Featured Articles

Not even three days and another nomination from the same user:
MarioWiki: Featured articles/N/Mario Party 4
And their reasonings aren't really that good tbh. I know it's hard to think of reasons other than "it's well-written and has a good amount of images" (I've been through it myself), but at least try to be more in-depth. I mean their reasonings aren't even longer than one sentence.
 
Huckit Crab as it stands currently has a lot of issues. The intro could definitely use expansion but most impertinently, the rest of the article looks rather sparse. A Huck-It Crab being defeated is practically like every enemy in the game, I'm not sure if it's necessary to list all methods players could kill it with (it's missing being able to throw projectiles into it like other frozen Huckit Crabs). The article also doesn't list where they appear in the level (I'm also mostly taking my criticisms using Bomber Bill as a standard on how these enemy articles should be, especially with rarer enemies like Huckit Crab. The history section also lacks images. Also the LEGO Mario parts need coverage.

FWD also talked about how the Mario Party section in his oppose is populated with sparse one-liners when it can be condensed into a Mario Party series section.

And tbh, if all of these issues are addressed, it wouldn't be a particularly long or impressive article, which is my biggest issue with it. It straddles the issues with length and if it can't comfortably pass the test, it shouldn't be featured.

Not even three days and another nomination from the same user:
MarioWiki: Featured articles/N/Mario Party 4

This article isn't ready yet. I've worked on it a long time ago, and I never finished it. Right off the bat, the intro and gameplay sections should use images and the reception section can be a little bit longer. Multimedia sections in this game articles should be repurposed to talk about the soundtrack tbh, rather than just a list of music tracks. The commercial part could also use an image.
 
Huckit Crab as it stands currently has a lot of issues. The intro could definitely use expansion but most impertinently, the rest of the article looks rather sparse. A Huck-It Crab being defeated is practically like every enemy in the game, I'm not sure if it's necessary to list all methods players could kill it with (it's missing being able to throw projectiles into it like other frozen Huckit Crabs). The article also doesn't list where they appear in the level (I'm also mostly taking my criticisms using Bomber Bill as a standard on how these enemy articles should be, especially with rarer enemies like Huckit Crab. The history section also lacks images. Also the LEGO Mario parts need coverage.

FWD also talked about how the Mario Party section in his oppose is populated with sparse one-liners when it can be condensed into a Mario Party series section.

And tbh, if all of these issues are addressed, it wouldn't be a particularly long or impressive article, which is my biggest issue with it. It straddles the issues with length and if it can't comfortably pass the test, it shouldn't be featured.



This article isn't ready yet. I've worked on it a long time ago, and I never finished it. Right off the bat, the intro and gameplay sections should use images and the reception section can be a little bit longer. Multimedia sections in this game articles should be repurposed to talk about the soundtrack tbh, rather than just a list of music tracks. The commercial part could also use an image.
I agree. The article is also missing a "pre-release and unused content" subarticle
 
I'm not sure if it's necessary to list all methods players could kill it with (it's missing being able to throw projectiles into it like other frozen Huckit Crabs).
It's probably necessary for consistency's sake. Some enemies are just randomly immune or resistant to some kinds of attacks. Admittedly, this is more of a Donkey Kong Country problem than a Super Mario problem, regarding how there's no real tell for "immune to Roll Attack" or "immune to Ground Pound", but they are both platformers. The History sections for platformer enemies should probably mostly fit together.
 
Back