SMG vs SMG2

[Nabber]

The games are actually more different than you may think. Which one did you like better?

 

[Boidoh]

Re: SMG vs SM2

I swear you only made this because everyone was arguing about this on my page i made. Im gonna go with galaxy because well the Hub seems bigger. And SMG2 looks like a great game but the only real upgrade is yoshi.

 

[GalacticPetey]

Like I said another thread, they're both some of the best Mario games ever. SMG was better visually and plotwise and SMG2 was more nostalgic and fun.

 

[Nabber]

Re: SMG vs SM2

I swear you only made this because everyone was arguing about this on my page i made. Im gonna go with galaxy because well the Hub seems bigger. And SMG2 looks like a great game but the only real upgrade is yoshi.

Your reasoning is because the hub was bigger? The hub does matter but it's not the biggest influence.
Also, I thought you said you haven't played them?

 

[Boidoh]

Re: SMG vs SM2

I swear you only made this because everyone was arguing about this on my page i made. Im gonna go with galaxy because well the Hub seems bigger. And SMG2 looks like a great game but the only real upgrade is yoshi.

Your reasoning is because the hub was bigger? The hub does matter but it's not the biggest influence.
Also, I thought you said you haven't played them?

Im going by videos. Plus thats just one of the factors.

 

[Nabber]

That's not a very good way to judge games.

 

[Boidoh]

That's not a very good way to judge games.

By videos or by hub? As i said before thats just one of the factors.. You want more? Anyways i just didnt see much of an upgrade in galaxy 2. Though it look cools with the throwbacks like to SM64, SMS, SMG1. And SMG1 looks more original.

 

[Snowstalker]

Both were great, but the first seemed more of an open adventure, while the second was more linear and gave us that annoying purple guy.

 

[Smasher]

That's not a very good way to judge games.

By videos or by hub?

Probably videos. Not really a good idea to judge games you haven't played :P

Also, SMG2. But only by a little.

 

[Boidoh]

Well I always like SMG1 more.

 

[Toad85]

I did a review of SMG2. I gave it a 7.6

I did a mini-review of SMG1. I gave it a 9.6

 

[YoshiGo99]

SMG2's missions were short and boring

 

[KoopaTroopa]

Hard to say, but

Spoiler

Galaxy 2, because of Yoshi, and it is a pain to find those last few Power Stars before you unlock the final battle.

 

[MnSG]

They're both equally good for my tastes.

 

[Ray Trace]

Super Mario Galaxy for me.

Super Mario Galaxy had that wow factor in it and the innovative gravity (for a Mario game anyway). Super Mario Galaxy 2....lacked it (the wow factor anyway) and it had my least favorite character as a powerup. Ugh.

 

[Mario4Ever]

I'll go with BLOF and say that SMG2 lacked the "wow" factor that SMG1 had, but I had more fun with the sequel and was actually motivated to complete it 100%. The original is more of an afterthought to me now (SMG2 could pretty much be a standalone game as far as I'm concerned).

 

[John Doe]

Hmmm. That's a difficult choice. I liked both. I'm more thinking SMG2, as it seems more fun in level design.

 

[Raven Effect]

Both were great, but the first seemed more of an open adventure, while the second was more linear and gave us that annoying purple guy.

Damn it now i want to change my vote cause you reminded me of my intense hatred for that purple guy

 

[Dry-Petey]

Super Mario Galaxy 2 was played more recently by me, and since it was played in the giant pile of video games I got for christmas (only 4) then I might like it more. I really don't know, but maybe I do like SMG2 better, and I'm just afraid to admit it to myself.

Don't feel lke reading that^ SMG2

 

[Boidoh]

There should really be a both option. Because i now decided both are really good games with different things that make them good.

 

[Mijzelffan]

Definitely the first one.

 

[NSY]

I like them both nut I have to say SMG2 just because of Yoshi.

 

[yoshidude99]

SMG2 because it had Yoshi and I got it before SMG so it gave me the wow

 

[Nabber]

I like how people chose SMG2 just because of Yoshi. I bet you would pick it even if it was horrible.

 

[SiFi]

I like how people hate on SMG2 just because of Yoshi. I bet you would pick on him even if the game was spectacular.