Proposals

[Yoshi18]

This thread deals with proposals. Both normal and talk page proposals. If there are new proposals, failed ones, passed ones, votes, etc.; if it's Proposal-related, post it here.

Since this is a collaboration thread, you can also announce on what you are planning to propose, ask for feedback, or see if anyone wants to co-author with you.

If there is anything I missed, just post and I'll add whatever needs to be added.

 

[Yoshi18]

For anyone who hasn't realized it yet: this is basically just Featured Articles but for proposal. Am honestly surprised nobody made this thread earlier

 

[Yoshi18]

Last proposal of 2025 just ended! (And ironically it's mines which I needed to cancel)

https://www.mariowiki.com/Talk:Big_Cosmic_Clone#Merge_Small_and_Big_Cosmic_Clone

 

[Yoshi18]

New year, new proposal of mine!

MarioWiki:Proposals

If you would like to get feedback on an idea before formally proposing it here, you may do so on the proposals talk. For talk page proposals, you can discuss the changes on the talk page itself before creating the TPP there. If someone has an idea...

www.mariowiki.com

 

[Illuminoid]

Why does the wiki have both regular proposals and talk page proposals? Some talk page proposals could be proposals and vice-versa. The only major difference between the two, excluding the archives and {{TPP}}, is the fact that editors without an account can comment, and that is a rather odd difference. Furthermore, the ToDoList template on the Main Page shows the amount of ongoing talk page proposals, completely excluding regular proposals. Additionally, the ToDoList is inaccurate if a single talk page has multiple talk page proposals at a given time. Personally, I would have talk page proposals removed, leaving MarioWiki:Proposals as the only page to post proposals.