Take This, Drop This

[Time Turner]

Take iPad, drop iPod
iPad|Cow

You took iPad, so that leaves, and iPod stays. Then you drop something else, and that replaces iPad.

 

[-----]

When you take something it's not in the new choice. Whatever you drop is added to whatever was not chosen. In other words: Pick something to go against the iPod. A.K.A Drop It.

EDIT: NVM Reversinator explained it.

Let's start anew.

Money | Mr. Krabs

 

[Time Turner]

Take Money, Drop Clarinet

Clarinet | Mr. Krabs

 

[-----]

Take Mr. Krabs, Drop Squidward

Clarinet | Squidward

 

[Toad Eightyfive]

Take Squidward, drop Oboe.

Clarinet|Oboe

 

[-----]

Take Oboe, Drop

| Clarinet

 

[Time Turner]

Take Yoshi, drop Clarinet

Clarinet | Reed

 

[Smashley]

agjdagfsag

close enough

Take Clarinet, drop cat

Reed | Cat

(you drop the new item, not the one not chosen. other than that you got it right)

 

[Mario Super Sluggers]

Take both, drop Mario Super Sluggers and Wii Sports Resort.

Take Cat, drop Piano.

 

[Smashley]

(assuming that you meant to put Piano | Reed) Take Piano, drop Vase

Vase | Reed

 

[-----]

Take Reed, Drop

| Vase

 

[Gigaremo]

Take CD, Drop DVD.

CD|CD-R

Take iPad, drop iPod
iPad|Cow

You took iPad, so that leaves, and iPod stays. Then you drop something else, and that replaces iPad.

These two quotes contradict each other. I think the whole first page breaks this rule...
I'm very confused. I won't answer vs. Vase until I figure out what's going on...

 

[NSY]

Take drop Sonic 1

Sonic 1/Vase

 

[Smashley]

Everyone on the first page misread it, but we got corrected. Most of the people playing have done it right since then.

Anyway, take Sonic, drop keyboard.

Keyboard | Vase

 

[NSY]

Take Keyboard drop Diddy Kong

Diddy Kong/Vase

 

[Time Turner]

Take Diddy Kong, Drop Cake

Cake | Vase

 

[Gigaremo]

Drop means a random item, not Dropping the other choice. JS. Here's one example: Random Guy 1: NES|SNES. Random Guy 2: Take NES, Drop Angry Birds, SNES|Angry Birds. What you do is add a random thing that was dropped, to join the thing not chosen last time, in this case, an SNES, and the case of the dropped thing, Angry Birds. Then you take one, and drop a RANDOM one. When you TAKE IT, it's NOT in the new selection. I really hope this fully explains it.

You guys are still playing it wrong, unless he changes the rules mid-thread.
So in this case it would be
Take Cake, drop Feather Pillow
Feather Pillow|Vase

 

[-----]

They were playing it right, mainly the ones around the 3-5th page. JS. Take Feather Pillow, Drop Camera

Camera | Vase

 

[Time Turner]

Take Vase, Drop Bat

Camera | Bat

 

[Smashley]

Take Bat, Drop Cheese

Camera | Cheese

 

[NSY]

Take Camera, drop Superman 64

Superman 64/Cheese

 

[Toad Eightyfive]

Take cheese, drop Sonic '06.

Superman 64|Sonic '06

 

[NSY]

Take Sonic 06, drop Super Monkey Ball

Superman 64/Super Monkey Ball

 

[Toad Eightyfive]

Take Super Monkey Ball, drop Panic Restaurant

Superman 64|Panic Restaurant

 

[PokemonMaster]

O_O
Take Panic Restaurant.

Chuchu. | Panic Restaurant.