Your Top 10 Most Wanted Newcomers

I don't care about the other 9, but... SHADOW IS ALMOST AS EPIC AS MR. L!!! SHADOW MUST APPEAR!!!
 
Mr. L rocks! said:
I don't care about the other 9, but... SHADOW IS ALMOST AS EPIC AS MR. L!!! SHADOW MUST APPEAR!!!
Click to expand...

you mean a black angry sonic?
 
Mr. L rocks! said:
I don't care about the other 9, but... SHADOW IS ALMOST AS EPIC AS MR. L!!! SHADOW MUST APPEAR!!!
Click to expand...

Sorry, but even as a Sonic fan myself. Shadow hasn't earned a spot in Smash Bros. He's not even the most deserving even if Sonic ever got a 2nd character. Which isn't likely.
 
I like Shadow, but Tails and Knuckles deserve it more than he does, and regardless I don't think any third party series should get more than one rep each.
 
Not sure if this has already been said but

1. Waluigi
2. Waluigi
3. Waluigi
4. Waluigi
5. Waluigi
6. Waluigi
7. Waluigi
8. Waluigi
9. Waluigi
10. Waluigi
 
Deku Link said:
1. Baby Mario [& Baby Luigi] (Yoshi)
2. Paper Mario (Mario)
3. Midna or Fi (Zelda)
>suggests fi but doesn't like the idea of ghirahim
4. Isaac (Golden Sun)
5. Alph (Pikmin)
6. Fire Emblem character (Fire Emblem)
>says "fire emblem character" because he's too stubborn to actually play the series
7. Another Metroid rep (Metroid)
8. Xerneas (Pokemon)
>ok, that'd actually be pretty awesome
9. Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
10. Mii
Click to expand...
 
New Super Mario said:
Deku Link said:
1. Baby Mario [& Baby Luigi] (Yoshi)
2. Paper Mario (Mario)
3. Midna or Fi (Zelda)
>suggests fi but doesn't like the idea of ghirahim
4. Isaac (Golden Sun)
5. Alph (Pikmin)
6. Fire Emblem character (Fire Emblem)
>says "fire emblem character" because he's too stubborn to actually play the series
7. Another Metroid rep (Metroid)
8. Xerneas (Pokemon)
>ok, that'd actually be pretty awesome
9. Dixie Kong (Donkey Kong)
10. Mii
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Deku Link said:
I like to try to be realistic about stuff like this, but I think I'll do a far-fetched list right now:
Click to expand...

Besides it's his list, not yours, of his most wanted newcomers.

btw, I was tempted to negatively respond to the guy who shouted Shadow because he was sorta asking for it
 
New Super Mario said:
lol, I just like giving bloops a hard time :P
Click to expand...

Who doesn't? Especially with "Baby Mario" combined with "Bloops" for a name