Hurt and Heal: Cartoon Episode Elimination Winners

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Since it’s been 3 years today since the elimination winners page was created, I’m gonna do something different and make a thread for cartoon episodes that have won in it. (I’m not sure whether Channel Chasers and It’s the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown count but I‘ll say no unless people disagree since Channel Chasers is Movie length and you could count Great Pumpkin as a short Peanuts special instead of a cartoon episode as well)

There’s a lot of ponies in here
Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 30
Flight to the Finish- 30
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 
Last edited:

Trab Pu Kcip

I'll just hang out in this vent.
It would help if we had some more cartoons, but...

Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 30
Flight to the Finish- 30
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 28
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
It would help if we had some more cartoons, but...
It’s just that not a lot of cartoon episodes have won yet.

Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 29 This is easily my least favorite of the remaining five due to the Mane Six not having to apologize for trying to use mind control to reform Discord and the moral being executed weakly with Fluttershy being a doormat and then just saying “I’m not your friend” like earlier episodes. While it might not be my least favorite episode of the show anymore compared to Somepony to Watch Over Me it needs to go as any of the other 4 would be better in my opinion by far
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 28
 
Last edited:

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Awards Committee
Former 'Shroom Staff
Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 29
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 27
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 23
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 11
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Trab Pu Kcip

I'll just hang out in this vent.
My vote went nowhere.

Party of One- 30
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 7
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Party of One- 29
The Last Roundup- 30
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 4
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Awards Committee
Former 'Shroom Staff
Party of One- 29
The Last Roundup- 28
Keep Calm and Flutter On- 4
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Yay, Keep Calm and Flutter On flutters out
Party of One- 29
The Last Roundup- 28
Keep Calm and Flutter On
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 
Last edited:

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Awards Committee
Former 'Shroom Staff
Party of One- 29
The Last Roundup- 24
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Linus van Pelt

Shadow Prince
Party of One- 29
The Last Roundup- 24
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
How much you’re hurting Last Roundup is interesting considering how in this thread you really wanted it to win.
To be fair Party of One is probably what I would have wanted to win out of these remaining four 4 years ago but looking back it still has some flaws. Flight to the Finish is probably what I want to win this round


Party of One- 28 Another episode that’s really good but with flaws as it looks like there could be a moral about Pinkie learning not to constantly invite everyone else to her parties, but the Mane 6 don’t teach her this lesson and agree to go to her third party
The Last Roundup- 21 While still really good like Party of One I feel like Flight to the Finish and Tales of Ba Sing Se top it out by a little bit

Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Awards Committee
Former 'Shroom Staff
yeah things change, i bingewatched the whole series last year and while i still like the episode i don't like it as much as i used to, and definitely would rank it below the other three here

Party of One- 28
The Last Roundup- 19
Flight to the Finish- 31
The Tales of Ba Sing Se- 30
 
Top