Best Mario incarnations

[Mcmadness]

which he is

Its as much Bowser as Dark Bowser is Bowser.

 

[Paper Mario]

Dark Bowser is a copy of Bowser

Rookie is Bowser himself with amnesia, but still Bowser

 

[Mcmadness]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

 

[Zae]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

But its still his body and everything, the only thing that changed was his memories.

Although if you want me to be honest this is a really stupid discussion.

 

[Paper Mario]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

He still breathes fire and throws freaking hammers like he did in SMB

 

[Shy Guy Forever]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

It's Bowser with Memory Loss. It's still technically Bowser.

 

[Mcmadness]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

But its still his body and everything, the only thing that changed was his memories.

Although if you want me to be honest this is a really stupid discussion.

You might as well say Bowletta is Bowser then.

 

[Zae]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

But its still his body and everything, the only thing that changed was his memories.

Although if you want me to be honest this is a really stupid discussion.

You might as well say Bowletta is Bowser then.

well it is bowser being possessed so

 

[Shy Guy Forever]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

But its still his body and everything, the only thing that changed was his memories.

Although if you want me to be honest this is a really stupid discussion.

You might as well say Bowletta is Bowser then.

Bowletta is partially Bowser. It's Bowser's body, after all.

But anyway, this thread is starting to go Off-Topic.

 

[yoshiking14x]

Spaghetti Luigi: you all eat spaghetti if you vote for me!

What character should I do next after the day is over?

Has any of you who replied here picked your Luigi?

 

[Mcmadness]

No, its not Bowser, its Rookie. Its him without anything that makes him who he is, thus its not him.

But its still his body and everything, the only thing that changed was his memories.

Although if you want me to be honest this is a really stupid discussion.

You might as well say Bowletta is Bowser then.

well it is bowser being possessed so

So its not him then.

 

[Zae]

you're hopeless.

If its still his body its still his existence, whether he be possed, or lost his memories, doesnt really matter.

Whatever takes bowser over or controls him, it remains to be a fact that bowser exists, his body is evident of that.

 

[Glitchy Bowser Jr.]

I like Luigi the way his now as the loveable coward.

EDIT: So, Mcmadness, if you got amnesia you wouldn't be you?

 

[Magikrazy]

I like Luigi the way his now as the loveable coward.

EDIT: So, Mcmadness, if you got amnesia you wouldn't be you?

no it wouldnt

 

[Mcmadness]

I like Luigi the way his now as the loveable coward.

EDIT: So, Mcmadness, if you got amnesia you wouldn't be you?

No, my memories and experiences define who I am, without that I'm a completely different person.

 

[yoshiking14x]

Re: Best Mario incarnations : Best Daisy

The winner is Current Luigi!
Next is who is the best Daisy.

 

[Magikrazy]

what about the n64 era clumsy daisy

 

[yoshiking14x]

I picked all, because Daisy was never really hate-able in all versions that currently exist, but I would love that Daisy gets more appearances in Mario games, spin-offs or not.

 

[TinTinfinite]

I liked all. Just her physical appearance.

 

[Glitchy Bowser Jr.]

I hate every Daisy.

SML Daisy: Peach clone
Current Daisy: Annoying
N64 Daisy: Peach clone

 

[Ray Trace]

Baby Daisy

 

[Paper Mario]

Can't stand Daisy. She used to be OK to me, but her fanbase ruined any shred of respect I had for her.

 

[Zae]

Honestly i like her quite a bit but her fanbase is very annoying.

 

[yoshiking14x]

Explain.

 

[Ray Trace]

I'm thinking they're giving Daisy more credit than she deserves and always want Daisy in Smash or something

Daisy DOES deserve to play big roles in more games, but at the moment, she's the Mario spin-off queen, nothing more, nothing less. Debates between her and Waluigi get very annoying.