SMG vs SMG2

Which one is better, the original or the sequel?

  • Super Mario Galaxy

    Votes: 8 42.1%

  • Super Mario Galaxy 2

    Votes: 11 57.9%
  • Total voters
    19
Nabber

Nabber

Artisanal Cheese Taster
The games are actually more different than you may think. Which one did you like better?
 
Like I said another thread, they're both some of the best Mario games ever. SMG was better visually and plotwise and SMG2 was more nostalgic and fun.
 
Re: SMG vs SM2

Boidoh said:
I swear you only made this because everyone was arguing about this on my page i made. Im gonna go with galaxy because well the Hub seems bigger. And SMG2 looks like a great game but the only real upgrade is yoshi.
Click to expand...
Your reasoning is because the hub was bigger? The hub does matter but it's not the biggest influence.
Also, I thought you said you haven't played them?
 
Re: SMG vs SM2

GLaDOS said:
Boidoh said:
I swear you only made this because everyone was arguing about this on my page i made. Im gonna go with galaxy because well the Hub seems bigger. And SMG2 looks like a great game but the only real upgrade is yoshi.
Click to expand...
Your reasoning is because the hub was bigger? The hub does matter but it's not the biggest influence.
Also, I thought you said you haven't played them?
Click to expand...

Im going by videos. Plus thats just one of the factors.
 
Both were great, but the first seemed more of an open adventure, while the second was more linear and gave us that annoying purple guy.
 
Boidoh said:
GLaDOS said:
That's not a very good way to judge games.
Click to expand...

By videos or by hub?
Click to expand...

Probably videos. Not really a good idea to judge games you haven't played :P

Also, SMG2. But only by a little.