KO a Character: MLP Friendship is Magic Episodes (Seasons 1-9)

I remember this episode had some okay spectacle regarding the pet competition narrowly keeping me from outright disliking it but I remember finding it to be extremely predictable (gee, which pet will win, it's not like there's a 100% chance it'll be the turtle!) which I might have put aside more except it wasn't told compellingly enough to be good. I remember Mr. Enter thought this episode was awful which I disagree with but this is as far as it's going

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Winter Wrap Up
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Lesson Zero
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
May the Best Pet Win!
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
im at the point currently where the episodes are fine, but not much more than that. simply weaker than other episodes

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Winter Wrap Up
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Lesson Zero
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
I feel people will likely leave episodes like "Lesson Zero" and "Party of One" until the very end, so I'm going to make things interesting!

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Lesson Zero
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
Dang the first episode in my preferred S1-3 Top 5 was cut, especially when it was my favorite of those 5 eps and seemed like it had better chances of making it
In fairness I remember cutting The Perfect Pear before making the Top 5 for the Seasons 6/7 game despite it being #4 on the list just because most people would have had it win that game and I wanted something different to win

EDIT: I really liked Winter Wrap Up too, I can see how a person or two might see it as the song as overshadowing the rest of the episode but I found the rest of the episode to be pleasant as well. That one was a 9/10 for me so while I definitely wouldn't push for it to make the final round I would have kept it further but oh well.

Next up is TSSCS6000 because it is clunkily written that the Apple family is down to make a bet that ends up costing them Sweet Apple Acres if they lost.

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
The Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
Last edited:
lesson zero was my favorite episode of this batch lol rip. still too early to "make things interesting" personally, although i didnt know you liked winter wrap up that much lmao that's fully a 5/10 for me. maybe that's a hot take on my part

i got sniped on my cut again so i'm just going to finally pull the trigger on this one. some funny moments here but the moral leaves me with mixed feelings in the end

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Feeling Pinkie Keen
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
Sorry Smashley! I promise I'll keep Party of One around. I enjoyed Winter Wrap Up by the way!

To make it up to you, I'll remove one of my favorites, Read It and Weep. It's a fantastic and funny episode that introduces us to Derring Do. I apologize if this episode is also one of your favorites.

IMG_5410.png

(Daring Do's face after I remove her introductory episode)

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
Read It and Weep
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
you definitely didn't need to that, and...oh yeah no that episode is also great and would not have gotten sent out anytime soon. i'm just going to stick to cutting the episodes near the bottom of my list

and since i already got rid of the other funny episode that has other things going against it, i'll get rid of this one too. i remember loving this episode when i first watched but god it did NOT hold up super well

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Bridle Gossip
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
Sparks said:
To make it up to you, I'll remove one of my favorites, Read It and Weep. It's a fantastic and funny episode that introduces us to Derring Do.
Click to expand...
I should say as the thread's creator, while it's not a big deal, in general try to stay away from eliminating episodes based on a "these episodes are good/have fans so it's more interesting to eliminate them to shake things up" rationale. I know you were intending that move as one more of a one-time case but I'd prefer that an episode should be eliminated based on one preferring the other episodes left to it. It'd be different if there's an episode that you distinctly don't want to win, on its own standards, but are cutting it a bit earlier in the thread than you would otherwise to avoid the episode accelerating due to popularity reasons
Smashley said:
and since i already got rid of the other funny episode that has other things going against it, i'll get rid of this one too. i remember loving this episode when i first watched but god it did NOT hold up super well
Click to expand...
Wow if you were going to cut Cider 6000 next the move I cut it, that's uncanny as Bridle Gossip and Feeling Pinkie Keen were my two next intended cuts, even though in the reverse order from you.

I wouldn't have cut Read it and Weep anywhere near as soon, but I agree with Feeling Pinkie Keen having funny moments but a poor execution of its moral, even though that seems to be the universal consensus on the episode. Bridle Gossip is mixed for me too because while I found the Poison Joke gags to be funny and I liked that it introduced Zecora it's extremely awkward in its implications that the ponies distrust Zecora just because of how she looks as a zebra.

At this point I at least slightly like everything left, so I'll cut the episode where there are a lot of minor problems as well as not having as many moments of impact as anything else here so I still care about it less than anything else. I'm cutting the episodes with longer names recently lol

Friendship is Magic, part 1
Friendship is Magic, part 2
Griffon the Brush Off
Dragonshy
Swarm of the Century
Call of the Cutie
Fall Weather Friends
Suited For Success
Sonic Rainboom
A Dog and Pony Show
The Cutie Mark Chronicles
Party of One
The Best Night Ever
The Return of Harmony Part 1
The Return of Harmony Part 2
Luna Eclipsed
Sisterhooves Social
Sweet and Elite
Secret of My Excess
Hearth's Warming Eve
Family Appreciation Day
Hearts and Hooves Day
It's About Time
Hurricane Fluttershy
Ponyville Confidential
MMMystery on the Friendship Express
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 1
A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
The Crystal Empire - Part 1
The Crystal Empire - Part 2
Too Many Pinkie Pies
Magic Duel
Sleepless in Ponyville
Wonderbolts Academy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back