What is your favourite 2D platformer in the Mario series?

[Leonyx]

I said "think". Superstar Saga isn't a 2D platformer, and I inculded Other in case there was a CDi or MOS game or something I was missing.

That depends on what you consider a 2D platformer. Since you didn't describe it in your original post, it's up to the voter to determine what that means.

Superstar Saga is nothing to do with a 2D Platformer, the adventure is even 3D.

There are plenty of parts in the game that are done in a 2D view (I believe). It's somewhat similar to Kirby 64, as that game was in a 3D view, but was a 2D platformer.

 

[WaluigiWare]

Superstar Saga isn't a platformer though. It's an RPG. The RPG aspect is its main focus.

 

[NSY]

Superstar Saga isn't a platformer though. It's an RPG. The RPG aspect is its main focus.

Yeah, why did someone say that.

 

[Smashgoom202]

Well I'd say it'd have to be Super Mario Bros. 3... New Super Mario Bros. Wii comes close, but doesn't quite have the charm and effect o of Super Mario Bros. 3... But it's still a really close second.

 

[User 101]

I actually think SMB3 would be nice if I had a NES.

 

[Smashgoom202]

I played the Super Mario All-Stars version more. I think I only played the NES version once, at my friend's house.

 

[New Super Mario]

New Super Mario Bros. Wii

I voted that, considering it's my favorite video game

 

[User 101]

If you put it that way, SM64DS. I'm still working at it, has more detailed levels, plus more unlockables. Plus NSMB got all it's minigames from Super Mario 64 DS.

 

[Mariorules25]

New Super Mario Bros. Wii

I voted that, considering it's my favorite video game

I voted it aswell

 

[User 101]

Oops I guess that's 3D. Ok then NSMB.

 

[NSY]

Oops I guess that's 3D. Ok then NSMB.

I don't get why some people like NSMB more than NSMBW.

 

[Ray Trace]

Probably because it has the Blue Shell

 

[Toad Eightyfive]

Probably because it has the Blue Shell

Yes, I liked the Blue Shell, but NSMBW had the Penguin Suit. I liked NSMB better (in fact, best), because it had great level design, good graphics, and astounding gameplay.

 

[Ray Trace]

The only reason I choose New Super Mario Bros. Wii over New Super Mario Bros. is the multiplayer. Or any 2D platformer for that matter.