Take This, Drop This

[Time Turner]

Take iPad, drop iPod
iPad|Cow

You took iPad, so that leaves, and iPod stays. Then you drop something else, and that replaces iPad.

 

[-----]

When you take something it's not in the new choice. Whatever you drop is added to whatever was not chosen. In other words: Pick something to go against the iPod. A.K.A Drop It.

EDIT: NVM Reversinator explained it.

Let's start anew.

Money | Mr. Krabs

 

[Time Turner]

Take Money, Drop Clarinet

Clarinet | Mr. Krabs

 

[-----]

Take Mr. Krabs, Drop Squidward

Clarinet | Squidward

 

[Toad Eightyfive]

Take Squidward, drop Oboe.

Clarinet|Oboe

 

[-----]

Take Oboe, Drop

| Clarinet

 

[Time Turner]

Take Yoshi, drop Clarinet

Clarinet | Reed

 

[Smashley]

agjdagfsag

close enough

Take Clarinet, drop cat

Reed | Cat

(you drop the new item, not the one not chosen. other than that you got it right)

 

[Mario Super Sluggers]

Take both, drop Mario Super Sluggers and Wii Sports Resort.

Take Cat, drop Piano.

 

[Smashley]

(assuming that you meant to put Piano | Reed) Take Piano, drop Vase

Vase | Reed

 

[-----]

Take Reed, Drop

| Vase

 

[Gigaremo]

Take CD, Drop DVD.

CD|CD-R

Take iPad, drop iPod
iPad|Cow

You took iPad, so that leaves, and iPod stays. Then you drop something else, and that replaces iPad.

These two quotes contradict each other. I think the whole first page breaks this rule...
I'm very confused. I won't answer vs. Vase until I figure out what's going on...