game to do this egg logo thing was [wiki=Yoshi (game)]The game
Yoshi[/wiki], and both it and the similarly egg-emblazoned
Yoshi's Cookie were released before
SMW2:YI. So,
Yoshi's Island isn't technically the first "Yoshi" series game, and between that, the egg logo, the omission from the
SMASLE booklet, and the fact that the story and gameplay are completely different than the regular "Super Mario" games, I think there's more than enough solid evidence to say, no, this game is not part of the
Super Mario series.
And finally, there's the issue of the G&W
SMB game. It's not a port, because of the differences in level design, but I'll argue that it's still a remake because the plot is the same. Same with
Vs. Super Mario Bros. and even
Super Mario Bros. Special, which even changes up the gameplay physics and adds new enemies, as well as
All Night Nippon Super Mario Bros, which makes lots of superficial changes yet leaves the gameplay and levels intact. If the G&W game gets promoted to the main roster, at the very least
VSMB and
SMBS need to be as well, but that's getting excessive: after all, none of these remakes need their own headers in the History sections, not when they're all just
SMB again, only with a few little changes.
I use this chart (
User:Walkazo/Essays#Timeline) to help me put Histories in the correct order (I'm hoping to use it in a Writing Guideline about how to organize articles, assuming I can find the time to write the draft before school starts); the groupings for the "Super Mario", "SML", "Wario Land" and "Yoshi" sub-series in particular are listed below. Brackets indicate "notable" remakes, ports and compilations (i.e.
SM64DS, the "Advance" games and
SMAS are included, but not things that don't really change at all from version to version, like
2-in-1 SMB/Duck Hunt, the
SMB demo in
SSBB, or straight ports, like to the Virtual Console); these usually wouldn't get their own History sections, except for some things that are drastically different from the original (mostly
SM64DS and sometimes
SMA stuff), or instances where something
only appeared in the later version.
Super Mario series
Super Mario Bros. - Sept. 13, 1985
(Super Mario Bros. Special) - 1986
(Vs. Super Mario Bros.) - 1986
(All Night Nippon Super Mario Bros.) - 1986
(Super Mario Bros. (G&W game)) - Aug. 19, 1987
(Super Mario Bros. Deluxe) - May, 1999
Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels - June 3, 1986
Super Mario Bros. 2 - Sept. 1, 1988
(Super Mario Advance) - March 21, 2001
Super Mario Bros. 3 - Oct. 23, 1988
(Super Mario Advance 4: Super Mario Bros. 3) - July 11, 2003
Super Mario World - Nov. 21, 1990
(Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2) - Dec. 2001
(Super Mario All-Stars) - July 14, 1993
(Super Mario All-Stars Limited Edition) - Oct. 21, 2010
BS Super Mario USA - March 31, 1996 (ends April 21, 1996)
Super Mario 64 - June 23, 1996
(Super Mario 64 DS) - Nov. 21, 2004
Super Mario Sunshine - July 19, 2002
New Super Mario Bros. - May 15, 2006
Super Mario Galaxy - Nov. 1, 2007
New Super Mario Bros. Wii - Nov. 12, 2009
Super Mario Galaxy 2 - May 23, 2010
Super Mario 3D Land - Nov. 3, 2011
New Super Mario Bros. 2 - July 28, 2012
New Super Mario Bros. U - TBA (Nov/Dec 2012) (UPCOMING)
Super Mario Land series
Super Mario Land - April 21, 1989
Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins - Oct. 21, 1992
Wario Land series
Wario Land: Super Mario Land 3 - Jan. 21, 1994
Virtual Boy Wario Land - Nov. 1995
Wario Land II - March 28, 1998
Wario Land 3 - March 21, 2000
Wario Land 4 - Aug. 21, 2001
Wario Land: Shake It! - July 24, 2008
Yoshi series
Yoshi - Dec. 4, 1991
Yoshi's Cookie - Nov. 21, 1992
Yoshi no Cookie: Kuruppon Oven de Cookie - 1994
Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island - Aug. 15, 1995
(Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3) - Sept. 20, 2002
Yoshi's Story - Dec. 21, 1997
Yoshi Topsy-Turvy - Dec. 9, 2004
Yoshi Touch & Go - Jan. 27, 2005
Yoshi's Island DS - Nov. 13, 2006
Yoshi's Safari - July 14, 1993